Big Joe Vs. Lovesac: A Cozy Showdown From My Living Room Perspective

I’m sprawled on my Big Joe bean bag, coffee in hand, pondering the ultimate seating showdown: Big Joe versus Lovesac. Both brands promise comfort, but which one truly delivers for my home?

In this article, I’ll unpack their features, weigh their strengths and weaknesses, and share my firsthand insights to help you decide which bean bag suits your vibe. From materials to price, comfort to durability, I’ve got you covered with a clear comparison to guide your choice.

A Brief Comparison Table

My Journey Into The World of Bean Bags

I’ve always been a sucker for cozy seating.

There’s something about sinking into a plush chair that makes binge-watching my favorite shows or curling up with a book feel like a mini-vacation.

When I decided to upgrade my living room, I stumbled upon Big Joe and Lovesac, two heavyweights in the bean bag arena.

At first, I thought, “A bean bag is a bean bag, right?” Oh, how wrong I was.

Each brand brings its own flavor, and choosing between them felt like picking a favorite song—tough but necessary. So, I set out to compare them, testing their comfort, durability, and overall vibe to see which one fits my lifestyle and might fit yours too.

Materials of Big Joe And Lovesac

Let’s start with what’s under the hood—or rather, under the cover. Big Joe uses a mix of shredded foam and polystyrene beads for its filling. The first time I sat on my Big Joe Fuf chair, it felt like a warm hug.

The shredded foam gives a soft, cushy vibe, while the polystyrene beads make it lightweight and easy to drag from my living room to my home office. But here’s the catch: over time, the foam can compress, especially if you’re a daily lounger like me.

I found myself fluffing it up every few weeks to keep that cloud-like feel. It’s not a dealbreaker, but it’s a bit like maintaining a high-maintenance pet.

Lovesac, on the other hand, uses its proprietary Durafoam blend. I had the chance to try a Lovesac SuperSac at a friend’s house, and let me tell you, it’s a game-changer. The Durafoam feels denser and more supportive, molding to my body without losing its shape.

After an hour of lounging, I didn’t feel like I was sinking into a void, which sometimes happens with Big Joe after prolonged use. Lovesac’s covers are another win—think plush velvets and soft furs that scream luxury.

Big Joe’s covers, while durable and available in fun fabrics like faux leather, don’t quite match that premium feel. If you’re after materials that feel like a splurge, Lovesac takes the crown, but Big Joe’s no slouch for the price.

Comfort and Ergonomics: Where I Sink In?

Comfort is king when it comes to bean bags, and both brands have their strengths.

Big Joe’s Fuf foam filling makes it a cozy spot for short-term lounging.

I’ve spent countless evenings on my Big Joe Roma chair, watching movies or reading, and it’s been a solid companion.

It supports my back decently for a couple of hours, but I noticed it’s not ideal for marathon sessions.

After a while, I start shifting to find that sweet spot again, and the foam sometimes needs a good shake to regain its fluff. It’s like a comfy couch that’s great for a nap but not for an all-day work-from-home setup.

Lovesac, however, is built for the long haul. When I sank into that SuperSac, it was like the chair was custom-made for me. The Durafoam adapts to your body, offering excellent back support whether you’re sitting upright or sprawled out.

I could work, read, or nap for hours without feeling like I needed to adjust. It’s the kind of chair that makes you forget time exists. For someone like me, who occasionally works from home on a laptop, Lovesac’s ergonomic edge is a big plus.

But if you’re just looking for a casual spot to chill for an hour or two, Big Joe’s comfort is more than sufficient.

Design And Aesthetics: Style Meets Function

I’m all about a space that looks good and feels functional, so design matters.

Big Joe leans into a fun, approachable aesthetic.

My Big Joe chair is a bold red that pops in my living room, and I love the side pockets for stashing my remote or phone.

The brand offers a variety of shapes—round, oval, or chair-like—and vibrant colors that scream personality.

It’s the kind of furniture that fits a quirky, eclectic home or a kid’s playroom. Plus, the built-in handles make it easy to move, which is great since I rearrange my furniture more often than I’d like to admit.

Lovesac goes for a sleeker, more modern look. Their Sacs have a clean, minimalist vibe with neutral tones that blend seamlessly into my friend’s chic apartment. The modular design is a standout—you can swap covers or even reconfigure Sactionals into different setups, like a sofa or sectional.

I was impressed by how effortlessly a Lovesac Sac fit into a contemporary space without screaming “bean bag.” However, if you want bold colors, you’ll need to hunt for their limited-edition covers. For me, Big Joe’s playful style wins for casual spaces, but Lovesac’s versatility is hard to beat for a polished look.

Size and Shape: Finding the Right Fit

Space is a big deal in my apartment, so size and shape are key. Big Joe offers a range of options, from small chairs (around 28 inches) perfect for kids or tight spaces to large ones (up to 48 inches) that can handle an adult like me.

I went with a medium-sized Fuf chair, which is about 33 inches and fits nicely in my living room corner.

The variety of shapes—round, oval, or structured—means there’s something for every need.

I’ve even tossed my Big Joe into the back of my car for a picnic, thanks to its portability.

Lovesac’s Sacs are generally larger, starting with the GamerSac (37 inches) and going up to the massive SuperSac (96 inches).

The CitySac I tried was perfect for my solo movie nights, but the SuperSac at my friend’s place could easily fit two or three people.

Their cushion-like or convertible designs add flexibility, but these bags are heftier and less portable. If you’ve got a spacious living room and want a statement piece, Lovesac’s sizes are ideal. For smaller spaces or frequent movers like me, Big Joe’s compact options are more practical.

Price: Budget Vs. Investment

Let’s talk money, because my wallet has opinions. Big Joe is the budget-friendly champ. My Roma chair cost me about $80, and even their larger Fuf models top out at around $300.

It’s the kind of price that doesn’t make you wince, especially if you’re furnishing a dorm, kid’s room, or a starter apartment. The affordability makes Big Joe accessible, but you’re trading some longevity for that lower price tag.

Lovesac, meanwhile, is a serious investment. Their Sacs start at around $900 for a CitySac and can climb to $2,500 for a BigOne. When I saw the price tag, I nearly choked on my coffee. But after sitting on one, I understood why.

The premium materials, durability, and comfort justify the cost if you’re in it for the long term. For me, Big Joe’s price fits my current budget, but if I were building a forever home, I’d consider splurging on Lovesac.

Durability: Will It Last?

I’m not gentle with my furniture, so durability is non-negotiable.

Big Joe uses SmartMax Fabric, which is stain-resistant and easy to clean—a lifesaver when I spilled wine during a movie night.

The Megahh beans and shredded foam hold up decently, but I’ve noticed some flattening after a year of heavy use.

The warranty is a bit thin—a 30-day return policy and a limited manufacturer’s warranty—but it’s fine for the price.

I’ve had to top up the filling once, which was a minor hassle but not a dealbreaker.

Lovesac’s Durafoam is a durability beast. My friend’s SuperSac has been through years of kids, pets, and parties, and it still looks and feels brand-new. The covers are washable and replaceable, which is a huge plus.

Their warranty is more robust—three years for Sacs and a lifetime for Sactionals. If you’re like me and want something that’ll survive a chaotic household, Lovesac’s longevity is worth the investment. Big Joe’s durable enough for casual use, but it’s not in the same league.

Eco-Friendliness: Green Vibes Only

I try to make eco-conscious choices, so sustainability is a factor. Big Joe scores points here with their zero-landfill manufacturing and 100% recyclable materials. Knowing my chair won’t end up clogging a landfill feels good.

Lovesac takes a different approach, focusing on longevity to reduce waste. Their modular Sactionals let you reconfigure or update pieces instead of buying new furniture. Both brands care about the planet, but Big Joe’s recyclable approach resonates more with my green sensibilities, while Lovesac’s durability appeals to my practical side.

My Experience With Big Joe And Lovesac

To really get a feel for these brands, I put them through their paces.

My Big Joe Fuf chair has been my go-to for casual lounging.

It’s lightweight, so I can drag it to wherever I’m hanging out—living room, bedroom, even my balcony.

But after a few months, I noticed it needed fluffing more often, especially after my friends crashed on it during a game night.

It’s perfect for spontaneous gatherings or solo chill sessions, but I wouldn’t trust it for all-day comfort.

Testing a Lovesac at my friend’s place was a revelation. The SuperSac felt like a throne—supportive, plush, and downright luxurious. I spent an entire afternoon working on my laptop, and my back didn’t complain once.

The modular design also blew me away; we rearranged the Sactionals into a sectional for a movie night, and it was seamless. The only downside? I kept thinking about that price tag. For now, my Big Joe fits my lifestyle, but I’m dreaming of a Lovesac upgrade someday.

Pros and Cons of Big Joe And Lovesac

Big Joe Pros

• Affordable: Prices from $60 to $300 make it wallet-friendly.
• Portable: Lightweight and easy to move, perfect for small spaces.
• Fun Design: Vibrant colors and functional features like pockets.
• Eco-Friendly: Recyclable materials and sustainable manufacturing.
• Variety: Multiple sizes and shapes for different needs.

Big Joe Cons

• Durability: Foam compresses over time, requiring fluffing or refilling.
• Comfort: Great for short-term use but less supportive for long sessions.
• Warranty: Limited coverage compared to premium brands.
• Materials: Decent but not as luxurious as higher-end options.

Lovesac Pros

• Premium Comfort: Durafoam and ergonomic design for all-day lounging.
• Durability: Long-lasting materials that hold shape and withstand wear.
• Modular Design: Customizable and reconfigurable for versatility.
• Warranty: Generous three-year or lifetime coverage.
• Aesthetics: Sleek, modern look that fits contemporary spaces.

Lovesac Cons

• Price: Starts at $900, a steep investment for most.
• Weight: Heavier and less portable than Big Joe.
• Color Options: Mostly neutral tones unless you hunt for special covers.
• Space: Larger sizes need more room, not ideal for small apartments.

Also Read: Comparison of Big Joe Plush And Lenox Bean Bag.

FAQ: Quick Answers To Your Questions

Wrapping It Up: Your Cozy Decision Awaits

After sinking into both Big Joe and Lovesac, I’ve learned they cater to different needs. If you’re like me—budget-conscious, always rearranging, and looking for a fun, casual vibe—Big Joe’s your pick. It’s affordable, portable, and eco-friendly, perfect for everyday lounging.

But if you crave luxury, long-term comfort, and a sleek, modular setup, Lovesac’s worth the splurge. You can’t go wrong, but it’s about what fits your life. So, grab a coffee, think about your space, and choose the bean bag that’ll make your home your happy place.