When it comes time to replace your home’s air conditioning system, you’ll likely be choosing between the two biggest names in the business – Payne and Trane. These two HVAC giants have been going head to head for decades, with both offering high-efficiency air conditioners packed with features.
But which one is right for your home?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Payne and Trane AC models side-by-side so you can weigh the pros and cons. We’ll look at efficiency ratings, available features, warranties, prices, and other important factors.
Our goal is to help you make the best decision for your home’s comfort and cooling needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | Payne | Trane |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency Ratings | 14-18 SEER | 15-21 SEER |
| 11-13 EER | 11-17 SEER | |
| Features | Comfort-FlexTM ComfortHeatTM NexiaTM controls Variable-speed fans | ComfortLinkTM II Variable-speed compressors Spine FinTM coils ClimateCueTM |
| Reliability | 10-year parts warranty 10-year compressor warranty | 10-year parts warranty 10-year compressor warranty on XR models |
| Smart Thermostat | NexiaTM controls | ComfortLinkTM II |
| Noise Levels | 72-76 decibels | As low as 69 decibels |
| Prices | Entry: $2,500 – $4,000 Mid: $4,000 – $5,500 High: $5,500 – $7,000 | Entry: $4,000 – $6,000 Mid: $6,000 – $8,000 High: $8,000 – $12,000 |
Key Differences Between Payne And Trane Air Conditioners
Efficiency Ratings: SEER And EER
When shopping for a new air conditioner, one of the most important factors is energy efficiency.
The higher the SEER (Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio) and EER (Energy Efficiency Ratio) ratings, the more efficient the AC unit.
Payne and Trane both offer models across a range of efficiencies.
Most Payne central AC units have SEER ratings between 14 to 18, while Trane has models ranging from 15 to 21 SEER.
The minimum SEER rating allowed today is 14, so both brands meet and exceed the baseline. However, Trane does have more options at the higher end of the spectrum for maximum efficiency.
EER measures how efficiently an AC unit can cool your home in the moment, rather than seasonally like SEER. Most Payne units range from 11 to 13 EER, while Trane ACs span from 11 up to a very impressive 17 EER. Again, Trane pulls ahead in the top end with its most efficient XR units.
Advantage: Trane for having more models available at higher SEER and EER ratings, resulting in the potential for greater energy savings. But Payne still offers efficient options that can help reduce your summer power bills.
Features and Functions
When you’re paying a premium for a new AC system, you want it loaded with features that provide smart cooling, convenience and custom control. Payne and Trane equip their air conditioners with proprietary technologies as well as smart home integration.
Payne AC Features
- Comfort-FlexTM: Allows gradual ramp-up and ramp-down of cooling capacity to maintain steady temps instead of frequent starts and stops.
- ComfortHeatTM: Provides efficient supplemental gas heating from the same unit as the AC.
- NexiaTM controls: Allow remote adjustment and monitoring of the AC via smartphone, tablet or computer.
- Variable-speed fans: For quieter, more consistent airflow and humidity control.
Trane AC Features
- ComfortLinkTM II: Communicates with the thermostat to optimize performance and includes remote access.
- Variable-speed compressors: Adjusts cooling capacity based on conditions for efficiency and comfort.
- Spine FinTM coils: Enhanced surface area for maximum heat transfer and dehumidification.
- ClimateCueTM: Uses weather data to adjust cooling based on humidity for comfort.
When comparing both brands side-by-side, Trane does have the edge in terms of innovative features and advanced functions. Technologies like their variable-speed compressors and ClimateCue humidity control allow for finer temperature and humidity management.
Advantage: Trane for a wider array of robust features to customize and optimize cooling performance.
Reliability and Durability
You don’t want to invest in a new air conditioner, only to have to replace it in a few years.
Payne and Trane both build durable units that can last over a decade with proper maintenance.
They offer similar warranties on parts and compressors to back up their claims.
Payne central AC units have a 10-year parts limited warranty. Compressors are covered for 10 years.
Trane provides a 10-year parts limited warranty on their AC equipment.
They also offer a 10-year limited warranty on compressors for their XR units, while lower-tier compressors are covered for 5 years.
Both brands use galvanized steel cabinets and louvered coil guards to protect the interior components from weather and debris. Copper tubing and aluminum fin coils add durability while resisting corrosion. Overall, Payne and Trane are on par when it comes to build quality and longevity.
Advantage: Draw – Payne and Trane seem to be on equal footing for durability, parts warranties, and lifespan.
Smart Thermostats
To get the most out of your high-efficiency AC system, you need an equally high-tech thermostat to control it. Payne and Trane both offer app-connected smart thermostats that communicate with your system.
Payne’s Nexia Smart Home Bridge gives you remote access to adjust temps, set schedules, and monitor energy use from anywhere.
It works with Amazon Alexa and Google Assistant too. Models with Comfort-Flex and variable-speed components respond to commands for more precise management.
Meanwhile, Trane offers their ComfortLink II Communicating Control touchscreen thermostat to pair with compatible AC units.
It makes automated adjustments to optimize performance and humidity control. You can also tweak settings and scheduling from your smartphone on-the-go.
Both brands provide robust smart thermostat options to get the most out of advanced functions like variable speeds and remote access. It’s a draw here.
Advantage: Draw – Payne and Trane have comparable smart thermostat solutions for convenient control.
Installation and Maintenance
The installation and long-term maintenance of your AC system does impact your total cost and satisfaction. Payne and Trane units are each professionally installed by licensed technicians. Shop around with local HVAC contractors to compare quotes.
Standard maintenance for both brands includes:
- Replacing filters monthly during cooling season
- Having a yearly tune-up by a technician
- Cleaning the outdoor condenser unit
- Checking refrigerant charge
- Inspecting electric terminals, wiring and controls
Payne may have a leg up for DIY repairs, as their units utilize universally sourced parts that are easy to obtain.
Trane ACs have some proprietary components only available through dealers.
Overall maintenance costs will be comparable between the two though.
Slight Advantage: Payne for using more standardized parts that homeowners can self-source for repairs.
Noise Levels
You want your AC system to keep you cool, not keep you awake with noisy operation. Newer central air conditioners are much quieter than older models, but you still want to minimize noise. Variable-speed components help to lower sound levels.
Most Payne air conditioners have sound ratings between 72 to 76 decibels, making them about as loud as a vacuum cleaner. Trane XR units are rated for sound as low as 69 decibels thanks to variable-speed fans and compressors. That’s comparable to the ambient noise level of a typical conversation.
Advantage: Trane offers the lowest sound ratings, making their XR series some of the quietest ACs available.
Costs and Pricing
Of course, price is a major factor when shopping for a new AC system for your home. You want maximum value for your budget. Payne and Trane units range from budget-tier to premium:
Payne AC Prices
- Entry-level: $2,500 – $4,000
- Mid-range: $4,000 – $5,500
- High-end: $5,500 – $7,000
Trane AC Prices
- Entry-level: $4,000 – $6,000
- Mid-range: $6,000 – $8,000
- High-end: $8,000 – $12,000
As you can see, Trane commands a premium price over comparable Payne units. However, the higher SEER ratings and robust features may justify the added cost – if it fits your budget. Get multiple bids to compare exact costs for your home’s needs.
Advantage: Payne offers more affordable AC systems for budget-conscious homeowners.
Payne And Trane Air Conditioners: Which Is Better For You?
So when comparing Payne vs. Trane AC units side-by-side, which brand comes out on top? Here’s a quick recap of our key findings:
Payne Pros:
- More affordable pricing
- Easier to self-source repair parts
- 10-year compressor warranty
Trane Pros:
- Higher SEER and EER efficiency
- Advanced features like ClimateCue and variable-speeds
- Ultra-quiet sound levels
- 10-year warranty on all XR components
For maximum long-term savings on energy bills, Trane AC systems win out with their higher efficiency ratings. Homeowners concerned about upfront costs may prefer a Payne unit for the lower price tag.
Make sure to get multiple quotes from local contractors, as installation costs can also vary. Verify warranties, expected lifespan, and sound levels. And choose a compatible smart thermostat to control the system.
By weighing all these factors against your budget and needs, you can determine whether Payne or Trane is the better fit your home. And you’ll stay comfortably cool for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Payne is considered a good and reliable brand, known for more affordable prices. They offer energy efficient models, durable components, and good warranties. While not considered premium, Payne ACs are solid mid-range options backed by years in the industry.
Yes, Payne is owned by Carrier Corporation, a leading HVAC brand. Carrier also owns Bryant ACs. So you get the engineering and technical expertise of Carrier, but at lower price points than the Carrier brand itself commands.
Trane is widely regarded as one of the top air conditioner brands in terms of innovation, efficiency, and reliability. Their most advanced XR series ACs offer the highest SEER ratings and quietest operations. But their premium pricing puts Trane out of some homeowner’s budgets.
Yes, Trane is positioned as a premium, high-end AC brand. Their prices are typically higher than Payne, Rheem, and other mid-range brands. But you’re paying for those best-in-class efficiencies and acoustic designs. For homeowners who can afford it, Trane ACs represent the top tier in performance.
The Bottom Line
At the end of the day, both Payne and Trane offer high-quality AC systems that will keep your home cool for over a decade. Payne provides affordable and efficient options, while Trane leans towards maximum performance and advanced features.
As long as you size your air conditioner properly and perform yearly maintenance, you can expect years of reliable cooling from both brands.
Focus on finding the best mix of efficiency, sound levels, and price that fits your household’s cooling needs and budget. By following this Payne and Trane air conditioner guide, you’ll be able to make the ideal choice to beat the heat this summer.