Coop Original Vs. Eden Pillow: In-depth Differences

If you’ve ever struggled to find the perfect pillow, I feel your pain. Choosing a pillow that keeps you comfortable all night, every night, is no small feat, especially if you toss and turn or need extra support for your neck and spine.

Two standout options in the memory foam pillow category—the Coop Original and the Eden Pillow—are designed to adjust to your unique needs. Coop Home Goods makes some of the best customizable pillows, but the choice between the Coop Original and the Eden can seem tricky.

Let’s break down the pros and cons of each to find the one that fits best for your specific sleeping style.

A Brief Comparison Table

Feature	Coop Original Pillow	Coop Eden Pillow
Material	Shredded memory foam and microfiber blend	Gel-infused shredded memory foam
Cover	Lulltra fabric (bamboo-derived viscose rayon blend)	Lulltra fabric with added gusset
Adjustability	Fully adjustable loft	Fully adjustable loft
Cooling	Moderate airflow, no gel	Enhanced cooling with gel-infused foam
Support for Sleep Positions	All sleep positions	All sleep positions
Shape Retention	May require occasional readjusting	Gusseted design for consistent loft
Price	Lower-cost option	Higher-cost option
Hypoallergenic	Yes	Yes
Certifications	CertiPUR-US, GREENGUARD Gold	CertiPUR-US, GREENGUARD Gold
Ideal For	Budget-conscious, adjustable support	Hot sleepers, consistent support

A Detailed Comparison of Coop Original And Eden Pillows

• Adjustability

Both the Coop Original and Eden are highly adjustable, giving you the freedom to modify the pillow to suit your needs. The fill in each pillow can be removed or added to create the desired loft, making it ideal for all sleep positions.

However, I found the Original to be a bit more straightforward when it comes to customization. If you prefer a pillow that you can tweak often, the Coop Original might have the edge. But, for a more even, consistent shape, the Eden Pillow’s gusseted structure keeps it stable and prevents any bunching.

• Cooling

If you tend to sleep hot, this is where the Coop Eden Pillow really shines. The gel-infused foam delivers a cooling effect that you won’t find in the Original, making it a solid pick for those who wake up from night sweats or overheating.

The Coop Original, while breathable, doesn’t offer the same cooling technology. For me, I found the Eden maintained a refreshing feel throughout the night, while the Original would gradually warm up. If temperature regulation is a top priority, the Eden is worth the higher price.

• Support and Shape Retention

The Coop Eden’s gusseted design keeps it in shape longer without flattening, making it great for people who prefer a consistent loft.

The Coop Original might require a bit more fluffing and adjusting to keep it from compressing too much over time.

For back and side sleepers, both pillows provide great support, but if you sleep on your stomach, you might find the Eden a bit too tall without significant fill adjustment. For the best all-position performance, I found the Coop Original a bit more adaptable.

• Price Considerations

If budget plays a role in your decision, the Coop Original has a more affordable price, and you’re still getting a solid pillow with all the key features. However, if cooling and long-term shape retention matter most, the Eden Pillow justifies its higher price with superior materials.

Pros And Cons of the Coop Original Pillow

Pros:

• Adjustability: You can easily control the firmness and loft by adding or removing foam, a major advantage if you prefer experimenting until you find the ideal comfort level.
• Breathability: The Coop Original features a breathable Lulltra cover, a blend of bamboo-derived viscose rayon and polyester, which allows for decent airflow, so you stay cool longer.
• Hypoallergenic and Safe Materials: If allergies are a concern, the Coop Original’s hypoallergenic and CertiPUR-US certified foam ensures you’re using a pillow free from harmful chemicals.
• Versatile for All Sleep Positions: Back, side, and stomach sleepers can all benefit from the adjustability that makes this pillow truly versatile.

Cons:

• Initial Off-Gassing: Like many memory foam products, the Coop Original can release a mild scent when new. It usually dissipates within a few days, but it’s worth considering if you’re sensitive to smells.
• May Require Frequent Adjustments: Over time, the fill may compress, requiring you to add more foam to maintain its shape. This can be a bit of an inconvenience for those who prefer a more hands-off pillow.
• Not the Coolest Option: Though the cover is breathable, the Coop Original lacks any cooling gel, so it may not stay as cool as the Eden.

Pros And Cons of the Coop Eden Pillow

Pros:

• Enhanced Cooling Effect: The gel-infused memory foam and gusseted design work together to provide a consistently cool and even sleeping surface, which is great for hot sleepers.
• Maintained Shape and Structure: The gusseted edge keeps the loft even, reducing the likelihood of bunching or flattening over time.
• Adjustable Support: Like the Coop Original, the Eden Pillow allows you to add or remove fill, giving you control over the firmness and loft.
• Hypoallergenic and Safe Materials: The Eden Pillow is also hypoallergenic and CertiPUR-US certified, so you can sleep soundly knowing it’s safe and eco-friendly.

Cons:

• Higher Price Tag: With added cooling benefits and structural design, the Eden Pillow is more expensive than the Coop Original, which could be a dealbreaker if you’re on a tight budget.
• Might Be Too Soft for Some: The gel-infused foam is generally softer than traditional memory foam, which may not provide enough support for those who prefer a firmer feel.
• Slightly Heavier: Due to the gusseted design and gel-infused foam, the Eden Pillow can feel heavier, which might make it less convenient if you frequently adjust your pillow during the night.

Maintenance Tips And Getting the Most Out of Your Coop Pillow

Taking proper care of your Coop pillow will extend its lifespan and ensure it provides top-notch comfort night after night. Here are some practical tips to help you get the best out of either the Coop Original or Eden:

1. Fluff Regularly: Give your pillow a few minutes of fluffing each morning. This will keep the foam from clumping and maintain the pillow’s shape.
2. Wash the Cover: Both pillows come with removable and washable covers. Washing it every couple of months helps maintain freshness and hygiene, especially if you’re prone to night sweats or allergies.
3. Air Out the Foam: If you notice a slight odor when your pillow is new, let it air out for a few days. This reduces any remaining manufacturing scent. Placing it outside for a day in a shaded area will work wonders.
4. Add or Remove Foam as Needed: Don’t hesitate to experiment with the fill to find the ideal loft. If you notice the pillow flattening over time, adding a bit more foam can make a big difference in comfort and support.
5. Use a Pillow Protector: Adding a waterproof protector can protect your investment from spills and accidents, which is particularly helpful for those who like to enjoy a beverage in bed.
6. Refresh the Foam: Every few months, empty out the foam and give it a gentle massage. This will re-fluff the pieces and restore their original comfort and structure.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Thoughts

In the end, both the Coop Original and Eden pillows offer excellent options that bring customizable comfort into your bedroom. The Coop Original is a well-rounded, versatile choice that works for a wide range of sleepers and budgets.

If you’re sensitive to temperature or prefer a pillow that maintains its shape with a luxurious feel, the Eden Pillow may be a better fit. Whichever you choose, you’re getting a high-quality, adjustable pillow designed to meet your sleep needs—night after night.

Now, go ahead and find the pillow that will help you get the rest you deserve!