If you’re in the market for luxury bed sheets, you’ve probably come across Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth. Both brands offer high-quality bedding made from premium materials like organic cotton and bamboo. But which one is really worth investing in?
I’ve tested sheets from both brands extensively. Keep reading for a detailed comparison of Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth sheets, including pros, cons, and key differences. By the end, you’ll know which option best suits your needs and budget.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | Boll & Branch | Cozy Earth |
| Material | Organic cotton | Bamboo viscose |
| Weave | Sateen | Jersey |
| Feel | Smooth, matte | Silky, soft |
| Temperature regulating | Breathable | Excellent |
| Price | $$ | $$$ |
| Fit | Elastic all around | Single elastic band |
| Warranty | 1 year | Lifetime guarantee |
| Best for | Value, organic | Temperature regulation |
Overview of Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch launched in 2014 with a mission to produce ethical, fair trade certified bedding. The company cuts out middlemen and keeps its supply chain tightly integrated, from farming the cotton to delivering products to customers.
Here are some quick facts about Boll & Branch:
- Based in New Jersey, USA
- Fair Trade CertifiedTM factory
- GOTS and OEKO-TEX certified organic cotton
- Also offers wool, linen, bamboo, and cotton-blend sheets
- Price range from $200 – $370 for a queen sheet set
Boll & Branch is best known for its signature organic cotton sheets.
They have a smooth, matte finish that feels both cool and soft. The fabric is tightly woven for durability but doesn’t feel stiff or rough.
Fit is another highlight. The fitted sheet has deep pockets and elastic all the way around to grip mattresses. The flat sheet stays neatly tucked in thanks to the weighted bottom edge.
Boll & Branch offers a wide selection of solid colors, along with a few classic patterns like stripes and windowpane.
Overview of Cozy Earth
Cozy Earth launched in 2005 with a focus on sleep health. Their sheets aim to regulate temperature and increase airflow thanks to proprietary bamboo viscose fabric.
Here are the key facts on Cozy Earth:
- Based in Utah, USA
- Fair Trade CertifiedTM factory
- GOTS certified bamboo viscose
- Also offers cotton, linen, and cotton-blend sheets
- Price range from $255 – $415 for a queen sheet set
Cozy Earth’s bamboo viscose sheets have an ultra-smooth, silky feel. The fabric is very breathable, moisture-wicking, and temperature regulating. This makes them ideal for hot sleepers.
The stretchy fitted sheet fits mattresses up to 18 inches deep. It has a wide elastic band all around to prevent slipping. The flat sheet and pillowcases also have stretch for a smooth, wrinkle-free fit.
Cozy Earth sheets come in both solid and striped patterns. The color palette includes neutrals as well as some bolder shades like coral and slate blue.
Key Differences Between Boll & Branch And Cozy Earth Bed Sheets
Now, let’s dig into the details and see how Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth sheets stack up in terms of materials, quality, comfort, and more.
Materials
Both brands use high-end fabrics, but there are some key differences:
- Boll & Branch: Organic long-staple cotton with a sateen weave creates a smooth, matte finish. Very breathable and durable.
- Cozy Earth: Viscose from bamboo creates a super soft, silky finish. Moisture-wicking and temperature regulating.
So Boll & Branch focuses on natural organic cotton, while Cozy Earth uses a viscose derived from bamboo.
Quality
These luxury sheets are both designed to last:
- They’re OEKO-TEX certified free of harmful chemicals.
- Made at Fair Trade CertifiedTM factories with ethical working conditions.
- Tightly woven with durable stitches.
- Can withstand regular machine washing and drying.
Boll & Branch has the edge when it comes to third-party certifications. Their factory has the prestigious GOTS organic certification, while Cozy Earth’s factory does not.
However, customers uniformly praise the quality of both brands. Over time, Cozy Earth sheets become even softer.
Comfort
Here’s how the fabrics stack up for comfort:
- Boll & Branch cotton: Very breathable and stays cool all night. Smooth feel that’s substantial but not stiff.
- Cozy Earth bamboo: Ultra-soft with a luxurious drape. Moisture-wicking and temperature regulating.
Cotton offers exceptional breathability. Bamboo viscose excels at moisture control and preventing heat buildup.
Both fabrics resist pilling or becoming scratchy over time. The stretchy fitted sheets provide a secure fit.
Sizing
Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth offer sheets in all the standard mattress sizes:
- Twin
- Twin XL
- Full
- Queen
- King
- California King
The fitted sheets have deep pockets to accommodate thicker mattresses.
Boll & Branch’s fitted sheets have elastic all around, while Cozy Earth uses a single elastic band. For the most secure fit, Boll & Branch may have a slight edge.
Color and Pattern Selection
Boll & Branch offers about 30 colors of sheets, ranging from white and cream to gray and navy. Patterns include stripes, windowpane, and colorblock.
Cozy Earth has around 20 color choices from neutrals to brights like coral. Their patterns include wide and narrow stripes.
So both brands have attractive color options to match any bedroom aesthetic. Boll & Branch has a few more traditional patterns, while Cozy Earth sticks to stripes.
Price
As premium bed sheets, both brands lie at the high end of the price spectrum. Here’s how they compare:
| Size | Boll & Branch | Cozy Earth |
| Twin | $200 | $255 |
| Queen | $270 | $395 |
| King | $320 | $415 |
| California King | $345 | $415 |
Across the board, Cozy Earth sheets are around $100+ more expensive than Boll & Branch. Twins start around $200 vs. $250. Queens around $270 vs. $400.
For the materials used, Boll & Branch offers a better price point. But Cozy Earth frequently has sales bringing the prices down.
Warranties
Most bed sheets don’t come with a warranty. But both of these brands offer impressive guarantees:
- Boll & Branch: 1-year warranty against defects. Free repairs or replacement.
- Cozy Earth: Lifetime satisfaction guarantee. Refunds anytime if not 100% satisfied.
So you can buy with confidence knowing either brand will stand behind their sheets. For peace of mind, Cozy Earth’s lifetime guarantee is hard to beat.
Which Is Better For Your Needs?
Now that we’ve compared all the details, let’s summarize which sheets are preferable in different scenarios.
- Best Organic Cotton Sheets: Boll & Branch
If you want ultra-breathable, naturally hypoallergenic sheets, choose Boll & Branch. Their tightly woven cotton is very durable and improves with washing. The sateen weave gives a silky feel without artificial fabrics.
- Best Temperature Regulating Sheets: Cozy Earth
Cozy Earth’s proprietary bamboo fabric is unlike any other. The ultra-fine weave feels absurdly soft while wicking moisture. If you sleep hot or struggle with night sweats, these are a game-changer.
- Best Sheets on a Budget: Boll & Branch
Hands-down, Boll & Branch sheets offer the best value. While not cheap, the organic cotton provides an elevated experience at an accessible price point for premium sheets.
- Best Splurge-Worthy Sheets: Cozy Earth
For no-compromise luxury, Cozy Earth sheets deliver an exceptional sleeping experience. From the skin-pampering feel to unparalleled temperature regulation, they’re worth the investment.
- Best Stylish Patterned Sheets: Boll & Branch
With patterns like stripes, windowpane, and color blocking, Boll & Branch offers attractive styling. The prints retain a sophisticated sensibility perfect for elevated bedroom decor.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Still deciding between Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth? Here are answers to some frequently asked questions:
Brooklinen: A popular direct-to-consumer brand with a similar price point and focus on quality materials like long-staple cotton. However, Brooklinen does not use certified organic cotton.
Snowe: Another direct-to-consumer brand with premium sateen weave cotton sheets. Their prices are a bit higher than Boll & Branch.
Parachute: They offer European-made relaxed linen sheets that are comparably priced to Boll & Branch cotton.
Buffy: Uses eucalyptus sheets instead of bamboo viscose but offers moisture-wicking temperature regulation at a lower price point.
Saatva: Their bamboo sheets are made with viscose from bamboo like Cozy Earth. Prices run a little lower but materials are very comparable.
Brooklinen: Some of their dual-layer sheet sets combine lyocell with cotton for added moisture management, though not as advanced as Cozy Earth.
Yes, for moisture-wicking temperature control, Cozy Earth sheets genuinely outperform competitors. The ultra-fine 300 thread count viscose feels decadently soft and silky. Hot sleepers of all kinds can benefit from the advanced fabric technology.
No, Brooklinen and Boll & Branch are completely separate competing brands started around the same time. While their sheet offerings both focus on quality materials, Brooklinen utilizes a wider range of fabrics like Tencel and linen in addition to cotton. Boll & Branch sets themselves apart with 100% certified organic cotton.
The Bottom Line
Boll & Branch and Cozy Earth both offer an elevated sheet buying experience, albeit with different material focuses.
For the best value organic cotton sheets, choose Boll & Branch. If moisture wicking and temperature regulation are your top priority, opt for Cozy Earth’s bamboo viscose sheets.
Either brand provides a meaningful upgrade over standard bedding. Taking time to compare the fabrics and pricing helps ensure you get the ideal sheets for your needs.
With high-end details like elastic edging and long warranties, you really can’t go wrong with these luxurious picks.