When it comes to selecting new siding for your home, ProVia and CertainTeed are two of the most popular and trusted brands on the market today. But how do you decide which option is right for your specific needs and budget?
This comprehensive guide examines the key differences between ProVia siding and CertainTeed siding to help you make an informed decision.
A Brief Comparison Table
To help you further differentiate ProVia vs. CertainTeed siding, here’s a detailed comparison of some of their most important features:
| Feature | ProVia | CertainTeed |
| Panel thickness | .044″ – .052″ | .040″ – .046″ |
| Texture options | Smooth, light woodgrain | Smooth, Brushed, Rustic, Sandblasted |
| Warranty | Lifetime limited, transferable | Lifetime limited |
| Fade protection | Yes | Yes |
| Hail protection | Yes | Yes (Monogram series only) |
| Rigidity | High – won’t sag or buckle easily | Moderate – more prone to dents |
| Color selection | 21 standard colors | 50+ standard colors |
| Wood grain finish | No, Cellular PVC only | Yes, ColorMax technology |
| Manufacturing location | Made in USA | Mostly overseas |
As you can see, ProVia offers thicker and more rigid panels that resist dents better and provide excellent fade protection. But CertainTeed gives you more finish options, a wider range of colors, and competitive pricing. Think about which features are must-haves for your particular home exterior.
Overview of ProVia Siding
Founded in 1977, ProVia is a family-owned manufacturer of windows, doors, siding, and other building products. Their vinyl siding line includes a range of styles and colors designed to suit both traditional and modern home exteriors. Here are some of the benefits and drawbacks of ProVia siding:
Pros:
- Wide selection of styles and colors – Choose from traditional clapboard or dutch lap siding, vertical board and batten, or shake and scallop designs in over 20 color options.
- DuraPlank and Structural Premium Panels – These rigid panels resist dents and help level uneven walls.
- Lifetime limited transferable warranty – Coverage includes fade and hail protection.
- Made in the USA – ProVia siding is manufactured in Ohio.
Cons:
- Premium pricing – ProVia sits at the higher end of the vinyl siding price spectrum.
- Limited availability – Sold primarily through exclusive distributors rather than big box stores.
- No wood grain options – For a natural wood look, you’ll need to upgrade to their Cellular PVC line.
Overall, ProVia offers a high-quality product backed by strong warranties. It’s best suited for homeowners who want robust, dent-resistant siding with a wide selection of colors.
Overview of CertainTeed Siding
Established over 100 years ago, CertainTeed is a leading manufacturer of roofing, siding, fencing, and other building materials. Their vinyl siding line provides numerous style and color options:
Pros:
- Broad product selection – Choose from clapboard, dutch lap, shakes, scallops, verticals, and more in over 50 colors.
- Realistic wood grain finishes – CertainTeed’s ColorMax technology recreates natural wood textures.
- Lifetime limited warranty – Coverage includes fade protection and hail damage.
- Wide availability – Sold at major home improvement stores and lumberyards.
Cons:
- Prone to dents – Their standard siding is not as rigid and impact-resistant as ProVia.
- Mixed reviews on quality – Some homeowners report issues with warped or cracking panels.
- Mostly manufactured overseas – CertainTeed siding is produced internationally, not in the USA.
CertainTeed is ideal if you want a broad selection of styles and colors at relatively affordable prices. Just be aware that the materials may not hold up as well over time compared to other brands.
Key Differences Between ProVia And CertainTeed Siding
Styles Offered
Both ProVia and CertainTeed offer all the most popular siding styles and profiles:
ProVia Siding Styles:
- Double 4″ clapboard
- Double 4.5″ dutch lap
- 8″ and 9″ vertical board and batten
- Cedar shake
- Scallop and half-round decorative accents
- Insulated panels, shakes, and scallops
- Structural Premium Panels
CertainTeed Siding Styles:
- Double 4” and Double 5” clapboard
- Double 4” and Double 5” dutch lap
- Double 6” clapboard
- 8” vertical board and batten
- Cedar impressions (shake and scallop)
- Beaded panels
- Insulated panels
No matter what aesthetic you’re going for, from traditional to contemporary, both brands offer plenty of design choices.
CertainTeed provides a few more unique options like their Regal Beaded siding.
But ProVia covers all the most popular looks that appeal to most homeowners.
Durability and Longevity
When evaluating siding, you want products that will hold up well for decades without fading, cracking, or becoming damaged. Here’s how ProVia and CertainTeed compare:
- Fade resistance – Both offer fade protection warranties to guard against color loss. ProVia warranties their colors for life while CertainTeed covers fading for 30 years. Real-world testing shows ProVia and CertainTeed colors performing well over many years.
- Hail protection – ProVia provides lifetime hail protection on their top-tier siding lines. For CertainTeed, only their premium Monogram series includes hail coverage.
- Impact resistance – ProVia’s thicker and denser panels resist dents from impacts better than standard CertainTeed siding. ProVia’s Structural Premium Panels are engineered to be extra rigid.
- Cracking/warping – Some homeowners report issues with CertainTeed siding warping or cracking after some years of exposure. ProVia panels appear more resistant to bending and buckling over the long-term.
Based on user reviews and the terms of their warranties, ProVia seems to have a slight edge in overall durability and longevity. But CertainTeed also makes quality products that will last when properly installed.
Cost Comparison
Since ProVia and CertainTeed target different segments of the market, their siding prices vary significantly:
- ProVia – As a premium brand, their siding costs range from $8-12 per square foot installed. This puts them amongst the most expensive vinyl options, but they offer a top-tier product.
- CertainTeed – Their siding costs $4-8 per square foot installed typically, which is an affordable to mid-range price point. You get strong value for the money with their products.
Other factors like special colors and textures, insulation, and professional installation will also affect the final costs.
Be sure to get detailed quotes before making any siding decisions.
Generally, CertainTeed is the more budget-friendly choice, while ProVia offers superior quality and performance for those who can afford the higher prices.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Laticrete Hydro Ban is a thin, liquid waterproofing membrane designed for wet areas like showers and bathrooms. It creates a complete water barrier that protects against leaks and moisture damage on finishes like tile and stone. Hydro Ban can be applied directly to substrates like cement board, concrete, mortar beds, and drywall. It dries to form a seamless rubber-like coating that stops water penetration behind tiles, helping prevent loose or damaged tiles, grout, and underlying materials.
ProVia is consistently ranked as a top siding manufacturer known for making high-quality, durable vinyl siding products. They only use premium raw materials and granules in an effort to produce some of the strongest and longest-lasting siding on the market. If properly installed, ProVia siding can maintain its appearance and resist dents, impacts, and water infiltration for decades. The company also backs their sidings with strong lifetime limited warranties. So while ProVia is on the pricier end, many homeowners find the quality and performance worth the extra investment.
Some of the best siding brands based on durability, appearance, warranties, and homeowner satisfaction include:
James Hardie – The top choice for fiber cement siding
Royal Building Products – Excellent wood-look siding options
ProVia – High-end vinyl with rigid, dent-resistant panels
Gentek – Affordable and attractive vinyl siding
Swiss Pearl – Porcelain tiles for a striking, modern look
CertainTeed makes solid quality vinyl and polymer siding that offers a wide selection of styles and colors at reasonable price points. Their products meet industry standards and provide durable, weather-resistant exteriors when properly installed. However, CertainTeed siding is not quite as impact resistant or rigid as premium brands. Some homeowners do experience issues like warping or cracking after some years. Their warranty and fade protection are also not as robust as options like ProVia. For the money, CertainTeed remains a good mid-range choice, but other brands offer superior performance and longevity.
ProVia is a family-owned, American company first founded by Walter and Gertrude Rastetter in 1977, headquartered in Sugarcreek, Ohio. Their son Martin Rastetter later became CEO of the company after gaining experience working in various departments. He helped expand ProVia’s product lines to include doors, windows, siding, stone, and decorative glass. His son Alex is the current Vice President of marketing, continuing the family legacy spanning over 40 years. From its beginnings, ProVia has stayed locally owned and operated while growing into one of the nation’s top manufacturers of building products. They take great pride in producing high-quality products from their state-of-the-art Ohio facility.
Final Thoughts
When choosing between ProVia and CertainTeed siding, there are good reasons to consider both of these top brands. CertainTeed offers more colors and wood grain options along with competitive pricing. Their products are a great value for budget-conscious homeowners.
However, ProVia rises above when it comes to durability and performance. Their thicker and denser panels resist dents, impacts, and warping better than standard CertainTeed siding based on real-world testing and reviews.
ProVia’s warranties are also stronger on fade and hail protection. So for those willing to invest more upfront, ProVia delivers very long-lasting, premium siding.
Ultimately, taking the time to understand these key differences allows you to make the best decision for your particular home. CertainTeed gives you more style choices at affordable prices, while ProVia emphasizes robust construction and longevity.
Weigh your priorities, look at product samples, read reviews, and get quotes. And choose the exceptional siding brand that meets your needs and expectations.
