When it comes to keeping pests at bay, more and more homeowners are looking for safe and effective solutions that don’t require harsh chemicals. Two popular natural pest control products on the market are NatureTek and Pestie. But how do you choose between them?
Here we’ll take an in-depth look at the pros and cons of NatureTek and Pestie to help you decide which is right for your needs.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | NatureTek | Pestie |
| Active Ingredients | Clove oil, cottonseed oil, thyme oil | Peppermint oil, lemongrass oil, rosemary oil |
| Scent | Strong, aromatic | Mild, pleasant |
| Pest Coverage | Spiders, roaches, ants, fleas, etc | Spiders, roaches, ants, fleas, etc |
| Usage | Indoor and outdoor | Indoor and outdoor |
| Application Method | Trigger spray or concentrate | Trigger spray or concentrate |
| Dilution Ratio | 1:9 concentrate to water | 1:4 concentrate to water |
| Speed of Effect | Fast knockdown and kill | Slower kill time |
| Duration of Control | Up to 2 weeks | 7-14 days |
| Toxicity | Non-toxic, kid/pet safe | Non-toxic, kid/pet safe |
| Price Per Bottle | $25 (16 oz concentrate)<br>$9 (20 oz trigger spray) | $15-20 (16 oz concentrate)<br>$6 (20 oz trigger spray) |
| Availability | Primarily online | Online and major retailers |
Overview of NatureTek
NatureTek is an all-natural pest control spray made from plant-based ingredients like clove oil, cottonseed oil, and thyme oil. It claims to kill and repel common household pests like ants, roaches, spiders, fleas, and more.
Some key features of NatureTek include:
- Made from natural plant oils – no harsh chemicals
- Kills and repels insects on contact
- Safe for use around kids and pets
- Pleasant natural scent
- Can be used indoors and outdoors
- Easy trigger spray bottle for application
The active ingredients in NatureTek are classified by the EPA as minimum risk and exempt from normal pesticide registration.
The spray works by suffocating insects and disrupting their nervous systems.
According to the company, NatureTek starts working immediately and provides pest control for up to two weeks when applied thoroughly. It’s designed to be long-lasting without leaving any chemical residue behind.
Overview of Pestie
Like NatureTek, Pestie is a natural pest control product made from plant-based ingredients. Key oils in Pestie include peppermint oil, lemongrass oil, and rosemary oil.
Here are some of the main features of Pestie:
- Natural formula derived from plants
- Kills and repels common pests
- Safe for use around children and pets
- Light fresh scent
- Can be used inside the home and yard
- Available as a ready-to-use spray or concentrate
- Provides pest control lasting 7-14 days
The active ingredients in Pestie are classified as minimum risk by the EPA. The product works by irritating pests’ respiratory systems and interfering with their ability to detect food sources.
Pestie claims to kill insects on contact and keep working to prevent future infestations for up to two weeks. The spray residue is non-toxic but can be cleaned up with soap and water if desired.
Comparing Effectiveness
When it comes to effectiveness, both NatureTek and Pestie products can work well for controlling common household pests thanks to their natural active ingredients. However, they may differ in how quickly they work and how long the pest control effects last.
Some users have reported NatureTek taking effect more rapidly, with insects dying within minutes of application. Its longer-lasting plant oils seem to provide pest control for up to 2 weeks. Pestie may take a bit longer to kill bugs after initial spraying, but maintains pest repelling effects for 1-2 weeks.
For severe infestations, NatureTek’s high concentration of clove oil may provide stronger knockdown and kill power compared to Pestie. For general pest prevention, both products seem capable of providing long-lasting control. Proper application is key for both sprays.
It’s difficult to say definitively whether one product is more effective than the other, as results can vary based on the specific pests being treated and infestation levels. However, users of both sprays report satisfactory pest control when used properly.
Also Read: Comparison of Bifen IT And Bifen XTS Pesticides.
Comparing Active Ingredients
The active ingredients in NatureTek and Pestie work in similar ways to kill and repel insects, but there are some differences:
NatureTek’s key ingredients:
- Clove oil – disrupts nervous system, suffocates insects
- Cottonseed oil – smothers exoskeleton
- Thyme oil – repels pests
Pestie’s key ingredients:
- Peppermint oil – irritates respiratory system
- Lemongrass oil – repels insects
- Rosemary oil – disrupts nervous system
While the specific oils used vary, both products rely on plant-based ingredients that are irritating and potentially fatal to common household pests but gentle for human and pet exposure.
NatureTek’s very high clove oil content may give it an edge in potency and kill rate for severe infestations. Pestie offers a different blend of repellent oils that users report provides sufficient pest control.
Evaluating Safety
When using any pest control product, safety is a top concern, especially in homes with children and pets. Both NatureTek and Pestie are designed to be low-risk compared to traditional chemical pesticides.
NatureTek uses food-grade oils and EPA minimum risk active ingredients.
The company states its products are child and pet safe when used as directed.
However, some users note the strong scent from the clove oil can be initially overpowering.
Pestie is also classified as minimum risk by the EPA.
The company says its products can be used safely around kids and animals. Some users describe the peppermint and lemongrass scent as pleasant and less intense than some natural pest sprays.
Neither spray contains chemical pesticides, volatile organic compounds (VOCs) or synthetic ingredients of significant toxicological concern. They both appear to be relatively safe options for natural pest control, although basic precautions like keeping kids and pets away during application are still recommended.
Comparing Price and Availability
When shopping for natural pest control products, price and availability may also be important factors.
NatureTek tends to be a bit more expensive than Pestie. A 16 oz bottle of NatureTek concentrate costs around $25, while Pestie concentrate in a similar size bottle ranges from $15-20.
The ready-to-use trigger spray bottles cost more for both products. NatureTek’s trigger spray is around $9 per 20 oz bottle, and Pestie’s trigger spray costs about $6 per 20 oz.
In terms of availability, both products can be purchased from major online retailers like Amazon as well as from the manufacturer’s website. NatureTek may be slightly harder to find stocked in physical stores. Pestie appears to have better brick-and-mortar retail availability in home improvement stores like Home Depot.
Overall, Pestie comes in a bit cheaper than NatureTek, and may be easier to find in local stores for quicker access. But NatureTek is competitively priced for a natural option and available online.
Ease of Use
NatureTek and Pestie both earn high marks for ease of use thanks to their ready-to-use trigger spray bottles. For basic pest control, you can simply point and spray either product in problem areas without mixing or mess.
The concentrates allow for more flexibility in dilution and application methods. NatureTek requires a higher dilution ratio of 1 part concentrate to 9 parts water. Pestie can be diluted at a 1:4 concentrate-to-water ratio.
When applying the concentrated liquids, follow the label instructions carefully for both products. NatureTek may have a slightly steeper learning curve for first-time users to get the dilution right. Pestie’s flexibility in dilution makes it a bit simpler to mix up.
For maintenance pest prevention, the trigger spray bottles provide convenience and simplicity. NatureTek and Pestie are both easy-to-use, beginner-friendly pest control options.
Pros and Cons of NatureTek
NatureTek Pros:
- Made with all natural plant oils
- No harsh chemicals or pesticides
- Pleasant smelling formula
- Can be used indoors and outdoors
- Kills and repels common household pests
- Starts working quickly according to users
- Provides 2 weeks pest protection
NatureTek Cons:
- Concentrate requires 9:1 dilution ratio
- Can have strong smell initially
- More expensive than some competitors
- May need reapplication for severe infestations
- Limited retail availability in stores
Pros and Cons of Pestie
Pestie Pros:
- Natural plant-based active ingredients
- Safe to use around kids and pets
- Light fresh scent
- Easy 1:4 dilution ratio for concentrate
- Kills and repels common pests
- Provides 7-14 days of pest control
- More affordable than some natural options
- Sold in major retail stores
Pestie Cons:
- Takes longer to kill insects than some natural sprays
- May require reapplication for heavy infestations
- Not as long lasting as NatureTek (7-14 days vs 2 weeks)
- Primary packaging only available online
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Based on user experiences and product comparisons, NatureTek seems to provide slightly stronger insect knockdown and kill power than Pestie overall. Its higher clove oil content rapidly kills insects on contact. However, both are capable natural insecticides.
The plant oil ingredients in NatureTek and Pestie provide effective pest control without harsh chemicals. Both use food-grade EPA minimum risk active ingredients. NatureTek may offer longer-lasting control while Pestie is more affordable. Ultimately the “best” option depends on your needs.
Yes, Pestie is considered child and pet safe when used as directed. Its natural plant oil ingredients have low toxicity for humans. However, it’s always smart to keep infants away from the area during application until the spray has dried.
Pestie claims to provide pest control and repelling for 7-14 days after application. Results may vary based on environment factors and severity of infestation. Reapplication every 1-2 weeks is recommended for ongoing pest prevention.
The Bottom Line
For natural pest control that’s safe and effective, both NatureTek and Pestie are great options to consider. While they have slightly different active ingredients and longevity, they rely on plant oils to knock down and repel pests without toxic chemicals.
NatureTek may be the way to go if you want immediate insect knockdown and up to 2 weeks of protection. Pestie offers an affordably-priced option for 7-14 days control. Both are beginner-friendly sprays that are easy to use in trigger bottle form.
At the end of the day, you can’t go wrong with either NatureTek or Pestie for natural, non-toxic pest control in your home. Evaluate your exact needs and budget to decide which solution fits best.
With regular reapplication, both products provide a safe way to keep annoying pests at bay.