After living in my home for several years, I decided it was time to replace all of the old, drafty windows. I wanted something energy efficient that would keep my home comfortable in both summer and winter.
As I researched different brands and options, Weather Shield Signature series windows kept coming up as a top choice for high performance and durability. I ultimately chose to have Signature series windows installed throughout my entire home and wanted to share my thoughts after having them for the past year.
Overview of Weather Shield Signature Series
The Weather Shield Signature series is the company’s premium line of windows, proudly made here in the USA. They utilize a vinyl construction with a multi-chamber frame and sash design to provide strength and insulation. The windows come standard with a multitude of features:
- High performance glazing with low-E coating to reduce solar heat gain
- Argon gas fill between the panes for further efficiency
- Foam-enhanced frames for better structural stability
- Composite reinforcement for durability and longevity
- Pre-finished wood extension jambs on the interior
Weather Shield offers Signature windows in a variety of styles including double hung, casement, awning, sliding, picture, bay, bow, garden, and specialty shapes.
You can choose from numerous grid patterns and glass tint options to complement your home’s aesthetic.
The hallmarks of the Signature series that set them apart from Weather Shield’s basic options are the enhanced energy efficiency, boosted structural performance, premium grade materials, and robust warranty that comes standard.
My Review of the Windows After 1 Year
I could not be happier with my decision to install Signature series windows last year. Here are some of the key benefits I’ve experienced:
- Energy Efficiency
The Signature series makes a huge difference in the temperature regulation in my home. I immediately noticed my air conditioner running less frequently and for shorter intervals in the summer.
In the winter, the cold air stays out and the heat stays in remarkably well. Opening the blinds on a sunny day helps passively warm the house. I am saving a significant amount on heating and cooling costs compared to my old windows.
- Noise Reduction
The new windows do an impressive job blocking outside noise. I used to hear every passing car and neighbor; now the only time I notice noise is when a window is open.
With the windows closed, my home is an oasis of quiet. I don’t even hear the pitter patter of rain on the windows like before.
- Improved Durability
My old windows constantly needed repairing – I was re-caulking and replacing weather stripping frequently.
The Signature series windows are solidly constructed from quality materials.
After a year of use with kids and pets, they operate smoothly and look brand new.
No cracks, fogging, or other issues to report.
- Enhanced Security
The sturdy construction, tamper-resistant lock hardware, and laminated glass provides peace of mind from a security standpoint.
I feel much more comfortable leaving windows open for fresh air when I’m not home compared to my past experience.
- Aesthetic Appeal
I love the clean, crisp look of the vinyl frames and the wood jambs complement my home’s interior beautifully. The grids provide just the right amount of accent. Visitors frequently compliment how nice the windows make my house look.
The only downside I’ve noticed is a bit more condensation on the interior glass in winter. But a quick wipe with a towel clears it up. A very minor issue considering all the positives I’ve gained.
How Weather Shield Signature Windows Stack Up to Other Top Brands?
Vs. Pella Impervia
Pella Impervia is also a premium, highly rated window line. Like Signature, it has robust vinyl construction, low-E coating, argon gas, and fiberglass reinforcement. A few differences:
- Pella offers wider custom sizing options for large openings or unique needs
- Weather Shield has slightly better air infiltration scores
- Pella Impervia has more contemporary color choices
- Signature windows achieve marginally better ratings for condensation resistance
- Pella provides more specialty shape choices like circles
Overall, Pella Impervia and Weather Shield Signature are closely matched. Both are great options, performing better than standard vinyl. Personal preferences for styling, customization, and price may drive the decision between the two brands.
Vs. Milgard Tuscany
The Milgard Tuscany series competes directly as a high-end vinyl window. It has premium features like foam-filled frames and triplet glazing for excellent thermal efficiency. Comparisons:
- Signature has more glass coating and fill options to choose from
- Milgard offers wider product selection including bi-folding doors
- Weather Shield provides a longer warranty period
- Both achieve very low air leakage but Signature is slightly better
- Milgard has more contemporary exterior styling
Milgard Tuscany windows are beautifully made and energy efficient. Weather Shield Signature takes the leg up with longer warranties, superior weatherproofing, and more classic look.
Vs. Okna Windows
Okna is lesser known than some brands but makes very high performing windows.
- Okna windows are thicker and heavier than Signature series
- Signature has higher visible light transmittance
- Okna has a unique vacuum-sealed glass option
- Weather Shield offers larger maximum sizes
- Both achieve excellent air tightness and U-factors
For those wanting beefy, industrial grade windows, Okna is a great option.
Signature provides a good balance of strength, light, and size flexibility.
Vs. Hurd Windows
Hurd Windows are primarily made of Western pine, so they have a completely different look and feel than vinyl Signature windows.
- Hurd wood windows can’t match Signature series for energy efficiency
- Hurd offers custom stained wood to match any home
- Signature provides better rot and warp resistance
- Hurd uses high quality brass hardware vs. Signature’s stainless steel
- Hurd has a more classic, rustic appearance
For those wanting the natural beauty of real wood, Hurd is an excellent choice. Signature better suits those prioritizing low maintenance, thermal performance, and cost.
Vs. Simonton Daylight Maximizer
Simonton’s top series, the Daylight Maximizer, utilizes advanced glazing, vinyl construction, and triple-pane options.
- Simonton offers impact resistant upgrades not available from Signature
- Weather Shield provides better sound insulation
- Simonton has slightly more contemporary styling
- The Maximizer is only Energy Star certified up to Northern zone, unlike Signature’s full certification
- Simonton’s air infiltration scores don’t match Signature series
Overall the Maximizer line is a good choice for hot southern climates wanting hurricane protection. Those wanting maximum energy savings across all zones get better results from Signature series.
Answering Key Questions About Weather Shield Signature Windows
Yes, absolutely! Weather Shield is one of the best window brands available today. The company has over 60 years of manufacturing expertise. Their windows are built to last, providing long-term value. Both the materials and construction methods are top-notch. Of course, all brands produce some lemons, but Weather Shield has a proven reputation among window industry experts and homeowners for consistent quality and performance.
There is currently a class action lawsuit related to some Weather Shield windows manufactured between 1991-2009 that allegedly developed issues with seal failure, resulting in fogging between the panes. However, it is important to note that this lawsuit does not apply to the Signature series. It only involves a specific product line of lower-end vinyl windows lacking the robust construction and materials of the Signature series.
Weather Shield has addressed the deficiencies that led to issues with those past products and the Signature series utilizes modern engineering advancements and quality control practices. While legal action can happen with any major manufacturer, the lawsuit does not indicate widespread problems with Weather Shield’s current windows. My personal Signature windows have maintained their seal and clarity without any indication of premature failure.
When it comes to ratings, Signature series windows score very highly:
Energy Star – They meet strict Energy Star requirements for thermal efficiency in all climate zones.
NFRC – Earns top marks from the National Fenestration Rating Council in areas like solar heat gain, visible light transmittance, condensation resistance, and air leakage. Signature series U-factors are as low as 0.27, far surpassing minimums.
AAMA – Complies with the most stringent specifications from the American Architectural Manufacturers Association for structural integrity and forced entry resistance. Signature series ratings go up to DP-50.
So in terms of ratings from all the major window certification organizations, the Signature series measures up very well and exceeds benchmarks.
Weather Shield windows are owned by their parent company Weather Shield Mfg., Inc. which is based in Wisconsin. It is a family-owned and operated company that has been passed down and expanded through four generations since they first started making windows in 1956.
Weather Shield takes great pride in keeping their window manufacturing operations based in the United States. When many competitors have moved production overseas, Weather Shield has held firm to keeping facilities in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. They also have a strong network of exclusive local dealerships across the U.S. that sell and install their windows.
Owning Weather Shield windows means supporting American workers and small businesses. As the owner of Signature series products, I feel good knowing I purchased quality U.S.-made windows and am helping my local authorized dealer stay in business.
Conclusion and Recommendation
In summary, my experience with Weather Shield’s Signature series windows has been outstanding. After a year of use, I could not recommend them more highly to other homeowners looking to replace windows. The combination of energy efficiency, noise reduction, security, durability, and aesthetics is unmatched.
While they are an investment, the long lifespan and performance of Signature series windows make them well worth the cost. I am confident my new windows will continue providing comfort and benefits for decades to come.
For anyone considering Weather Shield windows, you can feel assured you are getting a top-tier product backed by outstanding service and warranties. I would not hesitate to choose them again.
Let me know if you have any other questions! I’m happy to provide additional details on my firsthand experience as a satisfied Signature series owner.