If you’re in the market for new windows, you’ve likely come across two big names: Window Mart and Pella. Both companies have been around for decades and offer a wide selection of high-quality windows. But which one is right for your home and budget?
In this guide, we’ll compare Window Mart and Pella windows to help you decide which is the better investment. We’ll look at factors like cost, materials, energy efficiency, warranties, styles, and more. Let’s dive in!
A Brief Comparison Table
| Category | Window Mart | Pella |
| Cost | $150 – $200 per window installed (lower cost) | $350+ per window installed (higher cost) |
| Materials | Vinyl, wood, fiberglass | Premium vinyl, fine wood species |
| Energy Efficiency | Double/triple pane, argon gas, low-E coatings Meet Energy Star guidelines | Triple pane, advanced low-E, optimized foam spacers Exceed Energy Star standards |
| Warranties | Varies by manufacturer, typically: Glass: 10-20 years Parts: 5-10 years Labor: 1-5 years | Glass: 20+ years Materials/workmanship: 10 years Labor: 2 years Lifetime warranties available |
| Styles | Wide selection from various brands Custom sizes and configurations | Four premium vinyl lines, wood, fiberglass, aluminum clad More limited customization |
| Installation | Independent installers contracted for each job Quality varies | Factory-trained Pella professionals Accountability from start to finish |
Window Mart Overview
Founded in 1946 under the name Glass Distributors, Window Mart is one of the largest US-based retailers of windows and doors.
They offer a range of products from leading brands like Simonton, Atrium, and Therma-Tru.
Pros:
- Competitively priced
- Wide selection of styles and materials
- Good variety of customization options
- Large retailer with over 200 locations nationwide
Cons:
- Quality and warranties vary by manufacturer
- Primarily a retailer, not manufacturer
Pella Overview
Pella Windows and Doors was established in 1925 and is headquartered in Pella, Iowa. Unlike Window Mart, Pella both manufactures and installs their own windows.
Pros:
- Vertically integrated from manufacturing to installation
- High-end materials and construction quality
- Comprehensive warranties
- Various lines to suit different budgets
Cons:
- More expensive than Window Mart
- Smaller retailer with limited locations
Now that we’ve introduced both brands, let’s do a detailed comparison.
Cost Comparison
One of the biggest factors for most homeowners is cost. Window Mart is known for affordability, while Pella commands a premium price.
For basic vinyl windows, Window Mart’s prices start around $200 per window installed. They have frequent sales that can bring that price down to $150 or lower.
Pella’s vinyl windows start around $350 installed and go up from there. Their top-tier wood windows can cost $1,000 or more per window.
Of course, cost varies based on the size, type, and features of each window. But overall, Window Mart offers greater value and budget-friendliness over Pella.
Materials and Construction
Windows are a complex system of frames, sashes, glass, and hardware. The materials and engineering quality make a big impact on performance, durability, and aesthetics.
Window Mart primarily sells vinyl windows, which are cost-effective and low-maintenance. However, vinyl quality varies among their manufacturing partners.
Some Window Mart vinyl windows use welded frames and multi-chamber construction for rigidity and insulation. But lower-end models may be thin and prone to warping.
By comparison, Pella uses premium vinyl formulations with thick walls, fusion-welded corners, and insulating foam fill. Even their basic Impervia line beats standard vinyl windows on strength and durability.
For wood windows, Window Mart relies on suppliers like Simonton and Atrium. The wood is usually lesser grades of pine or poplar. Compared to Pella’s kiln-dried oak, mahogany, and other fine woods, the construction is not as robust.
Pella takes the crown for superior materials and construction. Their industry-leading innovation and rigorous testing result in extremely durable, high-performing windows.
Energy Efficiency
Energy efficient windows save money on utilities and make homes more comfortable.
Efficiency is measured by the U-factor and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC).
The lower these numbers, the better.
For reference, Energy Star recommends U-factors of 0.27 to 0.32 and SHGC around 0.25 to 0.40 for the most efficient windows.
Window Mart’s vinyl models can match the Energy Star guidelines with double or triple pane glass, argon gas, and low-E coatings. With these upgrades, their windows reach U-factors of 0.27 to 0.30 and SHGC of 0.25 to 0.28.
Pella goes beyond the minimum standards with triple pane glass and two low-E coatings standard. Their optimized foam spacers and thermally improved frame deliver U-factors as low as 0.17. SHGC can get down to 0.19.
Pella outperforms Window Mart to provide maximum energy savings and comfort. Their advanced materials and engineering allow for superior thermal performance.
Styles and Customization
When it comes to options, both Window Mart and Pella deliver:
Window Mart
- Dozens of vinyl, wood, and fiberglass models
- Single hung, double hung, sliding, casement, awning, and specialty shapes
- Custom sizing in 1/8” increments
- Interior and exterior color choices
- Add-ons like grids, hardware finishes, and glass tinting
Pella
- Impervia, Lifestyle, Architect, and Designer vinyl lines
- Single hung, double hung, casement, awning, and sliding
- Dimensional adjustability and custom shapes
- Exterior color matched to trim
- Divided light grids, hardware, and interior wood species
Window Mart works with multiple manufacturers, so styles and options vary. Pella maintains consistency across their own lines, but the total customization is more limited.
For exotic wood grains and unlimited interior/exterior color matching, Window Mart pulls ahead. For seamless design within their vinyl families, Pella is unmatched.
Warranties
The warranty coverage reflects the quality and expected lifespan of the windows.
Window Mart’s warranties differ depending on the manufacturer:
- Glass coverage: 10-20 years
- Vinyl and hardware parts: 5-10 years
- Labor: 1-5 years
Pella warranties are straightforward:
- Glass: 20 years+
- Materials and workmanship: 10 years
- Labor: 2 years
Pella also offers several transferable lifetime warranties on glass, vinyl, and other components.
Pella provides better assurance against defects and gives peace of mind for long-term ownership.
Their lifetime warranties are hard to beat.
Professional Installation
Proper installation is crucial for windows to operate smoothly and prevent leaks.
Window Mart contracts experienced independent installers for each job. They have high standards for their installers, but quality can still be hit-or-miss. Getting someone reliable is not guaranteed.
Pella takes installation into their own hands. Their factory-trained professionals follow stringent protocols and undergo continuing education. This gives Pella unmatched control and accountability for the entire customer experience.
Between large retailers, local crews will likely offer greater attention to detail. Pella’s dedicated installation gives them an advantage on seamless integration and water tightness.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Some brands that offer similar quality and features as Pella include: Marvin Windows, Andersen Windows, JELD-WEN Windows, Milgard Windows, Sierra Pacific Windows, etc.
They use top-tier materials like wood, fiberglass, and premium vinyl. Advanced engineering provides excellent durability and energy efficiency. And like Pella, most handle their own manufacturing and installation. Expect prices comparable to Pella as well.
According to various professional ratings and customer reviews, the best replacement window companies include: Pella, Andersen, Marvin, Simonton, Milgard, JELD-WEN, PGT Custom Windows + Doors, etc.
Key factors that make these companies stand out are their warranties, selection, energy efficiency, quality installation, and overall value. They offer different types of materials, from vinyl to wood to fiberglass, at varying price points.
Three highly rated window replacement companies based on customer reviews and satisfaction are:
Pella – With a 60+ year history and A+ BBB rating, Pella is known for gorgeous, flawless installation and responsive support. Their lifetime warranties provide peace of mind.
Marvin – Excellent warranties combined with made-to-order customization. Marvin’s wood and fiberglass windows earn rave reviews for quality and energy savings.
Milgard – A great choice for vinyl windows. Milgard’s variety of styles, quality materials, and focus on smart home technology generate many positive reviews.
There are several prominent brands, but Pella and Andersen consistently top the lists of leading window manufacturers.
Key reasons they rate as the best include:
1. Long histories and strong reputations
2. Cutting-edge innovation in engineering and technology
3. Rigorous testing and quality control
4. Extensive style and material options
5. Substantial warranties and excellent customer service
Both Pella and Andersen are large national and international companies that deliver the whole package – exceptional manufacturing, energy efficiency, noise reduction, customization, installation, and support. Their premium windows stand the test of time.
Final Thoughts
For budget-conscious homeowners who still want quality, Window Mart is a great choice. Their professional installers and variety of products cater to most needs. Just be sure to clarify details upfront to get their best windows and service.
Those wanting the utmost in top-tier materials, energy efficiency, and durable construction will prefer Pella. Their windows deliver excellence from design to installation. With Pella, expect to pay a premium but get virtually unparalleled performance and guarantees in return.
In summary:
- Window Mart offers solid midrange products at bargain prices
- Pella is the pinnacle of quality with premium warranties to match
Carefully assess your priorities. And don’t hesitate to request quotes from each company to compare apples-to-apples pricing. Investing in the right windows for your home is well worth the time and consideration.