Stickley Furniture Reviews From Experience: Is It Worth It?

I’m sitting on my Stickley sofa, sipping coffee, and let me tell you, it feels like a hug from a well-dressed craftsman. If you’re hunting for furniture that’s built to last, looks timeless, and carries a legacy of quality, Stickley is your answer.

I’ve lived with their pieces for years, and they’ve transformed my home into a space that’s both elegant and enduring. From their iconic Mission style to modern designs, Stickley delivers heirloom-quality furniture that’s worth every penny.

Trust me, you’ll want to make this investment for your home.

My Experience With Stickley Furniture

When I first brought home my Stickley dining table, I was nervous. Dropping that kind of money on furniture felt like a leap, especially when I could’ve grabbed something cheaper from a big-box store.

But the moment that solid oak table arrived, I knew I’d made the right call. The rich, warm grain gleamed under my dining room light, and the craftsmanship was undeniable—every joint, every curve screamed care and precision.

It’s been five years, and that table still looks as good as the day it arrived, despite hosting countless dinner parties, kid art projects, and even a spilled glass of red wine (don’t ask).

Then there’s my Stickley Morris chair. I snagged it on a whim during a showroom visit, drawn to its classic Arts and Crafts vibe. Sitting in it feels like sinking into history—sturdy, comfortable, and somehow both rustic and refined.

I’ve spent hours reading in it, and it’s become my go-to spot for unwinding. The leather upholstery has softened over time, developing a patina that adds character without looking worn out.

My living room also houses a Stickley bookcase, its quartersawn oak showcasing that iconic tiger-stripe pattern. It’s not just a piece of furniture; it’s a conversation starter when guests come over.

What struck me most was the delivery process. The team handled my pieces like they were priceless artifacts, setting everything up with care and even giving me tips on maintenance. It’s rare to feel that level of service these days.

Sure, the price tag made me wince at first, but living with Stickley furniture has shown me what “you get what you pay for” really means. These pieces aren’t just functional; they’re part of my home’s story, and I can already imagine passing them down to my kids.

Pros of Stickley Furniture

• Unmatched Craftsmanship

Let’s talk about why Stickley stands out: the craftsmanship is unreal.

Every piece I own, from my dining table to my bookcase, feels like it was made by someone who genuinely loves their craft.

Stickley uses time-honored techniques like mortise and tenon joinery, dovetailed cross rails, and pinned chair joints.

These aren’t just fancy terms—they mean your furniture won’t wobble or fall apart after a few years. My table’s joints are so tight, it feels like it could survive an earthquake. Stickley’s commitment to quality is evident in every detail, from the hand-finished wood to the perfectly aligned drawers.

• Heirloom Quality

Stickley furniture isn’t just built to last; it’s built to be passed down. I’ve heard stories of Stickley pieces being handed down through generations, still looking pristine after decades. My sofa, for instance, has held up through daily use, kids jumping on it, and even a few pet-related mishaps.

The solid oak and cherry hardwoods they use are naturally durable, and the construction methods—like quarter-sawn lumber—ensure stability and beauty over time. I’m confident my pieces will be around for my grandkids to fight over one day.

• Timeless Design

Stickley’s designs are like that classic jacket you’ll never toss out—they just work, no matter the era. Their Mission style, with its clean lines and honest simplicity, feels as fresh today as it did in the 1900s. My Morris chair fits perfectly in my modern living room, blending seamlessly with newer decor.

But Stickley doesn’t stop at Arts and Crafts; their modern collections, like the Walnut Grove or Park Slope, bring a sleek, contemporary edge without sacrificing that timeless vibe. You won’t need to redecorate your whole house to make Stickley fit.

• Sustainable Practices

I’m a bit of a green nerd, so Stickley’s commitment to sustainability won me over. Over 90% of their furniture is made in the USA, in Upstate New York and North Carolina, using responsibly sourced hardwoods like oak, cherry, and maple.

They’re part of the Sustainable Furnishings Council, which means they care about minimizing environmental impact. Knowing my furniture was crafted with respect for the planet makes me feel even better about my purchase. Plus, the durability means less waste—no replacing cheap furniture every few years.

• Versatility

Whether you’re furnishing a cozy apartment or a sprawling house, Stickley has you covered. Their range spans living rooms, dining rooms, bedrooms, and even home offices, with rugs and accessories to boot. I love how my bookcase works as both storage and a statement piece.

You can choose from over 30 finishes, from dark Oxford to lighter Sand, so you’re bound to find something that matches your style. Stickley’s versatility means you can mix their pieces with other decor without it feeling like a showroom catalog.

Not-So-Good Parts of Stickley Furniture

• High Price Point

Let’s be real: Stickley isn’t cheap. My dining table set me back more than I’d ever spent on furniture before, and I had to budget carefully to make it work. A single chair can run you thousands, and a full living room set could rival a car payment.

For some, that’s a dealbreaker, especially if you’re used to more budget-friendly options like IKEA or Ashley Furniture. I get it—spending $8,000 on a sofa feels like a gut punch. But for me, the quality and longevity have made it worth the investment.

• Limited Customer Service Accessibility

Here’s where Stickley stumbles a bit. When I needed to contact their customer service about a delivery question, I couldn’t get anyone on the phone—voicemail city. I ended up emailing and got a response, but it took a couple of days.

Some folks online have echoed this, complaining about slow follow-ups or unhelpful responses. It’s frustrating when you’re spending this much money and can’t get a quick answer.

• Strict Return Policy

Stickley’s return policy is tough. No returns or refunds for non-warranty issues, and if you do return something, there’s a 25% restocking fee. I haven’t had to deal with this myself, but I can imagine it’s a headache if you change your mind or get a defective piece.

The policy feels a bit rigid for such a premium brand, and it’s something to keep in mind before buying. Make sure you’re certain about your purchase, because Stickley doesn’t mess around with returns.

• Long Delivery Times

Patience is key with Stickley. My table took about eight weeks to arrive, and I’ve heard of custom orders taking up to 10 weeks or more. In a world of next-day Amazon deliveries, waiting that long can feel like forever.

I didn’t mind too much since I knew it was being made to order, but if you’re in a rush to furnish your place, this could be a drawback. Planning ahead is a must with Stickley.

Maintenance Tips For Stickley Furniture

• Regular Dusting and Vacuuming

Keeping your Stickley pieces looking pristine is easier than you’d think. I dust my table and bookcase weekly with a clean, soft cloth to prevent grime buildup. For upholstery, like my sofa, I vacuum lightly with a brush attachment every couple of weeks.

Stickley recommends using a non-metallic, stiff bristle brush for tougher spots, but I’ve found a soft cloth works fine for regular maintenance. Just don’t go overboard with water or harsh cleaners—they can damage the wood or fabric.

• Protecting Wood Finishes

Stickley’s wood finishes are gorgeous but need a little TLC. I learned early on to avoid placing hot mugs or wet glasses directly on my table—coasters are your friend.

Stickley advises against using products like nail polish remover, perfume, or scented candles near wood furniture, as they can stain or dissolve the finish. I polish my table once a month with a high-quality furniture polish, applying it sparingly with a soft cloth and buffing it to a shine. Never mix polishes; stick to one brand to avoid buildup.

• Leather Care

My Morris chair’s leather is a dream, but it requires specific care. I dust it regularly with a clean white cloth and vacuum the crevices to keep it fresh. Stickley suggests avoiding direct sunlight or heat sources, as they can fade or dry out the leather.

I use a leather conditioner recommended by Stickley every six months to keep it soft and supple. If you spill something, blot it immediately with a dry cloth—don’t rub, or you’ll spread the mess.

• Controlling Humidity

Wood furniture like Stickley’s can be sensitive to humidity. I live in a place with fluctuating weather, so I use a humidifier in winter to keep the air around 40-50% humidity. This prevents the wood from cracking or warping.

Stickley also recommends storing table leaves flat in a controlled environment to avoid damage. I keep my extra leaves in a closet with a dehumidifier packet, just to be safe.

• Handling Spills and Stains

Spills happen—I know this all too well. When my kid spilled juice on my sofa, I blotted it right away with a clean cloth, working from the outside in to avoid a ring. For stubborn stains, Stickley suggests professional cleaning, but I’ve had luck with a mild soap-and-water solution on fabric upholstery.

Test it in a hidden spot first, though. For wood, a slightly damp cloth followed by immediate drying works best. Never let water sit on the surface.

Comparison of Stickley Furniture With Other Brands

Let’s see how Stickley stacks up against King Hickory Furniture, Canadel Furniture, and Mantle Furniture.

I’ve researched and even tested some of these brands to give you a clear picture of where Stickley shines and where others hold their own, focusing on quality, style, customization, and value.

• Stickley Vs. King Hickory Furniture

King Hickory Furniture, made in North Carolina, is known for its customizable upholstered pieces like sofas and sectionals. I sat on their Carolina Sofa at a friend’s house, and it’s plush with a cozy, lived-in feel. King Hickory offers a ton of fabric and leather options, which is great if you want a specific look.

However, their wood furniture, like occasional tables, doesn’t match Stickley’s craftsmanship. My Stickley dining table has tighter joinery and a more refined finish than King Hickory’s wood pieces, which felt less substantial.

Stickley’s focus on heirloom-quality hardwoods and Arts and Crafts designs gives it an edge for longevity and timeless style. King Hickory is slightly more affordable, especially for upholstery, but Stickley’s durability makes it the better long-term investment.

• Stickley Vs. Canadel Furniture

Canadel, a Canadian brand, specializes in customizable dining and bedroom furniture.

I checked out their Champlain collection at a showroom, and the rustic, handcrafted vibe is appealing, especially with their 50+ finishes and 200+ fabrics.

Canadel’s strength is personalization—you can tweak table sizes, leg styles, and even distress levels.

My Stickley table, while customizable, doesn’t offer quite as many options for distressing or unique shapes.

However, Stickley’s construction feels more robust; Canadel’s pieces, while solid, don’t have the same heirloom heft.

Price-wise, Canadel is often a bit cheaper, but Stickley’s sustainable practices and iconic Mission style make it stand out for those who want furniture with a legacy.

• Stickley Vs. Mantle Furniture

Mantle Furniture, another American brand, focuses on affordable, made-to-order pieces with a modern farmhouse aesthetic. I saw their Hudson dining set online and liked the clean, minimalist look, but when I visited a retailer, the quality didn’t impress me as much as Stickley’s.

Mantle’s furniture uses solid wood, but the joinery and finishes feel less meticulous—my Stickley bookcase has a hand-finished glow that Mantle’s pieces lack. Mantle is significantly cheaper, making it a good pick for budget-conscious buyers who still want custom options.

However, Stickley’s superior durability and timeless designs, like my Morris chair, make it the go-to for those prioritizing longevity over cost.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Wrapping Up

If you’re ready to invest in furniture that’s more than just a purchase, Stickley is the way to go. My home is proof—their pieces bring warmth, style, and durability that cheap furniture can’t touch. From the heirloom quality to the timeless designs, Stickley transforms your space into something special.

Sure, it’s a splurge, but it’s one you’ll never regret. Your grandkids will thank you when they’re still lounging on your Stickley sofa years from now.