When shopping for bed sheets, Brooklinen and Bed Threads stand out as two popular and quality options. But how do you decide between them?
As a bedding enthusiast who has tested both brands extensively, I’m breaking down the key similarities and differences between Brooklinen and Bed Threads sheets. This overview includes a detailed comparison of materials, pricing, sizing, designs, special features, and more.
My goal? To provide an unbiased analysis so you can determine which brand offers the best sheets for your needs and budget. Let’s dive in!
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Brooklinen | Bed Threads |
| Materials | Luxe Sateen: 100% long staple cotton, 480 thread countLinen: 100% European flax linen Heathered Cashmere: Cashmere woven with cotton | French Flax Linen: 100% French flax linen Tencel Lyocell: Tencel from sustainable eucalyptus wood |
| Pricing | Luxe Sateen: $149 – $359 depending on size Linen: $149 – $349 depending on size Heathered Cashmere: $251 – $359 depending on size | $240 – $359 depending on size and material |
| Available Sizes | Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King | Plus Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King |
| Designs | 21 colors in solids and 20+ limited patterns | 9 solid, muted neutral colors |
| Special Features | Oeko-Tex certification for safe dyes 1-year return policy | Climate Neutral certified carbon neutral Sustainable manufacturing Lifetime guarantee |
Brooklinen Sheet Overview
Brooklinen launched in 2014 with a line of high-quality, direct-to-consumer sheets and bedding essentials. They quickly developed a strong following in the bedding space.
Here are some quick facts about their signature sheet offering:
- Materials:
- Luxe Sateen: 480 thread count long staple cotton with a smooth sateen weave
- Linen: 100% European flax linen
- Heathered Cashmere: Mongolian cashmere woven with cotton
- Pricing: $129 – $359 depending on size and material
- Sizes available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, California King
- Designs: Solid colors and patterns like stripes and plaids
- Special features: Oeko-Tex certification for safe dyes
Now let’s see how Bed Threads compares.
Bed Threads Sheet Overview
Australian brand Bed Threads launched in 2018, quickly emerging as a popular choice for eco-conscious luxury sheets.
Here is a high-level view of their sheet collection:
- Materials:
- French Flax Linen: 100% French flax linen
- Stonewashed Linen: pre-washed 100% French flax linen
- Tencel Lyocell: Tencel fibers from sustainable eucalyptus wood
- Pricing: $240 – $359 depending on size and material
- Sizes available: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Split King, California King, Split California King
- Designs: Solid muted neutral colors
- Special features: Climate Neutral certified carbon neutral brand
As you can see, Brooklinen and Bed Threads share some core similarities but also have some key differences that set them apart. Next, let’s do a deeper dive!
Detailed Sheet Comparison
Now that you know the product basics, let’s analyze how Brooklinen and Bed Threads sheets stack up across some key purchasing factors:
Quality and Materials
When it comes to sheet quality, both Brooklinen and Bed Threads offer top-tier options that outperform mass retailers. They focus on natural materials like cotton, linen, Tencel, and cashmere rather than synthetic microfibers.
That said, there are some variation across each of their material offerings:
Brooklinen Luxe Sateen
- 480 thread count long staple cotton
- Smooth, cool sateen weave that softens over time
- Recommended 2+ years of use before pilling
Bed Threads French Linen
- Stonewashed for extra softness
- Gets softer and better with age
- Wrinkles easily but doesn’t retain heat
Bed Threads Tencel Lyocell
- Made from sustainably harvested eucalyptus trees
- Extremely soft, smooth, and breathable
- Moisture wicking and temperature regulating
Brooklinen Heathered Cashmere
- Lightweight cashmere woven with cotton
- Luxurious softness and warmth
- Only available in select sizes
Based on materials alone, neither brand clearly outpaces the other. Brooklinen offers more affordable high quality cotton and lightweight cashmere. Bed Threads focuses specifically on luxury linen, responsibly made Tencel, and eco-friendly production.
Choose based on your preferred materials and priorities around sustainability.
Pricing
When it comes to sheet pricing, Bed Threads has a higher overall price point while Brooklinen aims to balance quality with approachable pricing.
Some key pricing differences:
Entry level queen sheets
- Brooklinen Luxe Sateen: $149
- Bed Threads Tencel Lyocell: $240
Premium queen sheets
- Brooklinen Heathered Cashmere: $359
- Bed Threads French Linen: $250
While Brooklinen’s sheet prices skew more budget-friendly, Bed Threads offers free shipping and returns to the US. So the actual cost difference evens out, especially if you live overseas.
Ultimately, Brooklinen sheets represent an exceptional value while Bed Threads prioritizes eco-friendly production. Choose based on your budget threshold and preference for responsibly made textiles.
Sizing
When it comes to sizing availability, Bed Threads pulls ahead by offering more niche size options beyond the standard range.
Brooklinen offers Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King sizes. This covers the basics for most customers.
Bed Threads takes it a step further with split sizes like Split King and Split California King.
These accommodate adjustable beds that allow couples to customize firmness preferences on each side.
If you have an unconventional mattress size, Bed Threads gives you more flexibility. But for standard mattresses, Brooklinen and Bed Threads both have you covered size-wise.
Design and Color Options
In terms of aesthetic design, Brooklinen caters to a wider variety of preferences with more colorways and patterns available.
Their core sateen cotton sheets come in versatile solids like white and cream alongside bolder hues like lilac and graphite green. They also offer playful limited-edition patterns featuring stripes, florals, and plaids.
By contrast, Bed Threads focuses on muted earth-inspired neutrals across their French linen and Tencel sheets. Think shades of white, stone, and sand for a natural, minimalist look.
Ultimately, this category comes down to personal style. Brooklinen offers more variety while Bed Threads keeps things simple and relaxed.
Special Features
When it comes to extra features, both brands incorporate special touches to enhance performance and sustainability. Here’s a quick look at standout features for each:
Brooklinen
- Made in ethical factories
- Oekotex certification for safe dyes
- Year-long return policy
Bed Threads
- Climate Neutral certified fully carbon neutral
- BCorp certification for sustainable business practices
- Lifetime guarantee against defects
So if responsible production is important to you, Bed Threads has an edge. But Brooklinen offers exceptional policies around returns and product quality as well.
Which Bedding Sheet To Pick?
Based on this detailed comparison, is Brooklinen or Bed Threads the better sheet brand overall?
While it’s impossible to declare one brand unanimously “superior”, here’s the lowdown based on common customer priorities:
Brooklinen wins for:
- More affordable everyday pricing
- Diverse color and pattern options
- Generous return policy period
Bed Threads wins for:
- Sustainable and ethical production
- Premium natural materials
- Lifetime quality guarantee
So if wanting high quality sheets and staying under budget is important for you, Brooklinen sheets make sense.
But if you highly prioritize responsible manufacturing — and don’t mind paying a bit more — Bed Threads takes the lead.
Either brand you choose, rest assured you’re getting exceptional quality sheets made to last. It comes down to personal priorities around design, pricing, and production ethics.
Now to cover some common questions to round out this sheet comparison guide!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Still trying to decide between Brooklinen and Bed Threads? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:
Brooklinen and Boll & Branch both sell luxury-quality sheets at approachable price points. So this one’s a close call!
In terms of materials, Boll & Branch sheets use long staple organic cotton while Brooklinen offers a mix of cotton, cashmere, and linen options.
For pricing, Boll & Branch starts around $200 for a Queen Set while Brooklinen Luxe Sateen comes in at $149 for a Queen.
Overall, Boll & Branch may edge out in terms of sustainable production methods. But Brooklinen beats them when it comes to affordable pricing for the everyday consumer. Both make exceptionally durable, comfortable sheets.
Many linen enthusiasts agree that French and Belgian linen offer the best quality globally.
Regions like Normandy in France as well as Belgium and the Netherlands have ideal cool climates to grow superior European flax. This results in durable, ultra-soft linen fiber.
Brands like Bed Threads source from established French linen mills to create world-class bed sheets. So if you’re looking for top-tier linen, French-sourced products deliver unmatched quality and craftsmanship.
While both Saatva and Brooklinen sell luxury bedding, Saatva is best known for mattresses whereas Brooklinen specializes in sheets and loungewear.
Saatva mattresses focus on advanced coil technology like individually wrapped coils for pressure relief and strong edge support. They use eco-friendly foams as well as organic cotton covers.
By contrast, Brooklinen sells shell-based mattress pads for extra cushioning instead of full mattress systems. Their strength lies more in their exceptional sheet quality and range of home textiles.
So Saatva excels at mattresses while Brooklinen dominates the high-end sheet game. But both are premium options for elevating your bedroom.
With proper care, Brooklinen sheets can last 5-10 years or beyond. Their Luxe Sateen cotton style even comes with an estimated “lifespan” of over 2 years before pilling may occur with regular use.
To maximize durability, Brooklinen recommends:
Washing sheets separately to avoid zippers damaging fibers
Machine washing cool on a gentle cycle
Line drying or tumble drying low to prevent shrinking
Avoiding bleach and fabric softeners when cleaning
Following these tips, you can expect many years of use from high quality Brooklinen sheets.
Wrapping Up
And there you have it — a comprehensive breakdown of how two popular sheet brands, Brooklinen and Bed Threads, compare across factors like materials, pricing, sizing availability, designs, and special features.
While both companies sell exceptional bed sheets, weigh your priorities around budget, design aesthetic, and production ethics to decide which best suits your needs.
Hopefully this guide gave you the insider’s perspective you need to confidently invest in luxury sheets tailored to your lifestyle! Here’s to many beautiful nights of sleeping ahead.
