When it comes time to replace the windows in your home, two big names often come to mind: Renewal by Andersen and Home Depot. But with so many factors to consider from prices to features to warranties, it can be tricky to decide which option is right for you.
This comprehensive guide will compare Renewal by Andersen and Home Depot windows to help you make an informed decision.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Category | Renewal by Andersen | Home Depot |
| Brand | Proprietary | Multiple brands available |
| Materials | Fibrex composite, fiberglass | Vinyl, wood, aluminum, composite, fiberglass |
| Frame Types | Perma-Shield exterior | Various (single & double hung, sliding, casement, etc) |
| Glass | SmartSun Low-E4 coated | Low-E varieties |
| Installation | Full-service, Renewal by Andersen technicians | DIY or independent installers |
| Warranty | Limited lifetime, transferable | 5 years – lifetime, varies by brand |
| Price | $600 – $1200 per window installed | $180 – $1000 per window (installation extra) |
| Customization | Limited options | Wide selection |
Overview of Renewal by Andersen Windows
Renewal by Andersen is a well-known window replacement company that was founded in 1995. They are known for their custom-made windows that are designed specifically for each order. Some key facts about Renewal by Andersen:
- They offer fiberglass composite windows which are highly energy efficient and durable. Their proprietary Fibrex material is twice as strong as vinyl.
- All their windows feature a high-performance Low-E4 SmartSun glass that provides insulation and protects against UV rays.
- Their windows are custom built rather than mass produced. Each one is made to fit your exact window openings.
- They have three tiers: the Series 10 being the most affordable and the Series 20 their highest end offering.
- All their windows come with a limited lifetime warranty.
Overview of Home Depot Windows
Home Depot offers a wide selection of windows from various brands across different price points. Here are some key facts about Home Depot windows:
- Brands available include Pella, JELD-WEN, Milgard, and Home Depot’s in-house American Craftsman line.
- You can find basic vinyl and aluminum windows as well as higher end wood, fiberglass, and composite options.
- Energy efficient features like low-E glass, argon gas, and insulated spacers are available.
- They stock many standard window sizes but can also order custom sizes.
- Warranties range from 5 years to a lifetime depending on the brand and type. Most are 10-20 years.
- Professional installation services are offered in addition to DIY installation.
Key Differences Between Renewal By Andersen And Home Depot Windows
- Window Materials Compared
One of the biggest differences between Renewal by Andersen and Home Depot is the type of materials used.
Renewal by Andersen
Renewal by Andersen windows are made from a proprietary composite material called Fibrex. This combines the strength and durability of wood with the low-maintenance benefits of vinyl. They also offer fiberglass windows.
Home Depot
Home Depot carries windows in vinyl, wood, aluminum, composite, and fiberglass. Their broad selection lets you find windows made from virtually any material based on your needs and budget.
Vinyl is low cost and low maintenance but can be less durable over time. Wood offers a classic look but requires staining and sealing. Fiberglass and composite are strong, durable, and energy efficient.
- Window Frame Types
In addition to materials, the frame type influences the windows’ quality, durability, and price.
Renewal by Andersen
All of their windows feature a Perma-Shield frame and sash exterior. This thick frame construction adds strength and rigidity. The swinging sash panels make the windows easy to operate.
Home Depot
You’ll find various frame types including:
- Single and double hung (up and down sliding sash)
- Casement (side swinging)
- Awning
- Sliding
- Fixed picture windows
- Bay and bow (combined windows)
- Garden windows (with built-in plant shelf)
Frame types like casement are more energy efficient while double hungs allow for good ventilation.
- Glass Options
The glass in the windows plays a major role in energy efficiency, durability, and noise reduction.
Renewal by Andersen
Their dual-pane SmartSun glass blocks UV rays while letting light through. It uses a Low-E4 coating to reflect heat and keep your home cooler. An air blend fills the space between panes to further improve insulation.
Home Depot
Low-E glass is standard on most models with options for more advanced Low-E coatings. You can also upgrade to triple pane glass and krypton/argon gas filled windows for better insulation. Additional glass options like textured, tinted, and laminated are available.
So both offer energy efficient glass but you’ll find more customization with Home Depot.
- Installation Process
A key difference is that Renewal by Andersen handles the entire replacement process while Home Depot provides windows only or partners with independent installers.
Renewal by Andersen
Their price includes everything from window construction to installation to clean up. They use their own highly trained technicians and proprietary replacement process designed to be completed quickly.
Home Depot
You can hire third party professionals to install Home Depot windows. They are background checked but work independently from Home Depot. For DIY installs, free in-store services include:
- Design consultations
- Measurement and installation training
- Tool rentals
So Renewal by Andersen offers a more seamless, start-to-finish experience while Home Depot provides the windows and DIY resources or installer referrals.
- Warranties
The warranty terms provide peace of mind should any defects arise down the line.
Renewal by Andersen
Their limited lifetime warranty covers both parts and labor. It is fully transferable to future homeowners.
Home Depot
Warranty lengths vary by brand and product from as little as 5 years to lifetime. Most are 10-20 years for materials and parts only—labor is not included. Transferability also varies.
Renewal by Andersen offers one of the strongest warranties you can get for replacement windows.
- Cost Comparison
The price and overall value you get for the money are essential factors when selecting replacement windows.
Renewal by Andersen
Their windows are premium-priced, generally ranging from $600 – $1,200 per window installed. The final price depends on the size, number and type of windows (double hung, casement, etc). Their high-end materials and handcrafted approach come at a cost.
Home Depot
Prices start at $180 per window for basic models from brands like American Craftsman. Higher end options from Milgard, Pella and others can range from $300 to $1,000 per window. Installation costs extra, typically $100-300 per window.
So while Andersen’s windows are often 2-3 times the price of Home Depot’s entry models, they offer long warranties and hassle-free installation. You pay more but get white glove service. With Home Depot, you trade lower prices for windows-only purchase and unknown installers.
Pros and Cons
To recap the key differences between the two brands:
Renewal by Andersen Pros:
- Fibrex composite material for strength and efficiency
- Industry-leading warranty on parts and labor
- Seamless installation from start to finish
- Highly trained technicians do install
Renewal by Andersen Cons:
- Premium pricing that is often double Home Depot
- Limited style and customization options
Home Depot Pros:
- Broad selection of window materials, types and brands
- Can find very affordable vinyl models
- Ability to handle install yourself or use independent installer
Home Depot Cons:
- No control over installer expertise and quality
- Lower quality windows have shorter warranties
- Must manage the process from buying to installation
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Renewal by Andersen windows are typically the most expensive option compared to big box retailers. You’ll pay a premium for their top-tier materials, handcrafted approach, and lifetime warranty.
Andersen is the original window company while Renewal by Andersen is their division focused specifically on window replacements vs new construction. Owned by Andersen, they use similar materials and manufacturing techniques.
Several factors contribute to their high prices including their proprietary Fibrex composite material, their “Renewal by Andersen” brand name, their Made in the USA production, and their full-service model with installs done by their own technicians.
Yes, Renewal by Andersen is highly regarded for their replacement window expertise and quality. They have an A+ Better Business Bureau rating despite the premium pricing. Their windows can be worth the investment for many homeowners.
The Bottom Line
When evaluating Renewal by Andersen vs Home Depot windows, there are tradeoffs. Andersen is the premium window with a flawless install experience. Home Depot offers affordable options if you don’t mind a process requiring more owner coordination.
Carefully examine the materials, features, warranties, brands, prices and installation considerations. This will help you select the right replacement windows from either company based on your home’s needs and your budget.
