Making the decision between Mr Glass and PGT impact windows can be tricky. Both companies offer high-quality impact-resistant windows, but there are some key differences you’ll want to consider.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Mr Glass and PGT windows on factors like price, warranties, efficiency, styles, and more. Read on to determine which is the better choice for protecting and enhancing your home.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Mr Glass | PGT |
| Frame Material | Frameless glass only | Vinyl, aluminum, or composite |
| Glass Options | Single or insulated double pane | Wide range including laminated, tinted, Low-E |
| Impact Resistance | Meet Florida standards | Meet Florida standards |
| Efficiency | Single pane not efficient; double pane better | Wide range from standard to highly efficient |
| Appearance | Sleek, uniform exterior | More styles and customization |
| Installation | Homeowner hires contractor | Factory-authorized installers |
Overview of Mr Glass and PGT
First, let’s start with a quick rundown on each company and their windows:
Mr Glass is a Florida-based company that exclusively manufactures, installs, and warranties impact resistant glass windows and doors.
They offer both single and double pane glass options. Mr Glass windows come with a lifetime warranty on materials and 10 years on labor.
PGT is among the largest manufacturers of impact-resistant windows and doors in the U.S.
They produce both vinyl and aluminum frames in addition to glass. PGT is based in Florida and offers a lifetime limited warranty on most of their products.
Key Differences Between Mr Glass And PGT Impact Windows
Now that we’ve introduced both brands, let’s delve into a detailed feature comparison.
Impact Resistance
The main reason homeowners choose PGT or Mr Glass is for protection against hurricane-force winds, flying debris, intruders, and more.
Both companies offer hurricane-proof impact windows that can withstand debris flying at high speeds. These windows meet the stringent Florida Building Code standards for impact resistance.
PGT and Mr Glass both have extensive testing reports to back up their claims of impact resistance. Both brands’ windows can withstand objects like a 9-pound 2×4 piece of lumber traveling at 34 mph.
Impact resistance depends somewhat on the window frame material too. Mr Glass only uses glass, while PGT offers vinyl and aluminum framed windows. Vinyl frames tend to hold up better than aluminum under heavy wind and debris loads.
Overall, PGT and Mr Glass are quite evenly matched when it comes to impact resistance. Both earn high marks in independent tests.
Glass Options
Mr Glass, as the name implies, focuses exclusively on glass windows and doors. Their impact resistant glass comes in two main options:
- Single pane – This consists of one thicker pane of impact-resistant glass. It’s the more affordable choice.
- Insulated double pane – Here, two panes of glass surround an insulating air gap. This improves sound dampening and thermal efficiency.
PGT provides a wider range of glass options, including:
- Clear impact-resistant glass
- Tinted or reflective glass
- Insulated glass with argon gas fill
- Laminated glass for added strength
- Sound control glass
PGT lets you customize the glass to control sun, heat, glare, sound, and security. Mr Glass doesn’t offer quite as much customization.
Window Frames
Mr Glass only provides glass windows and doors without frames. The glass is set directly into the window opening.
With PGT, you get to choose from vinyl or aluminum frames.
Vinyl frames hold up better against coastal weather and resist rotting, swelling, shrinking, and warping.
But aluminum frames are extremely strong and durable.
Frames add to the installation cost but provide added protection and architectural appeal. It’s a matter of personal preference whether you want a frameless glass window or vinyl/aluminum-framed window.
Efficiency
Energy efficiency is another consideration when comparing PGT vs Mr Glass.
Mr Glass single pane windows are not the most insulating option. But their insulated double pane glass offers impressive efficiency. Just be prepared to pay more for it.
Many PGT window styles come standard with efficient insulated glass. And you can upgrade to options like Low-E coatings and argon gas fill to boost efficiency further.
If maximizing energy savings is a priority, PGT windows tend to offer greater efficiency across more styles. Mr Glass can meet efficiency needs as well with their double pane glass.
Appearance
Impact-resistant windows don’t have to look industrial or out of place on a home. Modern manufacturing methods allow for attractive windows that also provide protection.
Mr Glass windows have a very sleek, uniform appearance from the exterior since you’re just seeing a sheet of glass. No grids or muntins interrupt the view. The interior look depends on the frame and trim details the contractor builds.
With PGT windows, you get more options for colors and architectural details:
- Numerous color choices for vinyl or aluminum framing
- Grids, muntins, and simulated divided lights
- Brickmould, 3-1/4” flat, or block frame styles
- Matching casement, single hung, sliding, fixed, and picture windows
If a certain exterior look is important for complementing your home’s style, PGT provides more aesthetic customization.
Installation Process
Another difference between Mr Glass and PGT windows is the installation process.
Since Mr Glass manufactures the glass only, you must hire your own contractor to remove old windows, build frames, and install the Mr Glass products properly. There’s an added layer of coordination and responsibility on the homeowner to ensure quality installation.
With PGT windows, the entire unit arrives prefabricated and ready to install. PGT has an extensive network of authorized dealers and installers who are trained to provide quality workmanship.
Depending on your needs, hiring your own contractor or using PGT’s installer network has pros and cons. As long as the contractor has experience with impact windows specifically, either approach can result in successful installation.
Pricing Considerations
Let’s discuss the cost of these two brands:
Mr Glass windows are cheaper upfront than comparably sized PGT units. Since you’re only buying the glass itself, there’s significant cost savings over a prefabricated window.
However, since you need to budget for custom construction of frames and installation, the overall project cost can exceed factory windows. And Mr Glass’ limited warranties may require paying for glass replacement if issues arise.
PGT windows carry a higher initial price, but that covers the glass, frames, and installation. Their lifetime warranty on glass materials also provides peace of mind. And factory-controlled manufacturing can result in more consistent quality.
These are just generalizations though. You need an itemized quote comparison to determine the true cost difference for your specific project.
Both PGT and Mr Glass also offer mitigation discounts for homeowners fortifying against hurricanes. This can help offset some upfront pricing.
Warranties
Let’s quickly summarize the warranties:
- Mr Glass provides a lifetime limited warranty on materials and 10 years coverage on labor.
- PGT offers lifetime warranties on most vinyl and aluminum window components, covering materials, workmanship, and accidental glass breakage.
PGT provides stronger assurances against defects and flaws down the road. But Mr Glass still offers decent coverage compared to standard residential windows.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Both PGT and CGI offer excellent impact-resistant windows that meet the toughest hurricane standards. PGT is the larger company known for their extensive testing and warranties. CGI has been around for over 20 years and offers more contemporary frame styles. Overall PGT edges out CGI slightly on reputation, number of installations, and service footprint. But both are great options.
Mr Glass makes a quality impact-resistant glass product that provides protection against debris, intruders, and noise. Their insulated double pane glass also offers good efficiency. As long as you have a competent installer, Mr Glass windows are a cost-effective option. The lifetime warranty on materials also provides peace of mind. Just be prepared to coordinate contractors and accept more responsibility during installation.
Yes, impact windows come in a few standard protection grades. The main ratings are:
Large missile impact – Meets code for hurricane-prone regions. Withstands debris like 9-pound 2x4s at 50 feet per second.
Small missile impact – Protects against smaller objects like gravel and tools. Meets codes for inland areas.
Basic impact – Guards against wind-borne debris. More of a moderate level of protection.
Florida and coastal homes generally need large missile protection. Further inland, small missile may suffice. Always check local codes.
No, PGT windows are designed to withstand wind-borne debris and forceful blunt impacts. But no residential impact window can stop high velocity rounds. For ballistic protection, you would need bullet-resistant glass or polycarbonate sheets designed specifically to stop bullets. Impact-resistant does not equal bulletproof.
Final Thoughts
Now that we’ve compared these two brands in depth, let’s boil it down to a final verdict:
For overall value, product quality, and worry-free installation, PGT is the winner for most homeowners. The inclusion of frames, expansive warranty, efficiency features, and professional installers make PGT a great choice if within your budget.
However, the lower upfront cost of Mr Glass is an attractive advantage for many. As long as you hire an experienced contractor and understand the limitations of DIY-style installation, Mr Glass can also be a good option.
Ultimately, considering your own priorities for cost, efficiency, installation needs, and aesthetics will determine whether PGT or Mr Glass is better for protecting your home from storms while enhancing its comfort and beauty. Carefully weigh the pros and cons before making this important investment.
