PenaShield Vs. Bora-Care For Better Wood Protection (2024)

Wouldn’t it be great to find the right wood preservative product for your home and furniture? 

Read my PenaShield and Bora-Care review to find out. Because here, I will discuss the two best wood preservatives and compare them with one another. 

We all go through wood insects, termites, and other insects every single day. And to be honest, it makes our life more and more difficult. That is why you must know which product is the best for wood preservation. 

So, without dillydally, let’s take this show underway. 

A Quick Comparison Table 

You will gather some basic knowledge about these two products from a comparison table. Plus, it will help you make up your mind and understand their in-depth differences later. 

Here’s a quick comparison table between PenaShield and Bora-Care:

TypeBorate-Based Wood PreserverLow Toxicity Wood Preservative
MaterialBorate Mineral SaltBorate Mineral Salt And DOT
Special FeatureA Ready-To-Use FormulaPrevention And Remedial Control
BenefitsEmits No VOCsPenetrates Wood And Stays There For The Life
UsageOutdoor and IndoorOutdoor and Indoor
PerformanceHigh-PerformingSuperior to PenaShield

In-Depth Differences Between PenaShield And Bora-Care

You need more information than just the comparison table above to make the right decision. So, stay with me here to learn the comparisons in detail. 

Here’re some key differences between PenaShield and Bora-Care:

  • Type

PenaShield is a clear wood preservative for decking and more. It is a borate-based ready-to-use penetrating fungicide and preservative. 

Using this wood preserver, you can kill and prevent termites, carpenter ants, wood-boring beetles, and decay fungi. 

On the other hand, Bora-Care is a low toxicity wood preservative that doesn’t need to be applied to the soil but to the structure. 

With a patented glycol penetrant, this termiticide, insecticide, and fungicide concentrate can kill and prevent termite, wood-bearing beetles, carpenter ants, and decay fungi. 

  • Pest Protection Offered

PenaShield and Bora-Care share effectiveness against some of the most common residential pests, including drywood termites, beetles, carpenter ants, and wood boring insects.

The main distinction in pests controlled relates to subterranean termites – the variety that nest underground but penetrate buildings to access wood sources.

Bora-Care offers proven protection against subterranean termites by creating a toxic barrier around the home. PenaShield does not claim effectiveness against subterranean termites.

So if you know you are dealing specifically with subterranean termites or want to guard against potential future subterranean termite infestations, Bora-Care is likely the better choice. For targeted treatment of existing drywood termite or beetle issues, PenaShield will provide similar results.

  • Material

PenaShield prevents insects from damaging the wood. It’s a borate-based solution that you can readily apply on wooden surfaces. Borate mineral salt is the active ingredient in PenaShield. 

Most importantly, this mineral salt makes sure that it does not break down over time like any other synthetic chemicals. Plus, you will receive long-term residual benefits to help protect treated wood for years. 

On the contrary, apart from borate mineral salt, another active ingredient of Bora-Care is Micronutrient Disodium Octaborate Tetrahydrate or DOT. Its unique patented blend of glycols combines with borate salt to give outstanding performance. 

This wood preservative mixture is half as toxic as sodium chloride or table salt. So, it won’t damage the environment either. 

  • Features 

PenaShield is a ready-to-use formula that you can spray or brush on raw and untreated wood.

This preservative can penetrate the wood and deliver long-lasting protection with its unique patented formula. 

Most importantly, it will not stain or discolor your wood surfaces. Once it becomes dry, you can paint over it or treat it with a water sealer. 

In contrast, many professionals and homeowners use Bora-Care as a pretreatment in new construction for termites and other wood-destroying insects.

Plus, you can also use this solution to eliminate the existing infestation in your home. 

Besides, you will get prevention and remedial control of wood decay fungi and algae with Bora-Care. 

  • Benefits 

You will receive many long-lasting benefits from PenaShield and Bora-Care. Let’s check them out. 

PenaShield helps protect the wood from wood destroying organisms like termite and wood-boring beetles. It will help you prevent wood decay and dry rot. Besides, this ready-to-use formula emits no VOCs. 

On the contrary, Bora-Care eliminates the need to pump gallons of pesticides into the ground under your home. 

Think I’m exaggerating? 

Well, it’s because you won’t have to apply it to the soil. You can directly apply this solution to structures. 

On top of that, you can provide residual protection to your wooden structures using Bora-Care because it penetrates the wood and stays there for its life.

  • Water Solubility Considerations

Both Bora-Care and PenaShield liquid products utilize DOT in a water soluble formula. This means after application, they can gradually diffuse deeper into porous materials when exposed to excess moisture.

However, it also means these chemicals may leach out of treated areas over an extended period, requiring reapplication. Leaching potential depends greatly on environmental conditions.

Indoors, leaching is typically very minimal so penetration and protection can last for years. Outdoors where treated areas are exposed to rain and weather, leaching occurs more rapidly.

If making outdoor applications, the manufacturer recommends recoating high risk areas annually to maintain maximum protection.

  • Odor and Health/Safety Considerations

The PenaShield and Bora-Care liquids have very low odor both as applied and once dried on materials. Indoors applications won’t require occupants to leave or even know treatment occurred aside from seeing the spray application.

Those with chemical sensitivities can comfortably resume normal activities in treated spaces once application moisture has dried.

Both products have low acute toxicity to humans and mammals, with bittering agents added to discourage ingestion. DOT has a history spanning decades for safe use around people and pets when applied accordingly to manufacturer recommendations.

However, as with any chemical treatment, basic precautions should be taken during application – avoiding contact with eyes, skin, food surfaces, and covering immersed application areas until fully dry. Having a second person is ideal to serve as an observer when spraying overhead or in tight spaces.

Long pants, closed toe shoes, safety glasses, and chemical resistant gloves should always be worn during application.

  • Usage 
Penashield wood preservative

You have to use PenaShield to bare wood. You will get an excellent result when you use it to treat decks.

Besides, you should use it on older decks after cleaning them and before staining, sealing, and painting. 

Apart from that, you can also apply it to roofs after removing old shingles.

This wood preservative also works perfectly on fences, wooden play structures, or any other wood that you want to last. 

Bora-Care is a replacement for soil treatment in new construction sites. Besides, it works as a primary termite treatment solution in many places and considerations. 

You can use this wood preservative to protect against drywood termites, Formosan termites, Powderpost beetles, subterranean termites, Carpenter ants, and old house borers. Plus, this product can kill and prevent wood-decay fungi and algae. 

  • Performance 

You can use PenaShield both inside and outside, but you must maintain a water repellant level. For indoor application, PenaShield will last for a lifetime. But for outdoor use, you will have to apply it once in a couple of years. 

Besides, one gallon of PenaShield will treat 150-250 square feet of wood. 

On the contrary, you can directly apply Bora-Care on wood surfaces and structures. Most importantly, it will penetrate the wood surface and remain there for a lifetime protecting it from various insects. 

Which Wood Preservative Is Best For You? 

By this time, with the above in-depth comparison, you should be clear on which one is better than the above—no need to worry if you still can’t figure it out. 

I will tell you which product I feel is best for wood preservation. 

According to my practical experience and other customer reviews, it is evident that Bora-Care is better equipped to protect your wood structures. 

Although, you will have to mix it after purchase. But look at the bright side. It will penetrate the wood and last for a lifetime. 

Plus, unlike PenaShield, you won’t have to reapply it every couple of years. So, you most definitely should use Bora-Care to preserve your wooden surfaces. 

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ) 

Is borax the same as Bora care?

When boric acid and borax form a union, a new compound substance called borate salt formulates. This borate salt is the active ingredient in Bora-Care. 

Can you make Bora care with borax?

Yes, you can make Bora-Care with borax. To make Bora-Care, you will need borate salt, a key component of Bora-Care. This borate salt is made from borax and boric acid. 

Do your own Boracare?

Bora-Care does not come readymade. So, you will have to mix it before use. But the mixing is quite easy. You will have to mix 1 gallon of Bora-Care with 1 gallon of water. It becomes a complete 2-gallon solution that you can put in a sprayer and apply to the surface.  

How do you use PenaShield?

PenaShield is a ready-to-use formula that does not require any mixing. You can directly apply it from the container using a brush or spray with a low-pressure sprayer.

Final Thoughts 

Our wooden surface can quickly become damaged by various insects, wood-decay fungi, and algae if we do not treat them properly. And for that, you need to find the best solution. 

From my PenaShield vs. Bora-Care review, now you know the best wood preservative out there. I’ve given you what you needed. Now go and protect your wood surfaces and structures. 

Ralph Wade

Hey...Ralph is here! So, did you find this article useful? If so, please leave a comment and let me know. If not, please tell me how I can improve this article. Your feedback is always appreciated. Take love :)

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Recent Posts