Fishers Finery Vs. Blissy Pillowcase: The Great Silk Debate

I’ve been on a quest for the perfect night’s sleep, and that journey led me down the luxurious rabbit hole of silk pillowcases. It’s a world filled with promises of better hair, skin, and unparalleled comfort. In my search, two names constantly surfaced: Fishers Finery and Blissy.

Deciding between them felt like a monumental task. That’s why I’m sharing my personal, in-depth comparison. I’ll walk you through my entire experience, from the unboxing to the long-term results, helping you understand which of these silk giants truly deserves a place on your bed.

This is the guide I wish I had.

A Side-by-Side Look

My Journey Into The World of Silk

Let’s get one thing straight from the outset: I was a silk skeptic. For years, I slept on high-thread-count cotton, believing it was the pinnacle of bedding. The idea of sleeping on silk seemed… frivolous. An unnecessary extravagance. How much difference could a pillowcase really make?

My hair was a constant battle against frizz, and my skin, prone to sleep creases, was starting to show the mileage of my side-sleeping habits. After hearing countless testimonials from friends and seeing endless praise online, my skepticism finally gave way to curiosity. I decided to invest, not just in a product, but in an experiment.

The two contenders that emerged from my research were Fishers Finery and Blissy. They both claimed to use 100% pure mulberry silk, the highest quality available. But their branding, price points, and some key features were distinctly different.

I decided to try both, dedicating several weeks to each to give a fair and honest assessment from a real user’s perspective. This isn’t just a review; it’s a chronicle of my conversion.

First Impressions: The Unboxing Experience

The arrival of a package always brings a little spark of excitement, but the unboxing of these two pillowcases set very different tones for what was to come.

The Arrival of Fishers Finery

The Fishers Finery pillowcase arrived in a tasteful, yet understated, box.

It felt elegant and well-packaged, the kind of box that says, “What’s inside is high quality, and we don’t need to shout about it.”

Sliding the inner tray out, the pillowcase was neatly folded and wrapped in tissue paper.

My first touch was a moment of revelation. The material felt thick—more substantial than I had anticipated. It had a weight to it that spoke of durability. The smoothness was unlike any fabric I had ever felt.

It wasn’t just soft; it was a frictionless surface that felt cool and calming against my fingertips. I ordered the “Natural White,” which was a beautiful, soft ivory color that looked incredibly clean and classic. The craftsmanship was immediately apparent.

The stitching was immaculate, with no loose threads or imperfections. The most notable design feature was the envelope closure. It’s essentially an overlapping flap of fabric on the side that tucks the pillow in, keeping it snug and secure without the need for zippers or buttons.

My initial thought was that this was a clever design, as there would be no hard parts to potentially press against my face or snag my hair. The overall first impression was one of quiet confidence and exceptional quality. It felt like a product designed for someone who values the integrity of the material above all else.

The Grand Entrance of Blissy

A few days later, the Blissy pillowcase arrived, and it was an entirely different spectacle. The term “unboxing experience” feels like it was coined for brands like Blissy. The pillowcase came in a heavy, rigid, and beautifully designed gift box with a magnetic closure.

It felt less like bedding and more like a luxury accessory, something you might expect from a high-end handbag or piece of jewelry. Opening the box was a genuine “wow” moment. The pillowcase was presented perfectly, nestled within the box like a precious gem.

The presentation alone makes it an incredible gift.

Pulling the pillowcase out, the first thing I noticed was its texture. While also 100% mulberry silk, the Blissy felt slightly lighter and, if possible, even softer to the touch than the Fishers Finery. It was an airy, almost ethereal softness.

This is likely due to the difference in momme count; Blissy uses 22 momme silk, while the Fishers Finery I chose was 25 momme. The higher momme in the Fishers Finery gives it that denser, more substantial feel, whereas the Blissy feels more delicate and fluid.

The Blissy pillowcase featured a hidden zipper closure. The zipper is color-matched to the fabric and tucked away so seamlessly that you barely notice it’s there. My immediate reaction was that this was a more secure way to keep the pillow in place.

No amount of tossing and turning would cause the pillow to peek out. I had chosen a vibrant “Pink” color, and it was stunning—rich, saturated, and with a beautiful, high-gloss sheen that screamed luxury.

The unboxing alone made me feel pampered. Blissy wasn’t just selling a pillowcase; they were selling an experience of opulence from the moment it landed on my doorstep.

The Tale of the Tape: Silk Quality and Momme

Before I go further, it’s crucial to understand the most important factor in this comparison: the silk itself. Both brands use 100% pure mulberry silk, which is the gold standard.

It’s produced by silkworms that are fed an exclusive diet of mulberry leaves, resulting in the longest, strongest, and most uniform silk fibers available. This is non-negotiable for a quality silk pillowcase.

The key differentiator is the “momme” (pronounced moe-mee), which is a unit of weight used to measure the density of silk. Think of it as the silk equivalent of thread count in cotton. A higher momme number means more silk is used in the fabric, resulting in a heavier, more durable, and often more lustrous material.

• Fishers Finery: The pillowcase I used is from their 25 Momme line. They also offer a 19 momme option for those on a tighter budget, but I wanted to compare the best against the best. Twenty-five momme is considered very high-end. It’s a weight often found in luxury men’s shirts and high-fashion garments.
• Blissy: Their standard pillowcases are 22 Momme. This is still a very high-quality, luxurious weight. For a long time, 19-22 momme was considered the sweet spot for bedding, offering a perfect balance of softness, durability, and sheen.

From a practical standpoint, the 3-momme difference was noticeable to the touch. The 25 momme Fishers Finery felt more robust and opaque. It gave me a sense of long-term durability. The 22 momme Blissy felt a bit more delicate and fluid in my hands.

Does this mean one is definitively “better”? Not necessarily. It’s a trade-off. The higher momme of the Fishers Finery might withstand more wear and tear over the years, while the slightly lower momme of the Blissy contributes to its uniquely airy and lightweight feel.

Both are leaps and bounds above the 16 or 19 momme pillowcases you might find on large online marketplaces, which often lack the durability and rich feel of these premium options.

The Sleep Test: Putting Silk to The Real-World Challenge

This is where the magic, or lack thereof, truly happens. I spent three weeks sleeping exclusively on the Fishers Finery pillowcase, followed by three weeks with the Blissy. I maintained my usual skincare and haircare routines to isolate the pillowcase as the primary variable.

My Weeks With Fishers Finery

The first night was transformative. Laying my head down on the Fishers Finery pillowcase was a sensory delight. The fabric was incredibly smooth and cool to the touch.

As a warm sleeper, this initial coolness was a huge plus, and I found that while it eventually warmed to my body temperature, it never felt hot or stuffy like cotton sometimes can. It breathes exceptionally well.

• Hair Results

I have fine, wavy hair that is prone to frizz and tangles. Usually, I wake up with a serious case of bedhead that requires taming with water and product. After the very first night on the Fishers Finery, the difference was astounding. My hair was noticeably smoother.

The usual halo of frizz was greatly diminished, and there were far fewer tangles. The science behind this is simple: cotton absorbs moisture and its rougher texture creates friction, snagging and roughing up the hair cuticle.

Silk, being a protein-based fiber with very little absorbency, allows your hair to glide across the surface. My hair retained its natural moisture, and by the end of the three weeks, my morning hair routine was cut in half. My waves were more defined, and my hair just looked and felt healthier.

• Skin Results

I am a dedicated side-sleeper, which means I often wake up with pronounced sleep creases etched onto my cheek. These creases, which used to take an hour or more to fade, were practically non-existent with the Fishers Finery.

The smooth surface meant my skin glided rather than getting crumpled and folded against the pillow. Furthermore, I felt like my nighttime skincare products were more effective.

It seemed logical that instead of my expensive serums and moisturizers being absorbed by my pillowcase, they were staying on my face where they belong. Over the three weeks, my skin felt more hydrated and looked plumper in the mornings.

• The Closure in Action

The envelope closure was a non-issue. It held my pillow perfectly, and I never once felt it or had the pillow slip out. It was completely silent and unobtrusive. In many ways, it felt like a more organic part of the pillowcase than a zipper.

Switching To Blissy

After three successful weeks, I was hesitant to switch, but my mission demanded it. I swapped in the freshly washed Blissy pillowcase. The initial feel was, as I noted before, slightly lighter and silkier. It felt incredibly luxurious against my skin.

• Hair Results

The positive hair results continued with the Blissy.

The smoothness, the lack of frizz, the reduction in tangles—it was all there.

I couldn’t discern a significant difference in the performance between the 22 momme Blissy and the 25 momme Fishers Finery in this department.

Both were exceptional at preserving my hairstyle and preventing bedhead.

If I were forced to find a minute difference, perhaps my hair felt a fraction “slipperier” on the Blissy, but the end result upon waking was identical: smoother, healthier-looking hair.

• Skin Results

Similarly, the Blissy performed wonderfully for my skin. No sleep creases, and that feeling of waking up with hydrated, calm skin persisted. The cooling effect was also present, providing that initial comfort as I settled into bed. Both pillowcases proved that high-quality mulberry silk is a game-changer for nighttime skin preservation.

• The Closure in Action

The hidden zipper on the Blissy was fantastic. It created a fully enclosed case, which gives a very clean, tidy look to the pillow. The zipper pull is tiny and completely hidden by a fabric flap, so I never felt it against my face. It provided a sense of security that the pillow was sealed away from dust and allergens, which is a nice psychological bonus.

My only long-term concern with any zipper, no matter how well-made, is its potential for snagging the delicate silk fabric over time, especially during washing, or potentially failing after many cycles. This is a minor concern, but one to consider when comparing it to the fail-proof simplicity of an envelope closure.

Pros And Cons of Fishers Finery And Blissy Pillowcase

After weeks of hands-on, or rather, head-on testing, I can confidently lay out the strengths and weaknesses of each brand from my personal viewpoint.

Fishers Finery: The Pragmatist’s Luxury

Pros:

• Superior Silk Weight: The 25 momme silk feels undeniably substantial and durable. It gives you confidence that this is a product built to last. For me, this is its single biggest advantage.
• Excellent Value: While not cheap, it is significantly more affordable than Blissy. You are getting a higher-grade silk (in terms of momme) for less money. The value proposition is off the charts.
• Gentle and Effective Closure: The envelope closure is simple, effective, and has zero hard parts. There is no risk of a zipper failing or snagging the fabric in the wash.
• Proven Performance: It delivered on every single promise. My hair and skin saw dramatic improvements that were sustained over the entire testing period. It works. Period.

Cons:

• Less “Giftable” Presentation: The packaging is nice, but it lacks the sheer wow-factor of the Blissy box. If you’re buying it as a truly special gift, it might feel a little less spectacular to unbox.
• Fewer Aesthetic Options: The range of colors and patterns is more limited compared to Blissy. If you’re trying to match a very specific or bold bedroom decor, you might not find the perfect shade.

Blissy: The Unapologetic Indulgence

Pros:

• The Ultimate Unboxing Experience: Blissy has mastered the art of presentation. From the moment you receive the box, it feels like a high-end, special-occasion gift. This adds significant perceived value.
• Vast Selection of Colors and Designs: The sheer variety is incredible. From classic solids to trendy patterns and tie-dyes, there is a Blissy pillowcase to suit virtually any taste or bedroom aesthetic.
• Secure Zipper Closure: The hidden zipper keeps the pillow completely encased, which can be appealing for those concerned with allergens or who simply prefer a tidier look.
• Incredibly Soft Feel: The 22 momme silk has an exceptionally light, airy, and fluid feel that many people will equate with ultimate softness and luxury.

Cons:

• Premium Price Tag: There’s no getting around it—Blissy is expensive. You are paying a premium for the brand name, the elaborate packaging, and the extensive marketing.
• Slightly Lower Silk Weight: While 22 momme is excellent, you are paying more for a technically lower density of silk compared to Fishers Finery’s 25 momme offering.
• Potential Zipper Concerns: While well-made, a zipper is a mechanical part that has the potential to fail or snag the delicate fabric over the long haul, especially with repeated machine washing.

The Maintenance Question: Caring for Your Investment

A common deterrent for people considering silk is the fear of high-maintenance laundering. I was pleasantly surprised on this front. Both Fishers Finery and Blissy state their pillowcases are machine washable, which I found to be true. My process for both was the same:

1. Turn the pillowcase inside out. For the Blissy, I made sure to zip it closed.
2. Place it in a mesh laundry bag. This is a crucial step to protect it from snags from other items or the machine itself.
3. Wash on a delicate, cold-water cycle with a pH-neutral liquid detergent (a special silk-friendly detergent is best, but a gentle wool wash also works).
4. Hang to dry away from direct sunlight. Silk dries surprisingly quickly.

Both pillowcases came out of the wash looking and feeling perfect. The fabric remained smooth and lustrous. The ease of care was a huge relief and made the idea of using a silk pillowcase long-term much more practical. The Fishers Finery, with its lack of a zipper, felt slightly simpler to just turn inside out and toss in the bag, but the difference in effort was negligible.

Who I Recommend Each For?

After living with both of these pillowcases, I came to a clear conclusion. The choice between Fishers Finery and Blissy isn’t about which one is “good” and which one is “bad.” Both are exceptional products that will likely revolutionize your sleep, hair, and skin.

The choice comes down to your personal priorities and what you value most.

For years, I believed that true luxury had to come with a hefty price tag and flashy branding. My experience with these two pillowcases has fundamentally changed that perspective.

I went into this expecting the more expensive, beautifully packaged Blissy to be the clear winner. And while it is a fantastic product, my head and my wallet found a different champion.

I found myself continually impressed by the straightforward, quality-focused approach of Fishers Finery. It felt like a brand that put all its resources into the fabric itself. The 25 momme silk has a tangible robustness that gives me confidence in its longevity.

It delivered every promised benefit, from smoother hair to crease-free skin, without the need for an extravagant marketing budget or an overly ornate box. It represents an intelligent, discerning form of luxury—one that is based on tangible quality rather than perceived value.

Blissy, on the other hand, excels in creating a feeling of indulgence. The entire experience, from the website to the unboxing, is designed to make you feel pampered. It’s the perfect choice if you are giving a gift, as its presentation is truly second to none.

If you desire a specific color or pattern to match your decor, Blissy’s vast selection is a massive advantage. You are paying for that experience, that brand assurance, and that aesthetic variety.

So, who should you, the person reading this, choose?

I recommend Fishers Finery if:

• You are a value-conscious consumer. You want the absolute best quality silk for your money, and you prioritize the physical product over branding and packaging.
• Durability is your top priority. The higher 25 momme weight suggests a longer lifespan and more resilience over time.
• You prefer an understated, classic aesthetic. You’re here for the performance of the silk, not for a fashion statement on your bed.
• You appreciate the elegant simplicity of an envelope closure.

I recommend Blissy if:

• You are buying this as a special gift. The unboxing experience alone is worth a significant part of the price and will make the recipient feel incredibly special.
• Aesthetic choice is paramount. You need that perfect shade of emerald green or a specific marble pattern to complete your bedroom’s look.
• You value brand recognition and the “experience” of luxury. You want the product that you’ve seen celebrated and are willing to pay for that peace of mind and sense of opulence.
• You prefer the security and tidy appearance of a zipper closure.

Ultimately, my personal pillowcase of choice for long-term, everyday use is the Fishers Finery. It aligns perfectly with my philosophy of investing in tangible quality. It provides a superior material at a more reasonable price point, and for me, that is the definition of a smart purchase.

It has earned its permanent place on my bed. Your priorities may be different, and if they lead you to the vibrant and luxurious world of Blissy, I can assure you that you will also be getting a phenomenal product that will elevate your sleep.

The wonderful truth is, by choosing either of these brands, you are making a fantastic investment in yourself.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Wrapping Up

After weeks of sleeping on what I can only describe as clouds of fabric, my journey with Fishers Finery and Blissy has come to a clear end. My personal pillowcase of choice, the one that has earned a permanent place on my bed, is the Fishers Finery.

For me, it represents the smartest form of luxury—one rooted in tangible quality and exceptional value. It delivered a higher-density silk that feels incredibly durable, and it met every promise for better hair and skin, all without the premium markup.

However, this was my journey, and now it’s time for you to start yours. Your choice depends entirely on what you value. If you are seeking the ultimate gift, a dazzling array of colors, and an experience of pure indulgence from the moment you open the box, then you will be absolutely thrilled with Blissy.

It’s an exceptional product that delivers on its luxurious promise. But if, like me, you are a pragmatist at heart who prioritizes material integrity and long-term value above all else, then I believe you will find, as I did, that Fishers Finery is the undeniable winner.

The wonderful truth is that whichever path you choose, you are making a fantastic investment in the quality of your sleep and the health of your hair and skin.

You simply can’t lose.