For most homeowners, choosing new door knobs and handles is all about aesthetics – finding something that matches the style and finishes in your home. But there’s a lot more to consider to find the right hardware that will stand the test of time.
When it comes to durability and security, not all door knobs are created equal.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare two of the most popular door hardware brands on the market: Probrico and Kwikset. We’ll look at the key features, pros and cons, and help you decide which is the better brand for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Probrico | Kwikset |
| Security | Grade 3 residential security features like enforced levers and pick-resistant locks | Decent security from SecureScreen technology, some meet grade 2 standards |
| Durability | Solid brass or zinc alloy construction, minimum 80% metal content | Good durability but some affordable lines have less metal content |
| Style Options | Contemporary modern lever designs with fashion-forward finishes | Traditional and classic styles plus some contemporary looks |
| Price | $60 – $250+, positioned as a premium brand | $20 – $250, more budget-friendly options |
| Warranty | Lifetime mechanical and finish warranty | Lifetime warranty against defects and tarnishing |
| Ease of Installation | Easy retrofit with standard footprint, includes mounting hardware | Easy install, SmartKey allows re-keying without new hardware |
| Smart Home Integration | Currently no smart lock options | Multiple smart lock lines with app control, touch access |
| Quality Certifications | Meets or exceeds residential security standards, ADA compliant | Meets grade 2/3 standards, UL listed, ADA compliant |
Overview of Probrico and Kwikset
Probrico and Kwikset are both well-known names in door hardware that offer a wide range of styles and finishes.
Probrico is a German brand that specializes in high-end, European-style door levers and modern fashion handles.
They use premium materials like solid brass and zinc alloy.
Probrico is best known for lever-style handles with unique, contemporary designs.
Kwikset is one of the most recognized and trusted names in door knobs and handles in the U.S.
They offer entry-level to mid-range locksets in traditional and contemporary styles. Kwikset uses brass, zinc, and other alloys for durability and strength.
Key Differences Between Probrico And Kwikset Door Knobs
Both brands offer features like adjustable latches, different lock functions (privacy, passage, dummy), and ADA-compliant levers. But there are some key differences that we’ll explore in detail below.
- Security
One of the most important factors for exterior door knobs is security. You want hardware that will keep your home and family safe.
Probrico handles use high-quality materials and tamper-proof designs. Most of their exterior levers feature bump-proof operation, pick-resistant locks, and enforced lever stems. For maximum security, look for their Protec line that meets grade 3 residential security standards.
Kwikset is known for their SecureScreen technology that uses a patented grooved keyway system. This makes their locksets drill- and bump-resistant. Several Kwikset exterior handles also meet grade 2 residential security requirements. However, most standard Kwikset interior knobs do not have the same level of security.
For high-traffic or exterior doors, Probrico has the edge when it comes to security features. Kwikset still offers decent security for most applications. But for tamper-proof performance, Probrico is the winner.
- Durability
You want door hardware that will stand up to years of daily use without loosening, tarnishing, or breaking. Durability depends on the quality of materials and construction.
Probrico lever handles are made from solid brass or zinc alloy, with a minimum zinc content of 80%. These materials resist rust, corrosion, scratches, and tarnishing. Probrico uses stainless steel springs and mechanisms inside for added strength. Their advanced coating process ensures a durable, smooth finish.
Kwikset offers decent durability, but some of their more affordable lines use less metal content.
Solid brass and zinc handles in their Signature Series or SmartKey line will be the most durable.
Lower-end styles with less metal alloy may lose their finish, peel, and wear down faster.
Both meet residential grade 2 impact resistance standards.
But Probrico’s solid construction from premium materials gives it the advantage for long-lasting durability.
- Style Options
When updating your interior and exterior doors, you want hardware that matches your home’s style.
Probrico is known for modern, contemporary door levers with straight clean lines and geometric shapes. Their lever handles come in fashion-forward styles like minimalist, industrial, retro, and architecturally inspired looks. You’ll also find unique finishes like matte black, brushed gold, satin nickel, and more.
Kwikset offers traditional and classic designs across several handle lines, like the Logan, Audra, and Asana. But they also have contemporary styles like the Lumina and Contemporary lever models.
Their finishes include matte black, satin chrome, Venetian bronze, and brushed nickel. However, style options are more limited compared to Probrico.
If you have a contemporary or modern home, Probrico will have more on-trend lever handles to choose from. For traditional style interiors, either brand could work. But Kwikset has more classic designs to accent traditional architecture.
- Ease of Installation
Replacing door knobs and handles requires disassembling the lockset and installing the new hardware. You want something that goes in smoothly without complications.
Probrico handles use a standard base footprint for ease of installation. Their levers come with all the necessary mounting hardware and multi-point locks to easily retrofit existing doors. Clear instructions with diagrams are included.
Kwikset also uses a standard footprint and includes detailed instructions with each product. One advantage is that Kwikset’s patented SmartKey technology allows you to re-key the lock yourself in seconds without new hardware.
Overall, both Probrico and Kwikset go in fairly easily for DIY installation. For their SmartKey re-key technology, Kwikset has a slight advantage. But Probrico also offers easy installation with all necessary parts in the box.
- Price
Budget plays a role in choosing new door hardware. Prices vary based on materials, security features, finish, and style.
Probrico is positioned as a premium product, so their hardware costs more than standard Kwikset models. Expect to pay $60-$100 for most Probrico levers, and $125-$250+ for high-end designer styles.
Kwikset has more price options. Basic interior knobs and levers start around $20. Mid-range models cost $60-$100. High-end decorative styles can run up to $250.
If budget is a concern, Kwikset has more choices at lower price points. For high-end, designer door hardware, Probrico is competitive with premium Kwikset prices. Overall, Kwikset offers better value for money. But Probrico provides premium quality materials for the price.
- Warranty
A good manufacturer’s warranty provides peace of mind that your investment is protected long-term.
Probrico offers a lifetime mechanical and finish warranty that covers the original owner against material manufacturing defects.
Kwikset also offers outstanding warranty coverage. Their products are warranted for life against mechanical defects and tarnishing under normal residential use.
For warranty coverage, this category is a tie. Both Probrico and Kwikset offer exceptional lifetime warranties.
- Ease of Use
You want door hardware that looks beautiful but also works flawlessly every time you lock or unlock it.
Probrico handles are engineered for smooth operation and easy grip.
Even their modern lever styles maintain comfort and usability.
Curved levers require minimal effort to open from young children to the elderly.
Kwikset aims for comfort and simplicity in their handle designs.
Most styles have ergonomic leverage that reduces locking force.
But some more stylized luxury models sacrifice a bit of ease of use for form over function.
Probrico maintains both easy operation and modern styling in their lever designs. Kwikset has a slight disadvantage if you favor contemporary levers, which may require more force to operate.
- Smart Home Integration
Smart locks are the newest innovation, allowing you to control and monitor your home from your phone. If smart integration is important, that can guide your brand selection.
Kwikset has embraced smart technology with different lines that work with home automation systems. Their Kevo, Halo Touch, and SmartCode models all offer app control, electronic keypads, remote access, and touch-to-open features.
Probrico has so far stayed focused on style and security in their door hardware. At the moment, they do not offer smart-enabled knobs or levers.
For the latest smart home features like voice activation and scheduling, Kwikset is the clear leader in innovation. But Probrico builds security and durability into their old-school handles.
- Quality Testing and Certifications
Extensive product testing and third-party certifications show a commitment to quality and safety.
Probrico meets or exceeds all applicable DIN and ANSI/BHMA standards for grade 2 residential security, durability, and finish. Their handles also comply with ADA accessibility guidelines.
Kwikset locks are BHMA certified grade 2 or 3 for residential security. They also meet ADA compliance standards for lever styles. Kwikset products are UL listed for their high security and durability.
Both brands meet the latest domestic standards and regulatory requirements. When it comes to quality testing and certifications, this round is a draw. You can trust Probrico and Kwikset hardware is independently tested for safety and performance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
For premium quality and contemporary style, Probrico is one of the best options on the market. If budget is more of a concern, Kwikset provides reliable security and durability at lower prices. Schlage and Baldwin also offer quality door knobs and levers at varying price points.
Solid brass and stainless steel handles will be the most durable long-term. Brands like Probrico, Emtek, and Von Morris use high percentages of brass and zinc alloys to resist rust, tarnish, and normal wear and tear. Avoid lower quality plated plastic handles that will break down faster.
For front entry doors, always opt for grade 2 or higher security features like a double cylinder deadbolt, reinforced strike plate, and bump and pick resistant keyway. Classic brands like Schlage and Baldwin provide durable security. Or choose high-end Probrico, Emtek, and Rocky Mountain handles for premium quality.
Satin nickel, polished chrome, and stainless steel finishes are the most durable. They resist scratches, tarnish, and rust. Polished brass and oil rubbed bronze will wear over time, showing natural patina. Painted or powder coated finishes can chip or peel. Avoid these less durable finishes on high-use exterior doors or entryways.
Final Thoughts
For exceptional quality and security, Probrico narrowly beats out Kwikset as our top pick. Probrico’s durable solid metal construction, high-end finishes, contemporary lever styles, and tamper-proof designs make them hard to beat for premium door hardware.
However, Kwikset is still an excellent choice if you want traditional styling, smart features, or more budget-friendly options. Kwikset offers decent security, durability, and warranty coverage for the price. Their smart locks also add convenience if home automation is a priority.
Ultimately, your decision comes down to your priorities. If cost is a factor, Kwikset provides reliable quality at lower price points. For unmatched security, contemporary design, and durability, invest in premium Probrico levers. Either option will provide style and performance for years to come.
