When it comes time to replace the windows in your home, it can feel overwhelming evaluating all the options. Andersen and Wallside are two of the biggest names in replacement windows, but they have some key differences.
This guide will compare the pros and cons of Wallside and Andersen windows to help you make the right choice for your home.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Comparison | Wallside Windows | Andersen Windows |
| Frame Materials | Primarily vinyl, some aluminum-clad wood | Fibrex, vinyl, wood, aluminum-clad wood |
| Window Styles | All standard styles | All standards plus specialty windows |
| Energy Efficiency | Double, triple pane with argon gas | SmartSunTM and Agribalance glass for added efficiency |
| Installation | By Wallside’s own crews | Through independent dealers |
| Pricing | $250-800 installed typically | $500-1500+ installed for most styles |
| Warranties | Limited lifetime, 10 years on glass | Limited lifetime, 20 years on glass |
| Reviews | Mixed but generally positive | Consistently positive reputation |
Overview of Wallside Windows
Wallside Windows is one of the largest window replacement companies in the Midwest. Founded in 1950 in Detroit, Wallside now services homeowners in Michigan, Indiana, Ohio, Wisconsin, Illinois, Pennsylvania, Minnesota and Iowa.
Some key things to know about Wallside Windows:
- They offer a full range of replacement window options including double hung, sliding, casement, awning, bay and bow, and garden windows.
- Wallside Windows are custom manufactured by GlassCraft, which is one of the largest domestic window manufacturers in the U.S.
- Their window materials include vinyl, wood, fiberglass and aluminum. Vinyl is their most popular choice for homeowners.
- Wallside focuses on affordable to mid-price range window options. They are not a high-end window but offer good value.
- All Wallside Windows come with limited lifetime warranties.
Overview of Andersen Windows
Andersen Corporation is one of the oldest and most recognizable window brands in America. Founded in 1903, Andersen is headquartered in Minnesota and offers windows and doors across the U.S. and Canada.
Some key facts about Andersen windows:
- Andersen offers a huge range of window styles and product lines across different price points. They are a true one-stop-shop.
- Their most popular materials are Fibrex (a proprietary composite of wood fiber and thermoplastics), vinyl, and wood.
- Andersen is considered a premium brand and their products are priced accordingly. They offer very high-end wood windows.
- All Andersen windows have limited lifetime warranties but the coverage varies by product line.
- Andersen windows are sold through a network of authorized dealers, not big box stores.
Key Differences Between Wallside And Andersen Windows
Now that we’ve covered the basics on both brands, let’s do a detailed comparison of the pros and cons.
Window Frame Materials
One of the biggest differences between Wallside and Andersen is the variety of frame materials available.
Wallside primarily sells vinyl windows which are affordable and durable. They also offer some aluminum-clad wood windows on their high end.
Andersen offers many more frame options including:
- Fibrex – Their proprietary composite of wood fiber and thermoplastics with the warmth of wood and durability of vinyl.
- Vinyl – Affordable and energy efficient.
- Wood – Beautiful and long-lasting but require more maintenance. Available as pine or oak.
- Wood-Clad Windows – Wood interior covered in extruded aluminum cladding. Very low maintenance.
This gives Andersen a leg up in terms of material selection and customization. Their wood and Fibrex windows offer a premium look and feel.
Window Styles Offered
Both Wallside and Andersen offer all the main window styles:
- Double Hung
- Sliding
- Casement
- Awning
- Bay and Bow
- Garden Windows
Andersen has a much more extensive selection of speciality windows like gliding, round top, curved windows, and architectural insert windows.
So they again have an edge if you want something more custom.
Wallside keeps the options simple which can benefit homeowners overwhelmed with choices. But if you want unique windows, Andersen has more flexibility.
Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency is crucial for any replacement window. Key factors include the frame material, number of panes, glazing, and gas fills.
Both Wallside and Andersen offer windows with:
- Double, triple, and quadruple pane glass
- Low-emissivity coatings to reduce heat/UV transfer
- Argon or other gas filled windows to improve insulation
Andersen uses their SmartSunTM glass coating and Agribalance glass technology to block more solar heat gain. This can result in energy savings of up to 32% compared to ordinary dual pane windows.
Wallside uses ComforTechTM glass for improved thermal performance. Their triple pane windows filled with argon gas match Andersen’s R-5 insulation ratings.
While Andersen may have a slight performance edge, both brands offer highly efficient windows. You can verify the exact U-factor and R-value ratings for the specific models you are comparing.
Installation Process
Replacing your windows means having installers at your home for multiple days. The installation process is important to consider.
Wallside Windows are installed by company employees. They have dedicated installation crews who are thoroughly trained and do efficient work. Homeowners report quick and clean installations from Wallside’s crews.
Andersen relies on local authorized dealers for window installation.
These dealers go through training but the quality can vary more than Wallside’s in-house crews.
Be sure to vet installers carefully.
The advantage of Andersen dealers is you get a more personalized service through a local small business.
But Wallside’s direct model creates more accountability and training standards.
Pricing and Warranties
Pricing and warranties are where the brands differ most significantly:
Wallside Pricing
As a budget to mid-priced brand, Wallside aims to offer the lowest upfront pricing:
- Average cost for a double hung vinyl window is $350-500 installed
- Basic vinyl sliders around $250-400
- More specialty or wood-clad windows in the $500-800 range
Their pricing is hard to beat on basic vinyl windows. But material upgrades add cost quickly.
Wallside Warranties
- Limited lifetime warranties on vinyl and clad wood windows
- 10 years on glass parts
- 1 year on labor
Andersen Pricing
As a premium brand, Andersen windows come at a higher upfront cost:
- Fibrex double hung windows average $700-1,200 installed
- Vinyl sliders $500-800 on average
- Wood windows over $1,500+ depending on type and size
Andersen Warranties
- Limited lifetime warranties but 20 years on glass
- Transferable warranties when selling home
- Have an A+ rating with Better Business Bureau
While the pricing gap is significant, many homeowners find Andersen worth the long-term investment in superior materials, efficiency, and performance.
Customer Service and Reviews
Understanding customer service and what homeowners say can provide great insight into true product quality.
Wallside Windows Reviews
- Generally positive reviews averaging 4 stars on consumer sites
- Praised for fair pricing and good installation service
- Some concerns with quality of hardware and getting warranty issues resolved
Andersen Windows Reviews
- Consistently positive reputation and reviews
- Customers rave about quality and getting issue-free installations
- Minor complaints about higher cost but most say worth the investment
Both companies have predominantly good reviews but Andersen’s are a bit more consistently glowing while Wallside has some complaints around hardware and responsiveness.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Some window brands considered comparable quality and performance to Andersen include:
Pella – Another well-known premium brand with strong reputation. Also offer many styles and materials.
Marvin – Known for very high-end wood and aluminum-clad windows. Comparable warranties and efficiency.
Jeld-Wen – Reliable mid-priced brand with fiberglass and wood windows. Great warranty programs.
Milgard – Popular vinyl windows known for quality components and energy efficiency. Budget friendly option.
While not identical, these brands can provide similar positives as Andersen like durability, aesthetics, and efficiency. Consider options like Fibrex and clad wood for closest comparisons.
With proper care and maintenance, Wallside vinyl windows are expected to last 20-30 years on average. Their composite wood windows may last 50+ years. Exact longevity depends on environmental factors. Wallside’s limited lifetime warranties cover defects but normal wear and tear is not covered. Following the proper cleaning and care guidelines from Wallside is essential to maximize the lifespan of the windows.
Wallside Windows are currently owned by Associated Materials, LLC, which is based in Belden Village, Ohio. Associated Materials is a large manufacturer of exterior home products including siding, windows, and doors. They have acquired a number of regional window companies over the years which now operate under the Wallside name. All Wallside windows are manufactured in the U.S. by domestic companies owned by Associated Materials.
According to consumer reviews and quality ratings, some of the best replacement window companies include:
Andersen – Excellent reputation and warranties on windows at various price points. Especially good for wood and Fibrex.
Pella – Another leader in premium window replacements with great service. Known for durability.
Milgard – Top choice for vinyl windows offering quality at affordable pricing. Good for hot climates.
Marvin – For those wanting very high-end wood windows, Marvin is virtually unmatched.
Wallside – For homeowners on a budget, Wallside vinyl and clad wood windows provide good value. Their installation service stands out.
Doing your research is crucial because even among the best brands, models and product lines vary. Be sure to understand warranties and features for that specific window.
Bottom Line
Replacement windows are a big investment for your home. Taking the time to understand how Wallside and Andersen compare is smart due diligence.
For homeowners wanting vinyl windows at low prices, Wallside is hard to beat. Just be aware of some quality concerns with hardware and warranty support.
Those willing to pay a premium for exceptional quality and efficiency will likely prefer Andersen windows. Their variety of styles and materials give you ultimate choice too.
Whichever brand you choose, be sure the window quality and features match your goals. Investing in better windows saves money long-term and adds comfort and beauty to your home for years to come.
