ForeverWick Candle Reviews From Experience: Is It Worth It?

When I first heard about ForeverWick candles, I was intrigued by their unique selling point: a real diamond hidden inside every candle. It sounded like the perfect mix of indulgence and surprise—a beautiful candle with luxurious scents and an actual diamond to keep forever.

But as someone who likes to dig deep before making a purchase, I decided to explore every angle of this product. And, well, the story is more complex than I initially thought.

My Experience With ForeverWick Candle

When I first heard about ForeverWick candles, I was intrigued by their unique selling point: a real diamond hidden inside every candle. It sounded like the perfect mix of indulgence and surprise—a beautiful candle with luxurious scents and an actual diamond to keep forever.

So, naturally, I had to try one for myself to see if it lived up to the hype.

From the moment I unboxed the ForeverWick candle, I could tell it was a premium product.

The jar felt solid, the wax was smooth and creamy, and the fragrance was immediately noticeable—a delightful mix of citrus, floral, and musk that filled the room even before I lit the wick.

I chose a scent that combined orange, strawberry, and jasmine, which turned out to be a winning choice for creating a cozy, uplifting atmosphere in my home.

Lighting the candle was a treat. The soy-based wax burned evenly, and the cotton wick ensured a steady flame without excessive smoke. The scent throw was moderate—not overwhelming but noticeable enough to make a difference.

It’s the kind of candle you’d want to light during a relaxing evening with a good book or while entertaining guests. The burn time lived up to its promise; I got well over 70 hours of use, which was impressive.

But let’s talk about the diamond. After hours of enjoying the candle, I finally reached the moment of truth. As the wax melted down, a small capsule emerged. I let the candle cool before carefully extracting the diamond with tweezers.

When I opened the capsule, there it was: a tiny, glistening stone. While it was indeed real and GIA-certified, the size was… underwhelming. To be honest, I had expected something more substantial. The diamond felt more like a novelty than a true keepsake.

Overall, my experience was a mixed bag. While the candle itself was enjoyable and high-quality, the diamond didn’t quite live up to the excitement promised by the marketing. If you’re buying this for the candle alone, you’ll likely be satisfied. But if you’re primarily after the diamond, temper your expectations.

The Pros of ForeverWick Candles

Like any product, ForeverWick candles have their strengths. Here are some of the highlights:

• Unique Concept: The idea of combining a high-quality scented candle with a keepsake diamond is undeniably creative. It makes for an excellent gift, especially for milestones like engagements, anniversaries, or birthdays.
• Luxurious Scents: The fragrances are well-thought-out and layered, combining fruity, floral, and musky tones. It’s a treat for anyone who loves aromatic experiences in their living spaces.
• Organic and Clean Burning: The candles are soy-based, which means they burn cleaner and longer than traditional paraffin candles. Plus, the cotton wicks ensure a more even burn.
• Diamonds Are Forever: The small diamond at the end of your candle-burning journey adds a touch of permanence to an otherwise ephemeral product. The diamonds are GIA-certified, which assures authenticity.

The Cons of ForeverWick Candles

Now, here’s where things get a little dicey. Despite its unique appeal, ForeverWick candles have left many customers underwhelmed.

• Tiny Diamonds: Let’s address the elephant in the room: the diamonds. While the promise of a diamond is exciting, many users have reported receiving incredibly small stones, often under 0.03 carats. Some customers even described their diamonds as nearly microscopic.
• Price vs. Value: ForeverWick candles are priced higher than your average luxury candle, largely because of the diamond. However, when the diamond turns out to be minuscule, the perceived value diminishes significantly.
• Quality Control Issues: Numerous reviews mention issues like candles arriving without diamonds or with scents that are too faint. In some cases, customers had to go through the hassle of contacting customer service for refunds or replacements.
• Overpromised, Underdelivered: The marketing creates high expectations, but many buyers feel let down by the actual product. Words like “underwhelming” and “disappointing” appear frequently in reviews.

How ForeverWick Compares To Other Brands?

To provide a well-rounded perspective, let’s compare ForeverWick candles to other notable brands: HomeWorx, Yankee Candle, and Anaïs Candle. Each brand has its unique strengths, and this breakdown will help you decide which aligns best with your preferences.

ForeverWick Vs. HomeWorx Candle

• Scent Selection: HomeWorx candles offer a vast array of scents designed by Harry Slatkin, a fragrance expert. While ForeverWick candles have elegant and layered scents, HomeWorx stands out with seasonal, gourmand, and highly creative fragrance combinations.
• Burn Time: ForeverWick candles boast a burn time of over 70 hours due to their slow-burning soy wax. HomeWorx candles also have a long burn time but are known for their multiple wicks, which provide faster and more even wax pooling, albeit at the cost of slightly shorter overall burn durations.
• Unique Features: ForeverWick’s diamond is its defining gimmick, whereas HomeWorx focuses on the aesthetics of the jar and the strength of its scent throw. If you’re after fragrance potency, HomeWorx outshines ForeverWick.
• Price: HomeWorx candles are generally more affordable and offer better value purely as a candle. ForeverWick’s price is driven by the diamond element, which doesn’t appeal to everyone.

ForeverWick Vs. Yankee Candle

• Scent Selection: Yankee Candle is a household name, known for its extensive scent library. Whether you want something fresh, floral, fruity, or holiday-inspired, Yankee likely has it. ForeverWick’s selection is more limited but offers sophisticated blends.
• Burn Time: Yankee Candles are also long-lasting but slightly lag behind ForeverWick’s 70-hour burn time. However, Yankee’s paraffin wax doesn’t burn as cleanly as ForeverWick’s soy-based wax.
• Unique Features: Yankee Candle focuses on consistent quality and branding without gimmicks. ForeverWick’s diamond adds an element of surprise but doesn’t necessarily enhance its core function as a candle.
• Price: Yankee Candles are more affordable and widely available, making them a reliable choice for everyday use. ForeverWick is better suited for gifting due to its unique concept.

ForeverWick Vs. Anaïs Candle

• Scent Selection: Anaïs candles are renowned for their niche and luxurious fragrances. They cater to a more upscale audience with refined and often unique scent profiles. ForeverWick’s scents are pleasant but lack the sophistication and exclusivity of Anaïs candles.
• Burn Time: Anaïs candles burn for a shorter duration but are made with high-quality ingredients that provide a superior fragrance throw. ForeverWick’s extended burn time is a plus for those who want long-lasting ambiance.
• Unique Features: Anaïs candles are all about elegance and minimalism, focusing on delivering a premium olfactory experience. ForeverWick’s diamond gimmick can feel out of place compared to the understated luxury of Anaïs.
• Price: Anaïs candles are priced at a premium, often higher than ForeverWick. However, their consistent quality and focus on luxury justify the cost. ForeverWick’s price is harder to justify unless you’re specifically drawn to the diamond.

Maintenance Tips For ForeverWick Candles

If you’re still curious to try one, here’s how to get the best experience from your ForeverWick candle:

1. Trim the Wick: Always trim the wick to about 1/4 inch before lighting the candle. This ensures a steady flame and minimizes soot
2. Burn Evenly: The first burn is crucial. Let the wax melt evenly across the surface to prevent tunneling.
3. Protect the Jar: Place the candle on a heat-resistant surface and avoid burning it for more than 4 hours at a time.
4. Retrieve the Diamond Carefully: Once the candle has burned down, let it cool completely before extracting the diamond. Use tweezers to avoid damaging it.

Should You Buy A ForeverWick Candle?

This is a tricky question, and the answer hinges on what you’re hoping to get out of the experience. If you’re someone who loves novelty items or enjoys the thrill of uncovering a hidden gem (literally), then ForeverWick candles might be worth trying—once.

The idea of burning a candle to reveal a diamond is undeniably fun and unique, making it a potential conversation starter or a memorable gift for special occasions. It’s also a creative way to add a layer of sentimentality to an already intimate ambiance.

However, if your primary motivation is value for money, you’ll likely feel disappointed. The candle itself, while pleasant, is not a standout in the luxury candle market.

The scents are subtle and enjoyable but not groundbreaking, and the quality doesn’t justify the premium price tag—especially when you factor in the size of the diamond. Many customers have reported feeling let down when their long-awaited diamond turned out to be almost too small to appreciate without magnification.

That said, if you set your expectations appropriately, the experience can still be satisfying. The candles burn well, have a decent scent throw, and last for a long time. And if you’re giving it as a gift, the recipient might appreciate the thoughtfulness and novelty even if the diamond is less than impressive.

Ultimately, ForeverWick candles are not for everyone. They’re a niche product designed for a specific kind of buyer—someone who values novelty and sentimentality over pure functionality or value.

If that sounds like you, go for it. But if you’re more focused on exceptional candle quality or substantial diamonds, you’d be better off exploring other options in the luxury candle or jewelry markets.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Wrapping Up

In conclusion, while the concept of ForeverWick candles is fascinating, the execution doesn’t always meet expectations. The scents are pleasant, and the diamond is a fun surprise, but the overall value falls short for many. If you’re looking for a gift that’s unique but comes with some risks, give it a try.

But if quality and value are your top priorities, you’re better off sticking with more reliable brands. Happy candle shopping!