When it comes time to replace the windows in your home, it’s important to do research and consider all of your options. Two popular replacement window companies are EcoView Windows and Window World.
But which one offers the better overall value and quality?
This comprehensive guide examines the pros and cons of both EcoView windows and Window World to help you make an informed decision.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Criteria | EcoView Windows | Window World |
| Frame Material | Premium vinyl or fiberglass | Standard vinyl |
| Glass Thickness | Up to triple pane | Double pane only |
| Energy Efficiency Ratings | Up to 0.20 U-Factor / 0.23 SHGC | Around 0.27 U-Factor / 0.30 SHGC |
| Noise Reduction | Excellent with laminated glass | Fair with standard glass |
| Durability Testing | Extensive testing | Unclear |
| Hardware Quality | Multi-finish, heavy duty | Single finish lightweight |
| Price for 2000 sq ft Home | $15,000 – $30,000 | $5,000 – $12,000 |
| Warranty | Lifetime on vinyl and fiberglass, 10 years on glass | Lifetime on vinyl only |
| Customer Reviews | 4+ stars overall | 3 – 3.5 stars overall |
Key Takeaways:
- EcoView offers superior materials and construction for better insulation, soundproofing, strength, and longevity. But the windows come at a high premium cost.
- Window World is the budget-friendly option, with vinyl windows that are decently energy efficient. However, quality control and durability issues are reported.
- For maximum long-term value, EcoView is likely the better investment. Window World makes more sense if low upfront cost is the priority.
- Homeowners wanting the best in noise reduction should opt for EcoView’s laminated glass packages.
- Make sure to factor in potential energy savings when comparing the higher EcoView prices versus cheaper Window World pricing.
- EcoView provides more customization choices for specialty windows and design features. Window World offers fewer options.
- Check warranties closely – EcoView has better coverage on glass, a key component. Both offer a lifetime warranty on vinyl.
- Research sizing, installation, and customer service for each company carefully before making a decision.
Overview of EcoView Windows
EcoView Windows is a respected manufacturer and installer of replacement windows. The company offers a full line of energy efficient windows made from vinyl, wood, fiberglass, and aluminum. Some of the key features of EcoView windows include:
- High energy efficiency – EcoView windows have low U-Factors and SHGC ratings to reduce heat loss in winter and block heat gain in summer. Their energy efficient glass packages can reduce energy bills by up to 30%.
- Superior noise reduction – With noise reduction glass packages, EcoView windows block exterior sounds extremely well. This allows for a peaceful, quiet indoor environment.
- Advanced glass options – Low-E coatings, argon gas, and triple pane designs are available. These features enhance energy savings and comfort.
- Durable vinyl or fiberglass – EcoView uses heavy-duty vinyl and long-lasting fiberglass for low maintenance and increased longevity.
- Comprehensive warranties – EcoView protects windows with a lifetime limited warranty on vinyl and fiberglass, 10 years on glass, and 1 year on labor.
EcoView windows come in single-hung, sliding, casement, awning, and picture styles. Custom grids and decorative glass choices allow for design flexibility. The company handles full-service installation using experienced crews.
Overview of Window World
Window World is a nationwide company that focuses on affordable replacement windows. They manufacture and install vinyl windows under their own American Window Systems brand name. Here are some key factors to consider about Window World:
- Lower upfront cost – The windows are very competitively priced, often undercutting other major brands. This makes them appealing if you want inexpensive windows.
- Energy efficient vinyl windows – Window World’s American Window Systems line has adequate U-Factors and SHGC ratings to offer good energy efficiency. Performance is not best-in-class but solid for the low price.
- Limited lifetime warranty – The vinyl windows are backed by a limited lifetime warranty covering defects in materials and workmanship. The glass has a 20-year warranty.
- Quick installation – Window World can replace windows rapidly, sometimes completing the work in one day. No need to go for weeks with unfinished window openings.
- Fewer glass/frame choices – Window World offers fewer options compared to other manufacturers. There are limited choices for the type of glass, vinyl color, hardware finishes, etc.
Window World sells affordable vinyl windows in single-hung, double-hung, sliding, and picture styles. More complex custom windows are not available.
Comparing Window Quality and Performance
When evaluating EcoView vs Window World, the differences become clear in terms of overall window quality and performance.
- Frame material – EcoView offers premium vinyl and fiberglass, whereas Window World has standard vinyl. Fiberglass is highly impact resistant.
- Glass thickness – EcoView has triple pane options. Window World’s maximum thickness is double pane. The extra pane enhances insulation.
- Energy efficiency ratings – EcoView maxes out under 0.20 U-Factor and 0.23 SHGC for the best efficiency. Window World hits around 0.27 U-Factor and 0.30 SHGC for decent but not outstanding performance.
- Noise reduction – EcoView uses laminated glass for excellent sound dampening. Window World’s standard glass allows more exterior noise transmission.
- Durability testing – EcoView windows withstand wind, water, UV rays, temperature swings, forced entry attempts, and other durability tests. It’s unclear what testing Window World subjects windows to.
- Hardware quality – EcoView provides heavy-duty hardware in multiple finishes. Window World’s hardware is lightweight and only available in white or clay.
So when you compare important criteria like materials, insulation, sound proofing, strength, and hardware, EcoView is the clear winner in terms of build quality and longevity.
Cost Comparison
One area where Window World shines is affordability. Here’s how EcoView and Window World window costs stack up:
- For a midrange double hung vinyl window, Window World runs $350 – $700 installed. EcoView costs $850 – $1,500 depending on glass packages and other upgrades.
- Complex custom windows like bay or bow windows cost at least $2,000 from EcoView due to their specialty engineering. Window World does not offer these custom shapes.
- Full window replacement for a typical 2500 sq ft home starts around $5,000 – $12,000 installed with Window World. With EcoView expect to pay $15,000 – $30,000 for the same project.
While EcoView offers superior quality and performance, the price is not cheap. But you may save money long-term through lower energy bills and fewer repair or replacement costs down the road.
Customer Reviews
Looking at customer feedback for both companies, a few key themes emerge:
- EcoView Reviews – Most reviews praise the windows’ quality, noise reduction, and energy efficiency. Complaints focus on the high price and occasionally installation issues. Overall EcoView earns 4+ stars.
- Window World Reviews – Reviews confirm the affordable pricing and convenient installation. Some report quality problems like leaks or cracked vinyl after a few years. Window World garners 3 – 3.5 star ratings.
Each company has mostly positive reviews, but EcoView satisfaction rates seem higher. Customers feel they get their money’s worth from the superior construction despite the steeper prices.
Pros and Cons of EcoView Windows And Window World
Here is a quick pros and cons breakdown when comparing EcoView and Window World:
EcoView Windows
Pros:
- Best-in-class energy efficiency
- Premium quality materials and construction
- Excellent noise reduction
- Ultra durable and long-lasting
- Comprehensive warranties
- Positive customer reviews
Cons:
- Expensive upfront cost
- Some complaints about installation problems
Window World
Pros:
- Very affordable and competitively priced
- Quick and convenient installation
- Energy efficient to a decent standard
- Lifetime warranty on vinyl
Cons:
- Lower quality materials than many brands
- Performance and features are mediocre
- Limited customization options
- Quality control issues reported in some reviews
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Window World installs vinyl windows manufactured under their own American Window Systems brand name. The windows are produced in company-owned facilities located in the U.S.
A few factors allow Window World to offer discounted pricing:
1. Use of standard, lower-cost vinyl and glass
2. High efficiency production process and vertical integration
3. Ordering materials in bulk for cost savings
4. Minimal customization options
5. Nationwide presence spreads marketing costs
These efficiencies enable Window World to undercut small local installers. But the cheaper construction may reduce longevity.
Three replacement window brands that earn consistently excellent reviews are:
1. Milgard – Known for premium materials and quality manufacturing
2. Simonton – A leader in energy efficient features and warranties
3. Pella – Offers many customization choices and innovative window designs
EcoView also garners very positive feedback for their combination of high-end construction and energy efficiency.
The top window replacement brands in terms of overall quality, value, and customer satisfaction include:
1. Marvin Windows and Doors
2. JELD-WEN Windows and Doors
3. Milgard Windows and Doors
4. Pella Windows and Doors
5. Andersen Windows and Doors
6. EcoView Windows
Doing your own research into each company’s offerings and ratings in your local area is recommended to find the right fit for your home and budget.
Final Thoughts
So when weighing EcoView and Window World, which is the better investment for replacing the windows on your home?
For those wanting a bargain upfront, Window World delivers rock-bottom pricing. But the compromise may be windows that develop issues after 5-10 years and need replacing again sooner.
For homeowners who can afford a steeper initial investment, EcoView provides exceptional quality and performance that should translate to decades of use with few problems. Energy savings can offset the higher cost over time.
Ultimately, opt for Window World if affordability is your top concern and you’re willing to sacrifice some construction quality to save money upfront. Or choose EcoView if you want truly top-tier windows that will serve your home well for generations.