Luxurious bed sheets can make all the difference when it comes to getting a good night’s sleep. And when it comes to luxury bedding, two brands stand out from the crowd: Brooklinen and Frette.
But which one offers the best bed sheets for your money?
Let’s take an in-depth look at the pros, cons, and key differences between these two popular luxury sheet brands.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Brooklinen | Frette |
| Price Range | $149 – $289 | $695 – $4,550 |
| Materials Used | 100% long-staple cotton | Premium cotton, linen, silk |
| Thread Count | 480 | Up to 1000 |
| Weave Types | Percale | Percale, sateen, dobby, jacquard |
| Country of Origin | US | Italy |
| Availability | Online only | High-end retailers |
| Brand Status | Mid-tier luxury | Ultra luxury |
| Special Features | N/A | Hand-stitched edges |
| Feel/Texture | Soft, breathable | Silky, ultra smooth |
| Best For | Value luxury sheets | No compromise luxury |
Overview of Brooklinen
Founded in 2014, Brooklinen has quickly become one of the most popular online retailers for high quality bed sheets and other home goods. Their bed sheets are made from 100% long-staple cotton with a lustrous 480-thread count weave.
Some of the key benefits of Brooklinen sheets include:
- Durable construction – Made to last after multiple washes
- Super soft feel – Gets even softer over time
- Cooling effect – Breathable weave keeps you from overheating
- Classic styles – Offered in both classic and novelty patterns/colors
- Reasonable prices – More affordable than many luxury brands
One downside is that Brooklinen only sells bedding online. But this direct-to-consumer model allows them to cut retail costs and pass the savings on to customers.
Overview of Frette
Founded in 1860 in Italy, Frette has a long heritage of producing ultra luxury linens and bedding items. Their sheets are crafted from premium long-staple cotton, silk, or linen fabrics.
Some of the key highlights of Frette sheets include:
- Hotel-grade quality – Same sheets used in 5-star hotels
- Very high thread counts – Up to 1000 threads for smoothest feel
- Unique weaving styles – Special techniques like hand-stitching edges
- Luxury brand status – Recognized globally as a top luxury brand
- Wide product range – Offer sheets, duvets, blankets, robes, and more
- Sold at high-end retailers – Neiman Marcus, Bloomingdale’s, etc.
The downside is that Frette sheets are very expensive, due to the brand’s premium status and use of top-tier fabrics. Their sheets can cost 5-10x more than Brooklinen’s.
Key Differences Between Brooklinen And Frette Luxury Bed Sheets
Direct Fabric and Construction Comparison
When it comes to the actual materials and construction quality, Brooklinen and Frette sheets have some clear differences:
Fabric
- Brooklinen uses 100% long-staple cotton. This cotton is extra long, resulting in soft and strong threads.
- Frette utilizes premium long-staple cotton, along with more luxurious options like silk, linen, and Egyptian cotton. The fabrics feel silky and smooth.
Thread Count
- Brooklinen sheets have a 480 thread count, which is on the higher end for most sheet brands. This produces a soft, breathable sheet.
- Frette thread counts go up to 1000. Some luxury collections even have hand-stitched edged to prevent fraying. This level of quality is why Frette sheets feel so soft and smooth.
Weave Style
- Brooklinen sheets have a basic percale weave that provides durability and a matte finish.
- Frette sheets use special techniques like dobby and jacquard weaves to create unique textures and designs. This adds to the luxury aesthetic.
Origins of Materials
- Brooklinen imports their cotton from Israel, keeping manufacturing local to the US.
- Frette imports premium cotton, linen, and silk from Italy and elsewhere in Europe. The Italian heritage is part of the luxury branding.
So in terms of the actual materials and construction, Frette sheets are made with higher standards and more premium fabrics compared to Brooklinen’s quality cotton sheets.
But Brooklinen still produces an excellent product using high-end long-staple cotton.
Pricing Differences
There is a significant gap in pricing between Brooklinen and Frette sheets:
Brooklinen Sheet Prices
- Core sheet sets – $149 to $169
- Luxe sheet sets – $208 to $248
- Special collections – $249 to $289
Frette Sheet Prices
- Classic bed sheet sets – $695 to $895
- Vintage collection sets – $1,050 to $1,450
- Bespoke handcrafted sets – $2,250 to $4,550
As you can see, the premium nature of Frette pushes their sheet sets way above the prices offered by Brooklyn. The Frette brand carries a luxury status that gets passed on to customers via the steep pricing.
However, Brooklinen still provides an excellent product and a luxury feel at a much more accessible price point. This makes them attractive to buyers who want a touch of luxury without breaking the bank.
Weighing the Pros and Cons
Based on the direct comparisons and pricing evaluation, here is a quick pros vs cons breakdown:
Brooklinen Pros
- Excellent quality for price
- Very soft, comfortable feel
- Direct-to-consumer pricing
- Easy online ordering
- Good color/pattern selection
Brooklinen Cons
- Not a luxury brand status
- Limited bedding options beyond sheets
- No luxury fabric options like silk
Frette Pros
- Luxury brand name recognition
- Hotel-grade quality and feel
- Special weaving techniques
- Ultra soft silk, linen, Egyptian cotton
- Wide selection of bedding
Frette Cons
- Very expensive, 5-10x higher prices
- Limited style selection
- Only sold through high-end retailers
- Italian brand less known to US buyers
Which Is The Better Buy?
So when comparing Brooklinen vs. Frette sheets, which comes out as the better buy and a better value for your money? Here is a final verdict:
For shoppers who want legitimate luxury sheets with special fabrics and weaves, Frette is the clear winner. The quality and exclusivity justify the extremely high prices for Frette sheets. If money is not an object, invest in the hotel-grade luxury that Frette provides.
However, for most buyers looking for premium sheets at reasonable prices, Brooklinen bed sheets are the better overall value. While not as posh as Frette, Brooklinen still produces quality sheets from nice long-staple cotton.
The prices stay relatively affordable and you can order sheets easily online. This makes Brooklinen the better choice for a touch of luxury without breaking your budget.
FAQ About Luxury Bed Sheets
Still debating between Brooklinen and Frette? Here are answers to some common questions luxury sheet buyers have:
Frette sheets are priced so high because the brand has maintained a luxury status since its founding in 1860. The premium materials and special manufacturing techniques also contribute to the high prices. Frette’s reputation for Hotel-grade sheets used by royalty justifies the expense for most buyers.
Yes, Frette is considered one of the top luxury bed sheet brands in the world. Their products are used by 5-star hotels and discerning high-end customers. Frette represents quality Italian craftsmanship applied to bed linens and home textiles.
For ultimate luxury, the most indulgent bedding uses high thread count sheets made from premium materials like Egyptian or Pima cotton, silk, and linen with a sateen weave. Italian-made sheets from heritage brands like Frette offer the peak of luxury bedding quality.
Brooklinen is considered a “luxury-light” brand. Their sheets are premium quality made from nice long-staple cotton. But their brand and materials don’t carry the prestige of a heritage luxury label like Frette. Their lower prices reflect this too. Brooklinen occupies an appealing space between mass-market and ultra luxury.
The Final Takeaway
While it’s hard to match the heritage prestige and indulgent feel of Frette sheets, Brooklinen still provides an excellent luxury-style sheets at fair price points accessible to more buyers.
Decide what level of luxury quality and spending you want, and choose between these two fine sheet brands accordingly. Either way, investing in high quality bed sheets pays off with a better night’s sleep.
