If you’re in the market for new bed sheets, you may be trying to decide between Coyuchi and Brooklinen. Both brands make high-quality bed linens with a focus on using natural, sustainable materials.
But there are some key differences between them that can help you choose which is better for your needs and preferences.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Coyuchi | Brooklinen |
| Materials | GOTS certified organic cotton and linen | Long-staple cotton, some linen |
| Manufacturing | Owned factories in India | Third-party factories in Portugal, Israel, India |
| Price | $200 – $500 for queen set | $109 – $169 for queen set |
| Sustainability | Organic farming, ethical production | OEKO-TEX certified cotton |
| Aesthetic | Natural, neutral colors | Modern, wide range of solids |
| Comfort | Lightweight, luxurious | Cool, crisp feel |
| Quality | Integrated manufacturing, natural dyes | Close oversight for durability |
| Patterns | Stripes and textures | Stripes, prints, windowpane |
| Policies | 90-day returns | 60-day returns |
| Ratings | 4.9 stars (8,000+ reviews) | 4.7 stars (20,000+ reviews) |
Overview of Coyuchi
Coyuchi is a home textile company founded in 1991 and based in San Francisco. They are known for their organic cotton bed sheets and other linens. Some key things to know about Coyuchi:
- Materials: They use organic cotton, linen, and other natural fibers. All of their cotton is certified organic by the Global Organic Textile Standard (GOTS).
- Manufacturing: The cotton is grown in India and Turkey, then woven into fabric at mills in India. The final products are sewn in factories they own in India.
- Prices: Coyuchi sheets range from $200 up to $500 for a queen sheet set. They are a premium-priced brand.
- Sustainability: Strong focus on organic farming, ethical production, and natural dyes. B Corporation certified.
- Aesthetic: Simple, elegant, and natural. Neutral colors with some patterns and textures available.
Overview of Brooklinen
Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer bedding startup founded in 2014 and based in New York. They are known for high-quality sheets at more accessible price points. Here are the key facts:
- Materials: Brooklinen sheets are made from 100% long-staple cotton or linen. Cotton options are 270-480 thread count.
- Manufacturing: The cotton is sourced from Israel and India. The sheets are woven in mills in Portugal, Israel, and India, before being sewn in factories in Israel.
- Prices: Queen sheet sets range from $109 to $169. More budget-friendly than Coyuchi.
- Sustainability: OEKO-TEX certified cotton, some ethical factories used. Not as comprehensive as Coyuchi.
- Aesthetic: Simple and modern. Lots of solid colors and limited patterns available.
Key Differences Between Coyuchi And Brooklinen Bed Sheets
Now that you have an overview of each brand, let’s compare them in a few key categories.
- Materials
Both brands use high-quality cotton and linen for their sheets. The biggest difference is that Coyuchi exclusively uses organic cotton certified to the strict GOTS standard. This means the cotton is grown without toxic pesticides and fertilizers. It’s better for the environment and your health.
Brooklinen uses long-staple cotton, which is smoother and softer than regular cotton. But it is not organic. Their cotton is OEKO-TEX certified free from harmful chemicals. However, no standards exist for the growing methods.
For natural linen sheets, the two brands source from similar regions like France and Belgium. Coyuchi’s linen is OEKO-TEX certified while Brooklinen’s is not.
Overall, Coyuchi wins for using organic cotton and having third-party certification for all materials. But Brooklinen is a good option if you want quality sheets for less.
- Comfort
When it comes to comfort, several factors come into play, like weave, thread count, and finishing processes.
Both brands use a sateen weave for their cotton sheets, which gives a smooth, silky feel. For linens, they use a relaxed linen weave that softens over time.
In terms of thread count, Brooklinen sheets range from 270-480, while Coyuchi does not disclose their thread count.
Higher thread counts tend to feel softer.
Based on customer reviews, both brands offer exceptionally soft, comfortable sheets.
Coyuchi’s tend to feel a bit more luxurious and lightweight, while Brooklinen’s have a cool, crisp feel. However, personal preference will also influence which feels best to you.
For extra comfort, Brooklinen offers percale cotton sheets, which have a matte finish and linen-like feel. Coyuchi also has flannel cotton sheets for winter and heavier linen sheets.
When it comes to comfort, it’s a very close tie. Try them out to decide which texture you prefer.
- Quality and Durability
With proper care, high-end sheets can last 5-10 years or longer. Both Coyuchi and Brooklinen are committed to making sheets that stand the test of time.
User reviews indicate excellent quality and durability from both brands. Some customers have sheets from each brand that still look great after 5+ years of regular use.
Coyuchi may have a slight edge for quality as they manufacture their sheets from start to finish. However, Brooklinen’s close oversight of production and focus on quality materials means their sheets are built to last as well.
One area where Coyuchi excels is colorfastness. They use low-impact natural dyes that retain vibrancy wash after wash. Some Brooklinen reviewers note their sheets show fading over time.
Overall, outstanding durability and quality from both companies. Coyuchi edges ahead thanks to their integrated manufacturing and natural dyes.
- Price
When it comes to price, Brooklinen is the clear winner if you want quality sheets for less. Their queen sheet sets start at $109, while Coyuchi’s start around $200.
Of course, Coyuchi sheets may be worth splurging on if you want the best organic cotton and an extremely luxurious feel. But Brooklinen offers solid value for money given the quality.
Here’s an overview of pricing for each brand:
Brooklinen
- Core sheet set (solid colors): $109-$139
- Luxe sheet set (specialty fabrics): $149-$169
Coyuchi
- Organic cotton sheet set: $248-$528
- Linen sheet set: $288-$528
Overall, Brooklinen offers the best prices for stylish, everyday sheets. Choose Coyuchi if budget is no concern and you want luxury organic cotton.
- Sustainability
For environmental impact and ethical production, Coyuchi is the winner. Their entire supply chain is certified organic to the strict GOTS standard. This covers everything from farming to manufacturing. They also prioritize natural dyes and run a few of their own factories.
While Brooklinen does not focus on sustainability as comprehensively, they do have OEKO-TEX certification to ensure no harmful chemicals are used in production. And they partner with some exemplary factories.
So Coyuchi takes the lead on sustainability due to their organic certification from start to finish. But Brooklinen still uses safe, high-quality materials in their sheets.
- Pattern and Color Selection
Brooklinen offers many more style options than Coyuchi when it comes to patterns and colors.
Brooklinen has dozens of different colors, ranging from neutrals like white and gray to bold hues like ruby red and cobalt blue. They also offer classic stripes, windowpane, and graphic prints.
Coyuchi has a tighter color palette focused on natural hues like ivory, slate, and indigo. For patterns, they have classic stripes plus some textures like ombré. Overall, their options are much more limited.
If you like variety when it comes to choosing new sheets, Brooklinen is the clear winner. Their extensive color and pattern choices make it easy to match your style.
- Customer Service and Policies
Both brands offer strong customer service and fair policies that make shopping worry-free.
- They both offer free shipping in the US.
- Returns are free as well – Brooklinen offers a 60-day window while Coyuchi has 90 days.
- All products come with a lifetime guarantee against defects.
- Helpful customer service by phone and online chat.
Based on reviews, customers are very satisfied with support from both companies.
But Coyuchi has a slight edge for their 90-day return window vs 60 days from Brooklinen.
In summary, you can confidently shop from either brand knowing returns are easy and sheets are covered by a lifetime warranty. But Coyuchi stands out slightly for their 3 month tryout period.
- Reviews and Ratings
Both companies have stellar ratings and rave reviews that speak to the exceptional quality of their sheets:
- Brooklinen – Around 20,000 verified reviews. Avg rating of 4.7 out of 5 stars.
- Coyuchi – Nearly 8,000 verified reviews. Avg rating of 4.9 out of 5 stars.
Coyuchi has slightly higher average ratings, which may reflect their focus on luxury organic materials. But overall, customers are extremely satisfied with both brands. The positive reviews confirm the excellent quality, comfort, and durability offered.
It’s hard to go wrong with either highly-rated option. But Coyuchi may appeal more to shoppers wanting eco-friendly luxury sheets.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Some of Brooklinen’s top competitors in the bedding space include: Parachute, Snowe, Buffy, Casper, MagicLinen, Layla, Riley Home
These brands offer high-quality sheets and other home textiles directly to consumers at an accessible price point. They also focus on style and simple branding like Brooklinen.
It’s hard to definitively declare the “best sheet in the world” but some brands known for outstanding quality include: Frette – Italian luxury sheets made from long-staple cotton, Peacock Alley – Family-run company using fibers like Egyptian cotton, Coyuchi – Organic cotton and linen with rigorous standards, Snowe – Exceptional Percale and sateen sheets, Matouk – Luxury sheets woven in Italy from Egyptian cotton, Brooklinen – Affordable everyday sheets with great quality.
Luxury hotels like the Four Seasons, Ritz-Carlton, and Park Hyatt often use bedding from premium brands like: Frette – Supplies linens to many 5-star resorts and hotels worldwide, Sferra – High-end Italian brand used at hotels like the Peninsula, Anichini – Provides custom linens for luxury chains like Aman, Matouk – Ritz-Carlton and other top hotels carry Matouk sheets, Yves Delorme – French luxury brand found at hotels like the Four Seasons.
Some of the best linen bedding and fabrics comes from: Matouk – Luxury French linen with exquisite quality, Coyuchi – Relaxed organic linen sheets, duvets, and blankets, MagicLinen – Affordable European flax linen sheets and linens, Cultiver – High-end linen fashioned in France, Rough Linen – Simple, minimalist linen basics made in the US, Piglet – Boutique French linen bedding, apparel, and home goods.
Conclusion
So which brand comes out on top in this Coyuchi vs Brooklinen comparison?
Here’s a quick recap of how the two brands compare across the key categories:
- Materials – Coyuchi for organic certification
- Comfort – Tie
- Quality – Slight edge to Coyuchi
- Price – Brooklinen is more budget-friendly
- Sustainability – Coyuchi leads
- Selection – Brooklinen offers more colors and patterns
- Policies – Tie
- Reviews – Slight edge to Coyuchi
Overall, Coyuchi is best if you want ultra-luxurious sheets made from organic materials and prioritize sustainability. You can expect amazing comfort and durability. But the price tag is high.
For most shoppers wanting great quality sheets for a reasonable price, Brooklinen is hard to beat. You still get outstanding comfort and durable construction. Just with less focus on organic fibers.
Either brand is an excellent choice that you’re sure to love sleeping in night after night. It just comes down to your priorities and budget. Hopefully this detailed comparison helps you choose the best bed sheets for your needs.
