Retractable screens are a popular way to keep bugs out while letting fresh air in. Two of the biggest names in retractable screens are Rainier and Phantom Screens.
But which one is better?
Here’s an in-depth comparison of Rainier and Phantom retractable screens including pros, cons, features, and cost.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Rainier | Phantom |
| Quality | High quality materials and construction | Excellent durability and build quality |
| Installation | Easy DIY installation, under an hour | Easy installation with instructions |
| Operation | Smooth manual or motorized options | Smooth manual and motorized options |
| Wind Resistance | Up to 50 mph when installed correctly | Up to 60 mph when installed correctly |
| Warranty | 10 years on framework, 3 years on mesh | Limited lifetime on most components |
| Visual Options | 5 mesh colors, 15 frame colors | 5 mesh colors, 4 frame colors, woodgrain options |
Key Takeaways:
- Both Rainier and Phantom make high-quality retractable screens built to last.
- Phantom offers more variety from basic to luxury screens while Rainier provides excellent quality at moderate prices.
- Wind resistance is excellent for both brands in residential settings. Phantom is slightly higher rated.
- Installation is straightforward with included instructions for DIY in under an hour.
- Operation of manual and motorized screens is smooth and easy for both brands.
- Warranties are similar and reflect the durability of both Rainier and Phantom.
- Visual appearance can be tailored with mesh and frame color options. It’s a matter of personal preference.
- Overall quality and performance is matched between Rainier and Phantom. Choose based on specific features and budget.
Rainier Retractable Screens Overview
Rainier Screens are made by AMI Industries, a company based in Brentwood, TN that has been making retractable screens since 1997.
Some key things to know about Rainier retractable screens:
- High quality materials and construction. Rainier uses thick PVC vinyl mesh that won’t sag over time. Their screens have passed over 10,000 open/close cycles in testing.
- Custom fit for each opening. Screens are built to order for each unique window or door opening.
- Easy to install. Rainier screens come with complete installation instructions and typically install in under an hour. No special tools required.
- Manual or motorized operation. Rainier offers both manual screens that roll up by hand or motorized screens that open and close automatically.
- Wide range of colors. Choose from 5 mesh colors and 15 powder coated frame colors to complement your home’s exterior.
- Wind and pet resistant. Rainier screens can withstand winds up to 50 mph and have a Pet Mat fabric option that prevents damage from pet claws.
- Made in the USA. Rainier screens are proudly manufactured in the United States.
Phantom Retractable Screens Overview
Phantom Screens are made by Phantom Screens, a Canadian company founded in 1992. They are North America’s leading provider of retractable screens.
Key features of Phantom retractable screens:
- Diverse product line. Phantom offers over 50 different screen models for doors, windows, multi-panel systems, and unconventional openings.
- Custom sizing. Like Rainier, Phantom screens are made-to-order for each unique opening.
- Manual or motorized. Phantom offers both manual and motorized screens. Motorized models can be integrated with home automation systems.
- Pet safe. Screens have a pet damage warranty and can withstand pet damage better than most screens.
- Child safe. Screens cannot be removed from the opening due to their fixed roller box at the top.
- Weather resistant. Can withstand winds up to 60 mph when properly installed.
- Wide selection. Available in 5 mesh colors, 5 frame colors, and translucent screening.
Key Comparisons of Rainier And Phantom Screens
Now that we’ve overviewed both Rainier and Phantom retractable screens, let’s compare them across some key factors:
- Quality and Durability
Both Rainier and Phantom make high quality screens built to last. They both use thick PVC mesh that resists tearing, sagging, and damage. Phantom offers a limited lifetime warranty on parts while Rainier provides a 10 year warranty, showing both companies stand behind their products.
In independent testing by a consumer magazine, Rainier and Phantom both scored top marks in durability, resisting damage from pets, children, wind, and everyday wear and tear. Overall build quality is excellent for both brands.
- Installation and Operation
Installation of both brands is straightforward with the provided instructions. Most homeowners can install their retractable screens in under an hour without any specialized tools.
Operation is smooth and easy for both Rainier and Phantom screens. Manual models roll up and down effortlessly by hand. Motorized options open and close silently at the touch of a button.
Phantom offers a slightly wider array of motorized options while Rainier has more manual screen models. Both brands have excellent reviews for their ease of operation.
- Wind Resistance
Proper installation is key for any retractable screen to achieve its maximum wind resistance. When installed correctly, Rainier screens can withstand winds up to 50 mph while Phantom states their screens can handle winds up to 60 mph.
Realistically, both brands offer sufficient wind resistance for residential settings. Only in very high wind regions near oceans or mountains would Phantom’s slightly higher wind rating make a difference.
For most homeowners choosing between the two brands, wind resistance will be comparable in real world conditions.
- Cost and Value
Rainier and Phantom retractable screens are close in terms of cost.
On average, Phantom screens tend to cost slightly more than comparable Rainier screens.
However, Phantom’s larger selection of screen models allows you to choose the level of features and options that fit your budget.
They have economy manual screens along with high-end motorized models with every bell and whistle.
Rainier provides excellent value at a moderate price point. Their screens offer all the essential features and options most homeowners need without going overboard.
- Visual Appearance
With both Rainier and Phantom, you can choose from a variety of mesh colors and frame finish options to match your home’s style and color palette.
Rainier offers screens in black, charcoal, ivory, tan, or grey mesh with 15 frame colors. Phantom’s mesh colors are charcoal, light grey, black, ivory, or sandstone. For the frame, Phantom provides 4 color options along with wood grain finishes.
Both Rainier and Phantom can blend in discreetly or make a bold statement with lighter mesh and frame colors. Overall visual appearance is a matter of personal taste.
- Warranty
The warranty coverage offered by both companies reflects the quality and durability of their products.
Rainier offers a 10 year warranty on the framework, 3 years on the mesh, and 1 year on motors and electrical components. Phantom provides a limited lifetime warranty on most components unless damaged by chemicals, pets, improper installation or accidents.
The warranties offered by both Rainier and Phantom are on par with others in the industry. Most homeowners won’t need to make use of the warranty, but it’s reassuring to have that support in case an issue arises.
Rainier Or Phantom Screens: Which Is Better?
When comparing Rainier vs Phantom screens, there’s no universally “better” option. The two brands are closely matched overall.
Here are a few key factors to consider when deciding between Rainier and Phantom retractable screens:
- Budget – Phantom offers more choices from basic to luxury. Rainier provides excellent quality at a moderate price.
- Wind resistance – Phantom is rated slightly higher for wind resistance. But in most residential settings, it’s negligible.
- Operation – Both manual and motorized options work beautifully. Phantom has more motorized varieties while Rainier focuses on manual.
- Warranty – Nearly identical coverage between the brands for framework, mesh, and other components.
- Visual options – Both have mesh and frame color options to match your home’s aesthetics. It’s a matter of personal taste.
- Reputation – Rainier and Phantom both have outstanding reputations and hundreds of positive homeowner reviews.
At the end of the day, you can feel confident choosing either brand. Focus on finding the specific model that best fits your budget, design preferences, and functionality needs. With proper installation, either Rainier or Phantom retractable screens will provide years of smooth, trouble-free performance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Phantom retractable screens are widely considered among the best on the market. They are built from quality materials to high durability standards and offer excellent functionality. Homeowners consistently praise their smooth operation, versatility, and sleek appearance.
Mirage is Phantom Screens’ proprietary mesh material that offers improved durability, optical clarity, and resistance to wear and tear. So Phantom screens with Mirage mesh will be more durable than their standard mesh models. Mirage is comparable to Rainier’s Pet Mat mesh.
Phantom screen pricing depends on the size, model, and options selected. On average, manual Phantom screens cost $600 – $1000 per opening. Motorized models range from $1000 – $3000 installed. Phantom screens carry about a 10-15% price premium over Rainier screens.
When installed correctly, Phantom states their screens can withstand winds up to 60 mph, making them very wind resistant. This wind rating applies to their newer models that use extruded aluminum. Older models have lower wind ratings around 35 mph.
Final Thoughts
Hopefully this comparison of Rainier vs Phantom retractable screens helps provide insight into the pros, cons, costs, and ideal uses for each brand.
While the two companies are closely matched, the variety of Phantom’s product line gives you more choices to find the ideal retractable screen for your home and budget.
With either brand, you can look forward to years of enjoyment and protection from annoying insects thanks to the superb quality and smooth functionality of today’s retractable screens.