If you’re in the market for new windows, two big names you may be considering are Lindsay and Marvin. Both companies make high-quality windows designed to stand the test of time.
But there are some key differences between these brands that are worth exploring.
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Lindsay and Marvin windows to help you decide which is the better choice for your home. We’ll look at factors like durability, energy efficiency, cost, aesthetics, customization options, warranties, and more. Let’s dive in!
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Lindsay | Marvin |
| Cost | $300 – $800 on average; lower cost | $600 – $1,500+ on average; higher cost |
| Materials | Vinyl frames | Ultrex fiberglass, wood, or fiberglass-clad wood frames |
| Energy Efficiency | Very good, meet ENERGY STAR standards | Excellent, exceed ENERGY STAR standards |
| Customization | Moderate customization available | Extremely customizable, made-to-order |
| Aesthetics | 9 exterior colors, woodgrain interior finishes | Many exterior color and interior finish options |
| Warranties | Lifetime limited; non-prorated | 20/10 coverage; transferable limited lifetime |
| Glass | ThermaStar insulated glass units | Wide range of premium glazing from Cardinal |
| Weather Resistance | Excellent through fusion welded corners | Excellent through precision construction |
| Screens | Come standard on most windows | Wide range of screen options available |
Key Differences Between Lindsay And Marvin Windows
- Durability and Longevity
When investing in new windows, you want them to last. Durability and longevity are key.
Lindsay windows are known for their toughness and durability.
They use an insulated glass option called ThermaStar by PPG.
This glass unit has an insulating foam spacer between the panes to reduce heat and cold transfer.
The foam spacer also adds rigidity and strength.
Independent tests show ThermaStar glass units can withstand 11,000 cycles of opening and closing without seal failure.
Marvin windows also use top-quality insulated glass units, often with Cardinal’s LoE366 glass. The dual-pane or triple-pane construction adds insulation. Marvin windows are built from strong ultrex fiberglass or wood. Their fusion-welded frames and sashes make them highly durable and long-lasting.
Both Lindsay and Marvin windows are engineered to hold up well over time. But Marvin’s wood options may require more maintenance to keep looking pristine.
- Energy Efficiency
Energy efficient windows help reduce heating and cooling costs and make your home more comfortable.
Lindsay offers excellent energy efficiency, with most of their double hung and casement windows earning ENERGY STAR certification. This means they meet or exceed the latest energy efficiency guidelines for U.S. windows.
Key efficiency features include ThermaStar insulated glass, fusion-welded vinyl frames, silicone foam weatherstripping, and multi-chambered frame construction.
Marvin windows also offer stellar energy efficiency. Their ultrex fiberglass windows deliver excellent thermal performance. Many Marvin window collections meet or exceed ENERGY STAR qualifications.
Efficiency features include low-E coated glass, argon gas filled glass units, weatherstripping, and energy-efficient frame materials.
Both brands offer triple pane windows for even better insulation in extreme climates. Ultimately, both companies make windows that will help reduce energy costs. But Marvin may have a slight performance edge.
- Cost and Value
Let’s talk price. There’s a considerable price difference between Lindsay and Marvin windows on average.
Lindsay is the more affordable option.
Their windows cost anywhere from $300 to $800 on average depending on the size, type, and features.
This makes them an attractive choice for homeowners on a tighter budget.
You can get a high-performance vinyl window for a reasonable price.
Marvin windows range from $600 on the low end to $1,500 or more on the high end.
Their ultrex fiberglass and wood windows come at a premium price. But you may get better durability and a longer lifespan that offsets the higher initial cost over time.
When it comes to value for what you pay, Lindsay is likely the better option for those looking for good quality at a more affordable price point. Marvin does offer superior craftsmanship and performance though.
- Aesthetics and Appearance
Let’s move on to aesthetics. What style and look options do Lindsay and Marvin offer?
Lindsay windows are only available in vinyl. But their vinyl comes in nine attractive exterior colors. So you still get some nice style options beyond basic white. Their windows feature contoured, sculpted frames for a more refined appearance.
Light oak, dark oak, and cherry woodgrain interior vinyl finishes are also available.
Marvin offers far more material and aesthetic options. Their windows come in ultrex fiberglass, wood, or a wood-fiberglass combo. You can design a truly custom window, choosing from dozens of exterior colors, interior finishes, hardware, and divided lite patterns.
Unique glass options are also available, like textured or smoked glass. Overall, Marvin offers superior aesthetic appeal.
- Customization and Options
Customization potential is important too.
How easily can you tailor the windows to your needs?
Lindsay windows come in standard sizes and options designed to fit most homes.
Their Made-to-Order program allows you to customize size, energy features, hardware, and other options.
But heavily customized windows can affect cost and lead times.
So while Lindsay offers some customization, it’s not as flexible as other brands.
Marvin is the clear winner when it comes to customization. They are essentially a made-to-order manufacturer, built to your exact specifications.
You can select custom sizes down to 1/8 inch increments and design the perfect window for your architectural needs. Their expansive product line and design options make unlimited customization possible.
- Glass and Glazing Options
The type of glass used in the window can impact appearance, durability, insulation, and other factors. Let’s compare Lindsay vs. Marvin’s glass and glazing options.
Lindsay windows feature ThermaStar insulated glass units made by PPG. This high-end glass offers excellent thermal efficiency and strength. Most ThermaStar options have Low-E coatings and argon gas fills for improved insulation.
An internal foam spacer lends structural integrity. Triple pane units are also available.
Marvin also uses top-tier glass products from Cardinal and other brands. Low-E coatings and argon gas fills are standard. Marvin’s specialty glazing options go far beyond the norm though.
You can choose textured glass, decorative glass, triple pane, and even Quad glazing for maximum efficiency. There are also impact-resistant, sound dampening, and other functional glazing upgrades available.
When it comes to innovative glass choices, Marvin wins out with their truly custom options. But Lindsay’s ThermaStar glass is extremely durable and efficient.
- Weather Tightness and Water Resistance
No one wants drafty, leaky windows. How well do these brands keep the elements out?
Lindsay windows are designed for weather tightness. Their fusion welded frames prevent air and water penetration through frame and sash corners. Multi-chambered profiles, triple weatherstripping, and interlocking sashes make them extra tight.
Years of weather endurance testing ensures excellent performance through rain, wind, and extreme temps.
Marvin also excels at weather resistance. Their Ultrex fiberglass material resists swelling and warping from moisture. Precision-fit weatherstripping stops infiltration. Specialty glazing options add extra insulation and storm resistance. Both brands undergo rigorous testing to meet or surpass air and water infiltration standards.
Overall, both Lindsay and Marvin windows earn top marks for weather tightness and water resistance. You can count on both brands to deliver a tight seal.
- Warranties and Protection
What kind of coverage do these window warranties provide?
Lindsay backs their windows with strong warranties.
Their non-prorated lifetime limited warranty covers the operation and finish of the window for as long as you own your home.
All components including the insulated glass unit are protected from defects and workmanship issues.
Marvin has comparable warranty coverage.
Their non-prorated 20/10 warranty provides 20 years coverage on glass components and 10 years on manufacturing materials and workmanship.
Their ultrex fiberglass windows have a transferable lifetime limited warranty.
Both brands offer reassuring warranties. Lindsay provides lifetime coverage while Marvin’s lengthy 20 and 10 year coverage is also generous. This makes either a low-risk investment.
- Service and Support
What kind of customer service and support can you expect from these brands?
Lindsay stands behind their products with responsive customer service and support. Most dealers can set up service calls and repairs for homeowners.
Alternatively, you can contact Lindsay directly by phone or email. The company has an excellent reputation for taking care of warranty issues and standing behind their windows.
Marvin also has outstanding customer service reviews. Their knowledgeable sales reps provide guidance on selecting the right windows. The company handles any warranty issues promptly and professionally. Longevity and consistent family ownership contribute to their customer focus.
When comparing Lindsay vs. Marvin windows, both companies offer exemplary customer service and support you would expect from premium window brands. This makes the buying and ownership experience positive.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Marvin windows are comparable or often superior to Andersen windows in many respects. Marvin offers greater customization options, more premium materials like real wood, better energy efficiency, and easier integration into unique architectural designs.
Yes, most Lindsay windows come with fiberglass mesh screens already installed or as an available option. Screens come standard with most of their double hung, single hung, sliding, and casement windows.
While very expensive, Marvin windows offer many features that justify their premium pricing. This includes extreme durability, customized sizing and options, superior energy savings, noise reduction, aesthetic appeal, and excellent resale value that offsets their high initial cost over time.
The best windows for Minnesota feature triple pane glass, Low-E coatings like Cardinal LoE3 366, argon or krypton gas fills, insulated vinyl or fiberglass frames, ample weatherstripping, a casement or awning style, and ENERGY STAR certification. Top brands include Marvin, Andersen, Pella, Jeld-Wen, and Lindsay.
Closing Remarks
When comparing Lindsay and Marvin windows, both brands offer quality, durability, and performance. Lindsay is the value option offering excellent vinyl windows at a reasonable price point.
For those wanting superior materials, extreme customization, and prestige, Marvin windows justify their higher cost.
Carefully consider the factors that matter most for your home. This includes budget, aesthetic needs, efficiency goals, window types, climate, and warranty protection. Do your homework on the many options offered by both brands. This helps ensure you select the ideal windows for your household.
With either choice, proper installation is also key for ensuring energy efficiency, weather tightness, and trouble-free operation. Work with experienced professionals and check credentials. New windows are an investment that should serve you well for decades when chosen and installed properly.