If you have a cluttered garage filled with tools, sports equipment, holiday decorations and other items, overhead garage storage could be the solution you need. Installing an overhead storage rack system allows you to get items up and off the floor.
This frees up valuable floor space and makes the garage feel bigger and more organized.
Two of the most popular overhead garage storage systems on the market are Topp Rax and SafeRacks. But which one is the better choice for your garage?
Here we’ll compare the pros and cons of Topp Rax and SafeRacks, so you can decide which system best fits your needs and budget.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Topp Rax | SafeRacks |
| Construction | Heavy duty steel | Heavy duty steel |
| Weight Capacity | 600 lbs per shelf | Up to 800 lbs per shelf |
| Installation | Pre-configured kits | Customizable system |
| Storage Options | Limited shelves and accessories | Wide selection of shelves, hooks, bins |
| Cost | $$ Pre-packaged deals | $-$$$ Flexible pricing |
| Visual Appeal | Uniform, matching components | Mix and match system |
| Warranty | 25 years | 10 years |
Key Takeaways:
- Topp Rax offers pre-configured garage storage systems that are quicker and easier to install. SafeRacks provides more customization and add-on options.
- Both brands make sturdy overhead racks rated for significant weight capacities. SafeRacks has higher shelves able to hold 800+ lbs.
- Topp Rax tends to cost less for a complete starter kit. SafeRacks allows you to buy only what you need now and expand later.
- SafeRacks provides far more storage accessories like bins, cabinets and bike lifts beyond basic shelves.
- Topp Rax has a longer 25 year warranty compared to 10 years for SafeRacks.
- Overall, Topp Rax is ideal if you value convenience and affordability. SafeRacks is better if customization and heavy-duty capacities are your top priority.
Overview of Topp Rax
Topp Rax has been manufacturing overhead garage storage solutions since 1999.
The company offers pre-configured rack systems in various sizes to fit one, two or three car garages.
The racks are made from heavy duty steel and can hold up to 600 pounds per shelf span.
Topp Rax uses a modular design, so you can easily expand your system in the future by adding more shelves and accessories.
The powder coated shelves have a lip around the edges help contain items and prevent them from sliding off. The mounting hardware is included for installation on ceiling joists up to 24 inches apart.
Pros of Topp Rax:
- Pre-configured systems designed specifically for garage use
- Heavy duty steel construction rated for 600 lbs per shelf
- Modular and expandable design
- Lip around shelves help contain items
- Includes mounting hardware
- 25 year manufacturer warranty
Cons of Topp Rax:
- Limited sizing options
- No overhead lift assist feature
- Expansion accessories sold separately
- Only available from a limited number of retailers
Overview of SafeRacks
SafeRacks is another popular brand of overhead garage storage racks. They offer a wider range of storage options than Topp Rax, with heavy duty systems rated up to 800 pounds per shelf.
SafeRacks uses a modular design so you can customize the shelving layout.
The selection includes steel wire shelves, heavy duty steel shelves, bike hooks, mesh bins and more. The QuickConnect system allows for tool-free assembly and easy expansion.
SafeRacks also offers an overhead lift assist bar to help you easily raise and lower items from storage.
Pros of SafeRacks:
- Wide range of shelving and accessory options
- Customizable modular design
- High weight capacities up to 800 lbs per shelf
- QuickConnect tool-free assembly
- Overhead lift assist available
- Sold at major retailers and via Amazon
Cons of SafeRacks:
- More complex to design and install yourself
- Not pre-configured specifically for garages
- Individual components may cost more than pre-packaged systems
Key Differences Between Topp Rax And SafeRacks Garage Storage Systems
- Weight Capacities
One of the main considerations when choosing an overhead garage storage system is the amount of weight it can handle. You don’t want overloaded shelves at risk of collapse.
Topp Rax has a weight capacity of 600 pounds per shelf span. This is suitable for heavy items like tools, auto parts, stacks of containers and more.
SafeRacks offers several shelving options rated for up to 800 pounds per span. This extra capacity provides flexibility if you have especially heavy storage needs.
Both brands offer systems sturdy enough for significant weight. Choose Topp Rax if you’ll be storing mostly lighter items or tools. Go with SafeRacks if you need the highest weight capacities to store heavy equipment or other substantial items up and out of the way.
- Ease of Installation
Installing overhead garage racks on your own can be a challenging DIY project. Topp Rax offers pre-configured systems designed specifically for standard garage dimensions.
This simplifies the measuring and layout process. SafeRacks systems allow for more customization but require you to plan the design yourself.
Both brands include mounting hardware to attach the racks to ceiling joists. SafeRacks uses a QuickConnect system for tool-free assembly of shelves and accessories. Topp Rax may require a bit more work to assemble and hang the components.
Consider going with Topp Rax if want a straightforward installation with a system pre-configured for your garage. SafeRacks is the better choice if you are comfortable designing and assembling the system yourself.
- Storage Options and Accessories
When comparing the product lines, SafeRacks provides far more choices for shelving types and optional accessories. With Topp Rax, you are limited to the specific system you purchase, along with a few add-on options.
SafeRacks gives you various shelf styles, bike lifts, storage bins, hooks and more. You can truly customize the system to suit your needs. Topp Rax offers open steel shelves, closed cabinets or a combination. Expanding your Topp Rax system later may require mixing components from different kits.
Go with Topp Rax for an affordable pre-packaged solution. SafeRacks is the better option if you value flexibility and a wide range of storage choices.
- Cost Considerations
On average, Topp Rax pre-configured storage racks cost less than similar size SafeRacks systems with comparable components. For example, the 48 inch wide Topp Rax 3-Bay Ceiling Storage Kit runs about $260.
A basic 3-bay SafeRacks system of the same width with two shelves costs around $420.
However, you have more room to scale back the spending with SafeRacks if desired. The wider selection allows you to start with just the essentials and add more later. You may be able to install a functional starter system for under $200.
Topp Rax is generally the more budget-friendly out of the box solution. But SafeRacks offers more flexibility to install an affordable minimal system now and build on it over time.
- Visual Appeal
An overhead garage storage system will be a focal point in your garage. So aesthetics may play a role in your decision. Topp Rax uses pre-configured sets with matching components and uniform shelves for a tidy, seamless appearance.
The broad range of SafeRacks products and mix-and-match approach can potentially look more piecemeal.
Both brands offer storage racks in similar neutral powder coated colors to fit with most garage decors. If a polished, all-in-one look is appealing, Topp Rax fits the bill. SafeRacks provides more versatility of layout and function, although possibly at the expense of aesthetics.
- Warranties
The warranty coverage provided by the manufacturer is important protection on your investment.
Topp Rax systems come with an impressive 25 year limited warranty.
This covers defects in materials and workmanship.
SafeRacks products have a 10 year limited warranty.
Both warranties become void if the systems are installed incorrectly or overloaded beyond rated capacities.
Topp Rax clearly stands out when it comes to long term peace of mind. Although SafeRacks still provides reasonable coverage against defects. Carefully review warranty terms during your buying decision process.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
For wall mounted storage, SafeRacks is the top choice. They offer an entire Wall Series line of brackets, baskets, cabinets and shelves designed for garage wall installation. The heavy duty steel and high weight capacities make these ideal for tool storage. SafeRacks wall components utilize the same QuickConnect system as the overhead racks for simple mounting.
As long as you install the storage racks properly and do not exceed the weight limits, overhead systems from brands like Topp Rax and SafeRacks are completely safe. Be sure to securely attach all components to joists or blocking that can support the weight. Never overload the shelves and perform periodic safety checks. With reasonable precautions, you can safely free up garage floor space with an overhead system.
SafeRacks offers several heavy duty overhead storage options rated for up to 800 pounds per shelf span. This includes the: SteelShelving, SteelShelving HD, Industrial Shelving, Steel Garage Shelving.
Other lighter duty SafeRacks components like wire shelves and plastic bins have lower weight capacities around 150-200 pounds per shelf. Check the product descriptions for the rated weight limits before purchasing and installing any storage items.
The Verdict
Topp Rax and SafeRacks both provide quality overhead garage storage systems. Topp Rax is best if you want an affordable, pre-configured system designed specifically for garages.
SafeRacks is the way to go if you need high capacities, expansive options and flexibility. Determine how much weight you need to support, your budget and the features that are important before picking the perfect system for your needs.
Investing in garage overhead storage yields valuable floor space and organization no matter which trusted brand you select.
