When it comes time to replace the windows in your home, you want to choose products that are high-quality, durable, energy efficient, and aesthetically pleasing. Two of the top brands on the market are Quaker and Andersen windows.
But how do you decide which option is right for you?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Quaker and Andersen windows side-by-side, analyzing the pros and cons of each brand. Key factors we’ll examine include:
- Materials and construction quality
- Design, style, and customization options
- Energy efficiency and temperature insulation
- Cost and warranty coverage
- Customer reviews and brand reputation
By the end, you’ll have all the information you need to make an informed decision about Quaker vs Andersen windows for your next home improvement project.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Comparison Criteria | Quaker Windows | Andersen Windows |
| Frame Materials | Vinyl, aluminum-clad wood | Fibrex composite, aluminum-clad wood, vinyl |
| Window Styles | Double hung, slider, casement, custom shapes | Double hung, casement, gliding, arch, radius, specialty |
| Energy Efficiency | Very good, meets ENERGY STAR standards | Excellent, industry leading performance |
| Design Aesthetic | Contemporary, clean lines | Classic to modern, unmatched customization |
| Cost Installed | $250-$800 typical range | $600-$1,200+ typical range |
| Warranties | Lifetime limited on materials, 20 years on glass | 20 years on glass, 10 years on materials |
| Brand Reputation | Well-reviewed, great value | Premier luxury brand, consistently rave reviews |
Quaker Windows Overview
Quaker Windows and Doors, a division of Quaker Manufacturing Corporation, has been crafting windows since 1949. The company offers a wide selection of vinyl and aluminum-clad wood windows and patio doors.
Some key things to know:
- Materials: Quaker uses premium raw materials like high-performance vinyl, aluminum, and wood. Their vinyl formulations are optimized for durability, energy efficiency, and color-retention.
- Design: Quaker windows feature a contemporary, sleek aesthetic achieved through narrowframe profiles. They offer various lines with different architectural styles.
- Efficiency: Their windows meet or exceed ENERGY STAR® requirements in all climate zones. Advanced glass coatings and argon gas filling boost efficiency.
- Customization: Quaker windows can be customized with different colors, hardware, glass, and grid options. Their patio doors also come in standard or custom sizes.
- Warranty: Most Quaker windows have lifetime limited warranties for materials and workmanship. Glass components have a 20-year warranty.
Andersen Windows Overview
Andersen Corporation has been manufacturing windows since 1903. They offer numerous lines of wood, vinyl, fiberglass, and aluminum-clad windows and doors.
Here are some Andersen key features:
- Materials: Andersen uses top-tier materials like Fibrex (fiberglass and wood composite), Impact-resistant thermoplastics, Perma-Shield exterior cladding, and high-performance glazing.
- Design: Their windows feature aesthetically appealing curves and arches, slim sightlines, and virtually endless configuration possibilities. Many lines emulate classic architectural styles.
- Efficiency: Andersen windows are engineered for energy efficiency, with advanced weatherstripping, insulating glass, and High-Performance Low-E4 glass. They meet or exceed ENERGY STAR standards.
- Customization: With 50 exterior colors, over 20 interior wood finishes, customizable hardware, and special glass options, you can create unique Andersen windows tailored to your home.
- Warranty: Most Andersen windows have 20-year limited warranties on glass, 10 years on non-glass parts, and 10 years on exterior color retention.
Quaker And Andersen Windows Comparison
Now that we’ve covered the basics of each brand, let’s do a detailed comparison of the pros and cons.
Materials and Construction
When evaluating window quality, the materials and construction methods used make a big difference in longevity, durability, and overall performance.
Quaker Construction
Quaker vinyl windows have multi-chambered frame and sash profiles that resist thermal transfer and enhance structural integrity. They use premium, lead-free, UV-resistant PVC that inhibits condensation and helps the windows maintain their appearance over time.
For wood windows, Quaker uses kiln-dried ponderosa pine and Douglas fir harvested from managed forests. The aluminum-clad exterior provides low-maintenance durability. Silicone-injected frame joints create a weather-tight seal.
Quaker Pros
- Multi-chamber vinyl frame provides structural stability and thermal insulation
- Lead-free, quality-controlled vinyl inhibits condensation and resists UV damage
- Pine and fir lumber harvested from managed forests
Quaker Cons
- No composite wood-fiberglass or aluminum options, only vinyl or aluminum-clad wood
- Silicone-injected frame joints may need re-sealing over time
Andersen Construction
Andersen windows feature a Fibrex composite material fusing wood fiber and thermoplastics for dimensional stability.
Their aluminum-clad wood windows have a Perma-Shield exterior coating and structural enhancements like mitered frame joints.
Vinyl options like 100 Series windows have a multi-wall frame design and tritanium enhanced PVC formula for added durability. Impact-resistant thermoplastics are used for strength.
Andersen Pros
- Fibrex material provides thermal stability without expanding or contracting
- Aluminum-clad Perma-Shield exteriors are low-maintenance
- Mitred frame joints, composite reinforcement, and structural enhancements add strength
Andersen Cons
- Multi-wall vinyl frame is comparable to Quaker’s, not superior
- More expensive window lines use proprietary materials that cost more
Design, Styles, and Customization
Both Quaker and Andersen offer attractive windows in a variety of architectural styles. But Andersen pulls ahead when it comes to the breadth of design options and ability to customize.
Quaker Design and Styles
Quaker windows have a sleek, uniform look with narrow frame profiles that maximize glass viewing area. Their contemporary style works well in modern homes. Available styles include:
- Quaker Prestige line: Double hung, sliding, picture, casement, awning, bay and bow, garden, patio doors
- Quaker Signature line: More basic slider, single hung, casement styles
- Quaker Custom Shape windows: Circle tops, arcs, angles, octagons, ovals
They offer various grid patterns and glass textures to match your home’s look. Exterior color choices are more limited than Andersen.
Quaker Pros
- Attractive narrow frames allow more natural light
- Prestige lines have architectural styling with clean lines
- Custom shapes add unique accents
Quaker Cons
- More limited exterior color and finish options
- Less ability to emulate classic architectural styles
Andersen Design and Styles
With Andersen, you can find styles ranging from Medieval Old World to sleek contemporary. Available lines include:
- A-Series: Double hung, casement, awning, gliding, stationary, bay, bow
- E-Series: Rectangle, radius, arched windows, exterior doors
- 200 Series: Double hung, gliding, hinged patio doors
- 400 Series: Casement, double hung, gliding windows
- 500 Series: Specialty windows like circular, gothic, cottage
Exterior colors span neutrals, deep hues, and black. You can customize grids, art glass, hardware finishes, wood trims, and more. No other brand matches Andersen’s versatile aesthetics.
Andersen Pros
- Huge selection of styles from Medieval to modern
- Signature lines emulate architectural aesthetics like Craftsman
- 50 exterior color and over 20 interior wood finish options
- Customize hardware, trims, art glass, and other accents
Andersen Cons
- More classic styles have wider frame profiles
- Higher cost for specialty window lines and customization
Energy Efficiency and Temperature Insulation
Energy efficiency is another essential factor when shopping for new windows. You want products that will provide excellent insulation, reducing your energy bills and making your home comfortable.
Quaker Efficiency
Quaker windows perform very well when it comes to thermal insulation. Even their most affordable lines meet or exceed ENERGY STAR requirements.
Key efficiency features include:
- Multi-layer weatherstripping to reduce air infiltration
- Thermal reinforcement in frame and sash
- Optional double or triple glazing with argon gas fill
- Low-E coatings to reflect infrared heat
- U-factors as low as 0.27 and SHGC as low as 0.21
With triple-pane glass and Low-E enhancements, Quaker windows can achieve excellent R-values and Solar Heat Gain Coefficients.
Quaker Pros
- Meets or exceeds ENERGY STAR for all climate zones
- Affordable lines have good thermal performance
- Multiple glazing and Low-E options available
Quaker Cons
- Can pay more for max energy-efficient triple glazing
- Limited low U-factors and SHGC without upgrades
Andersen Efficiency
From their dual-pane Fibrex windows to triple-pane glass options, Andersen products are engineered for energy efficiency and temperature insulation.
Key features that increase efficiency include:
- High-Performance Low-E4® glass that filters UV while letting light in
- Fibrex’s low thermal conductivity
- Weather-resistant sealants, gaskets, and barrier fins
- Optional triple glazing, Low-E coatings, argon gas fill
- Industry-leading U-Factors as low as 0.22 and SHGC as low as 0.17
Their innovative glazing technology sets Andersen apart when it comes to highly efficient windows.
Andersen Pros
- Innovative Low-E4® glass for unbeatable insulation
- Fibrex material never expands/contracts with temperature
- Exceptionally low U-factors and SHGC possible
- Triple glazing standard on some series
Andersen Cons
- Pay more for the most energy efficient glass and Fibrex frames
Overall, Andersen eeks out the win for maximum energy efficiency potential. But both brands offer excellent insulating windows.
Costs, Warranties, and Value Comparison
Let’s break down how Quaker and Andersen windows stack up in terms of upfront costs and long-term value.
Quaker Costs and Warranties
Quaker windows are affordably priced for the quality you get. Their Signature vinyl series starts around $250 per window installed. The higher-end Prestige line costs $500-$800 installed.
All Quaker windows come with a lifetime limited warranty on vinyl and aluminum materials and workmanship. Glass components have a 20-year warranty.
Quaker Pros
- Competitively priced versus other mid-tier brands
- Low-cost Signature series offers good value
- Lifetime warranty on materials and workmanship
Quaker Cons
- Upgrade costs add up for max efficiency features
- Less robust glass warranty than some brands
Andersen Costs and Warranties
As a premium brand, Andersen windows sit at the high end of the pricing spectrum. Expect to pay $600-$1,200 for a typical double-hung Fibrex window installed. Specialty lines cost even more.
However, you get robust coverage through their 20-year glass warranty, 10-year coverage on frame components, and 10 years on exterior finish.
Andersen Pros
- Prestige of owning a top tier brand
- Strong warranties provide peace of mind
- Get what you pay for in terms of features
Andersen Cons
- Budget-friendly options are limited
- Very expensive compared to Quaker and other brands
Value Comparison
When weighing affordability and overall value, Quaker windows shine as a mid-priced option with great quality and performance. Signature vinyl models offer tremendous value.
Andersen windows justify their high price tag for homeowners who want best-in-class efficiency, expansive style choices, and prestige. But you can get similar glass technology for less with Quaker.
Both brands offer excellent craftsmanship backed by strong warranties. For budget-focused homeowners, Quaker provides better overall value. Andersen is ideal if cost is less important than custom aesthetics and energy optimization.
Customer Reviews and Brand Reputation
Looking at unbiased customer reviews gives helpful insight into real-world quality and service delivered by each brand.
Quaker Reviews
Reviews for Quaker windows are overwhelmingly positive, with the brand earning 4+ star ratings across retail sites like Home Depot and Windows and Doors Store.
Positive feedback highlights their quality materials, easy maintenance, good value, and noticeable improvements in temperature control and noise reduction. Customers praise Quaker’s smooth installation process, knowledgeable associates, and responsive customer service.
Negative reviews are very rare and mostly related to individual installation or delivery issues rather than manufacturing defects.
Andersen Reviews
With a 100+ year legacy, Andersen has earned a reputation as the premier window original equipment manufacturer.
Their products receive rave reviews for beauty, durability, and energy savings.
Many reviews mention the excellence of Andersen’s materials, engineering, styling options, and craftsmanship.
Others praise their top-notch warranty service and responsive, friendly customer support. Negative feedback is uncommon.
Quaker Pros
- Consistent 4+ star ratings affirm quality and value
- Great reviews for energy savings and noise reduction
- Praise for excellent installation process and service
Quaker Cons
- Smaller brand lacks the legacy and name recognition of Andersen
Andersen Pros
- Longstanding reputation for window excellence
- Abundant rave reviews confirm premium quality
- Many positive remarks on aesthetics and custom options
- Great feedback on warranties and customer service
Andersen Cons
- Higher pricing prevents some negative value reviews
For both Quaker and Andersen, reviews indicate outstanding products that delight customers. Andersen edges out Quaker solely based on better brand recognition and prestige.
Which Is Better For Your Home?
So when comparing Quaker vs Andersen windows, how do you decide what’s right for your home and budget?
Choosing Quaker Windows
Quaker windows are ideal if you want:
- Mid-priced windows with excellent quality
- Good style options without luxury pricing
- Great thermal performance for energy savings
- Smooth installation and helpful customer service
- A mix of basic vinyl and higher-end aluminum-clad wood
Choosing Andersen Windows
Andersen windows are ideal if you want:
- The best of the best craftsmanship and materials
- Unique architectural aesthetics and customization
- Superior energy efficiency with advanced glazing
- Prestige of owning a luxury window brand
- Budget is not a concern and you value quality over price
While Andersen offers the pinnacle of window engineering and aesthetics, Quaker provides impressive quality and efficiency at more affordable pricing. Use this analysis to decide which brand aligns with your home style, performance needs, and budget.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Below are answers to some frequently asked questions about Quaker and Andersen windows:
Yes, Quaker windows are very good quality. They are made with premium vinyl formulations and aluminum-clad wood. Quaker windows have excellent ratings for thermal insulation, structural integrity, and durability.
Some window brands comparable to Andersen’s quality and features include Pella, Marvin, Milgard, Simonton, and Jeld-Wen. However, no brand fully matches Andersen’s extensive style and customization options.
Andersen, Pella, Marvin, and Milgard are consistently ranked among the best window brands overall based on quality, performance, features, and craftsmanship. Quaker offers similar construction quality at more affordable price points.
For windows specifically, Andersen and Marvin are the two leading high-end brands installed by contractors. Pella, Jeld-Wen, and Milgard are also excellent mid-range choices. For doors, top brands include Therma-Tru, Simpson, Masonite, and Pella.
Final Thoughts
Replacing your home’s windows is a significant investment. By understanding these two top brands, Quaker and Andersen, you can make the ideal choice based on your budget, aesthetic preferences, and performance needs.
Both companies make superbly crafted, insulating windows that will improve your home. Andersen excels at custom luxury quality, while Quaker provides impressive value at moderate prices.
Use this detailed side-by-side comparison to decide whether quality on a budget with Quaker or maximum prestige and efficiency with Andersen makes sense for your next window replacement project.