You’ve made the big decision to build a new home rather than buy an existing one. Now comes the fun part – picking the perfect home builder to construct your dream home!
Two of the biggest national names in new construction are Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison. Both companies have stellar reputations, but they take different approaches when it comes to home types, sizes, finishes, and amenities.
Keep reading this comprehensive guide to discover how Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison compare across the factors that matter most.
Feature And Pricing Comparison
| Category | Toll Brothers | Taylor Morrison |
| Type of homes | Luxury single-family homes, townhomes, communities | Mainstream single-family homes, townhomes, apartments |
| Home sizes | 2,000 to 10,000+ sq ft | 1,200 to 4,500+ sq ft |
| Home prices | $300,000 to $6M+ | $200,000 to $1M+ |
| Locations | 50+ markets across 24 states | 20+ states nationwide |
| Customization | Highly customizable, luxury options | Optional structural and design upgrades |
| Green building | Built to sustainability certification standards | Environments for Living® program for energy efficiency |
| Amenities | Resort-style pools, clubhouses, golf courses | Community parks, playgrounds, walking trails |
| Warranty | 1-year limited warranty; 2-year systems warranty | 2-year limited warranty; 10-year structural warranty |
Head-to-Head Comparison of Toll Brothers And Taylor Morrison
From included features to construction quality, pricing to community amenities, the two builders take distinct approaches. Keep reading for an in-depth exploration of how Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison stack up across the factors that matter most to homebuyers.
Home Types, Sizes, and Prices
Home is where the heart is, so the details of what you can build are pivotal. Let’s examine how Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison compare when it comes to home offerings:
Toll Brothers
- Home types: Luxury single-family homes, townhomes, communities
- Home sizes: From 2,000 to 10,000+ square feet
- Price range: $300,000 to over $6 million
Taylor Morrison
- Home types: Mainstream single-family, townhomes, apartments
- Home sizes: From 1,200 to 4,500+ square feet
- Price range: $200,000 to over $1 million
Winner: Tie
Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison take divergent approaches when it comes to home types and price points.
Toll Brothers focuses squarely on spacious luxury homes at premium prices.
Their cheapest options still clock in around $300,000 with massive multi-million-dollar estate designs topping the charts.
Meanwhile, Taylor Morrison offers much more diversity across sizes and price ranges.
Their affordable mainstream designs cater to first-time and move-up buyers, while still offering custom luxury homes pushing $1 million-plus for those seeking upgrades.
Which builder wins comes down to your budget and aspirations. Those dreaming of a true estate-style mansion will gravitate to Toll Brothers. But if you seek excellent new construction without breaking the bank, Taylor Morrison deserves a close look.
Locations and Communities
Your home’s surroundings matter just as much as the home itself. Here’s how the builders compare when it comes to locations and community amenities:
Toll Brothers
- 50+ luxury markets nationwide
- Urban, suburban, resort settings
- Resort-style amenities
- Golf, clubhouses, pools
Taylor Morrison
- 20+ states across America
- More affordable suburban locations
- Community parks, trails, playgrounds
- Neighborhood pools
Winner: Toll Brothers
There’s a reason Toll Brothers homes land in luxury magazines—their communities are just as jaw-dropping as the homes. You’ll find Toll Brothers building in affluent urban neighborhoods and suburban enclaves, not to mention resort destinations like Palm Springs.
Their communities typically include lavish amenities like professional-grade golf courses, clubhouses, and pools that feel straight out of a five-star hotel. You pay for the exclusive ambiance.
Taylor Morrison communities still offer charming amenities like pools, parks, playgrounds, and trails to meet family needs. But locations focus more on affordable markets versus high-end areas.
The community vibe skews more toward friendly, family-focused over luxury escapism. For resort-style amenities, Toll Brothers takes the trophy.
Construction Quality
You can’t judge a home by its photos. While toll Brothers offers gleaming mansion photos, Taylor Morrison boasts excellent construction too. Let’s compare build quality:
Toll Brothers
- Luxury materials and details
- Meticulous craftsmanship
- Customization options
- Built to sustainability standards
- Smart home tech
Taylor Morrison
- Quality construction
- Modern designs and finishes
- Environments for Living® efficiency
- Custom upgrades available
- Won “Most Trusted” awards
Winner: Tie
Both builders aim to construct homes that meet their brand standards, whether luxury living or affordable quality. Toll Brothers is synonymous with the highest-grade materials and construction quality down to the smallest details.
Stone, marble, mahogany—no luxury material is spared.
Homes can be customized from floor plans to fixtures to achieve each buyer’s vision.
Sustainability is also a focus, with homes built to green certification standards.
Taylor Morrison buildings may not reach the pinnacle of luxury, but the company still prides itself on quality construction with modern finishes. Efficiency features like their Environments for Living® program reduce energy costs.
Custom upgrades are available to enhance kitchens, bathrooms, and outdoor living spaces as desired. Their trusted home builder awards attest to meeting buyer expectations.
Ultimately, both builders aim to deliver on quality with their respective product lines. Toll Brothers offers pure luxury while Taylor Morrison provides excellent construction at moderate price points. It comes down to your budget and aspirations.
Design Styles
You’ll see the builders’ different approaches the moment you tour model homes. Here’s an overview of their contrasting design aesthetics:
Toll Brothers
- Luxury details and finishes
- Marble, granite, mahogany
- Ornate moldings and tilework
- Sophisticated architectural features
- Home automation, media rooms
- Resort-style outdoor living
Taylor Morrison
- Open, contemporary floor plans
- Modern kitchens and baths
- Seamless indoor-outdoor flow
- Outdoor kitchens, fireplaces
- Elegant but livable style
- Less ornate details
Winner: Toll Brothers
Design is subjective, but there’s no denying Toll Brothers’ homes embody luxury living, like a five-star resort crossed with a sophisticated urban penthouse. Expect dramatic touches like sweeping staircases, wine cellars, home spas, and the latest tech-enhanced amenities.
Outdoors, you’ll find lavish features like covered patios, outdoor kitchens, and resort-worthy pools.
Taylor Morrison opts for a more contemporary style focused on livable spaces versus pure opulence. You’ll find open concepts, indoor-outdoor flow, modern fixtures, and intuitive home technology.
Clean lines and neutral palettes keep the focus on function versus intricate details. Their design aesthetic caters to buyers seeking an elegant but approachable feel.
For sheer luxury design, Toll Brothers stands out. But Taylor Morrison offers appeal through contemporary, family-friendly spaces.
Customization Options
Just like finding the right outfit, a home should reflect your unique personality. How do the builders compare when it comes to customization?
Toll Brothers
- Personalize from floor plans to finishes
- Work with design consultants
- Luxury kitchen, bath, tech upgrades
- Add pools, sunrooms, wine cellars
Taylor Morrison
- Structural options to optimize floor plans
- Choice of finishes for kitchens, baths
- Outdoor living upgrades
- Smart home tech offerings
- Less all-out luxury customization
Winner: Toll Brothers
Finding your dream home is a given with Toll Brothers thanks to unmatched customization opportunities. Work one-on-one with a design consultant to tailor everything from structural layouts to luxury finishes.
Outfit your gourmet kitchen with a $100,000 La Cornue range, build a sunroom addition for entertaining, or deck out your home theater – the sky’s the limit.
Taylor Morrison allows more budget-friendly personalization through structural modifications to floor plans and finishes. You can upgrade cabinets, counters, flooring and select smart home features. But the builder offers fewer all-out luxury options compared to Toll Brothers.
For buyers who want everything fully customized from doorknobs to infinity pools, Toll Brothers is the clear choice. But Taylor Morrison provides personalization possibilities at more reasonable prices for structural changes and finishes.
Warranties and Service
The true test of any home builder comes with how they handle issues after you move in. Let’s compare the builders’ warranties:
Toll Brothers
- 1-year limited warranty
- 2-year systems warranty
- 5-year structural warranty
- Luxury Buyer Assurance Program
Taylor Morrison
- 2-year limited warranty
- 5-year structural warranty
- 10-year structural warranty
- Cares® warranty program
Winner: Taylor Morrison
Both builders back their homes with limited warranties against defects and multi-year structural coverage. Toll Brothers provides a 1-year limited warranty, while Taylor Morrison extends this to 2 years – giving them the edge for protecting against early issues like plumbing leaks or electrical malfunctions.
Taylor Morrison also stands out with an impressive 10-year structural warranty. The added years of coverage help buyers rest easy knowing vital components are covered for a decade. Taylor Morrison’s Cares® program also provides service repairs by experienced professionals.
For the essential assurance of warranty coverage, Taylor Morrison wins out. But Toll Brothers offers excellent service too through their Luxury Buyer Assurance Program available for the home’s first two years. Both builders aim to deliver complete peace of mind.
Weighing The Pros And Cons of Taylor Morrison And Toll Brothers
Now that we’ve compared the ins and outs, let’s summarize the core pros and cons of each builder. Keep these benefits and limitations in mind when deciding between Toll Brothers vs. Taylor Morrison.
Pros and Cons of Toll Brothers
Pros
- Luxury features and finishes
- Fully customized homes
- Resort-style amenities
- High-end communities
- Meticulous construction
- Unique architectural details
- Home automation included
Cons
- Significant premium pricing
- Limited locations
- Inventory scarcity
- Major budget required
- Substantial upcharges
- Less affordability
- Strict HOA rules
The main appeal of Toll Brothers is crafting a fully customized luxury home and lifestyle. Their homes offer features, finishes, communities and amenities beyond compare. But you have to be willing and able to spend maximum dollars. Toll Brothers is tailored purely to high-end buyers.
Pros and Cons of Taylor Morrison
Pros
- Attainable prices for new construction
- Range of sizes and styles
- Contemporary, livable designs
- Community parks and amenities
- Energy-efficient features
- Structural customization
- Ten-year warranty coverage
Cons
- Not a true luxury brand
- More basic finishes in lower price points
- Less lavish amenities
- Narrower customization scope
- Smaller community features
- Lower resale potential
Taylor Morrison stands out through new construction homes with excellent design, quality finishes and livable floor plans across a wide spectrum of prices. This gives first-time and move-up buyers access to new builds. Tradeoffs for affordability include fewer luxury upgrades and more mass-appeal community features.
Key Takeaways: How To Choose Between Toll Brothers And Taylor Morrison?
- Prioritize luxury versus affordability – Toll Brothers caters purely to luxury buyers with premium pricing while Taylor Morrison offers excellent new construction at more affordable mid-market price points.
- Determine desired community amenities – Resort-style features like golf courses come standard at Toll Brothers communities while Taylor Morrison offers more family-friendly amenities.
- Consider customization budget – Toll Brothers allows limitless luxury customization but requires paying a high premium, while Taylor Morrison provides more modest upgrades focused on finishes and structure.
- Compare warranties for peace of mind – Both builders offer multi-year warranties but Taylor Morrison stands out with a 10-year structural warranty.
- Focus on lifestyles – Toll Brothers is built for elegance and escapism while Taylor Morrison promotes livable everyday spaces. Prioritize which vibe suits you.
With those key insights in mind, you can zero in on the perfect builder for your new construction home needs and wants. Both offer qualities that make them leaders in the industry. Keep your lifestyle, budget, and dreams in focus as you decide between Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Still, trying to decide between Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison? This FAQ addresses common questions homebuyers have when comparing the builders.
While both builders have earned the “most trusted” designation in recent years, the winner depends on the year and survey. Toll Brothers won Lifestory Research’s America’s Most Trusted Home Builder award in 2019 and 2020. But Taylor Morrison took the top honor in 2021. Essentially, homeowners trust both companies for new construction.
For buyers who prioritize luxury living and custom details above all, Toll Brothers is well worth the premium pricing. The homes match the high asking prices with features like professional-grade appliances, luxe finishes, home automation and resort-level outdoor living. But buyers on stricter budgets will find better value with more affordable builders.
Toll Brothers homes likely have higher long-term resale value due to the luxury brand identity. The meticulous construction also contributes to extended value. While Taylor Morrison builds excellent homes, the mid-market prices and mass appeal make future value harder to predict. Luxury seekers typically gain more on resale.
Both builders construct quality homes true to their brand standards and price points. Toll Brothers offers pure luxury with the highest-end materials and details. Taylor Morrison provides excellent construction and finishes with more budget-friendly options. While Taylor Morrison doesn’t reach luxury pinnacles, their homes still emphasize durable, livable builds.
Taylor Morrison wins out when it comes to warranty coverage. Their 2-year limited warranty beats Toll Brothers 1-year duration. Even more impressive is Taylor Morrison’s 10-year structural warranty compared to Toll Brothers’ 5-year option. Longer warranty terms provide peace of mind.
Some luxury home builders competing with Toll Brothers include Pulte Homes, Lennar, Meritage Homes, and KB Homes. Local high-end custom builders in their markets also vie for affluent buyers. But none match Toll Brothers exact focus on luxury resort-style living options.
Nationwide builders like D.R. Horton, Lennar, and Pulte Homes compete with Taylor Morrison for buyers wanting quality at a more moderate price. Regional production builders like Ashton Woods, David Weekley Homes and Highland Homes also go head-to-head with Taylor Morrison. Local custom builders also challenge both on upgrades.
The Final Call: Choosing The Right Builder For You
And there you have it – a comprehensive side-by-side view of how Toll Brothers and Taylor Morrison stack up as you search for your dream home builder. Keep reflecting on your budget, must-haves, lifestyle vision, and how each company’s offerings line up.
Schedule model home tours to get a feel for quality, finishes and design aesthetics. Determine if the extra investment required by Toll Brothers fits your goals or if Taylor Morrison’s balance of quality and affordability is more your speed.
