If you’re in the market for new windows, you may be considering options from Simonton Windows. Two of their popular lines are the Madeira and DaylightMax series. But what’s the difference between these two window types?
And how do you choose which is right for your home?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare the Madeira and DaylightMax in depth, looking at key factors like materials, energy efficiency, cost, aesthetics, and more. Read on to learn the pros and cons of each so you can make an informed decision for your next window replacement project.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Madeira | DaylightMax |
| Frame Material | Vinyl | Ultrex Fiberglass |
| Frame Colors | White, Beige | White, Beige, Tan |
| Glazing | ThermaPlus SP Double Pane | Triple Pane IG |
| Energy Efficiency | ENERGY STAR qualified | Beyond ENERGY STAR |
| U-Factor | 0.30 | 0.27 |
| SHGC | 0.30 | 0.28 |
| Appearance | Slimline, clean edges | Sculpted edges, wood look |
| Glass Options | Low-E366, Obscure, Tempered | Triple-pane, Low-E272, Tempered |
| Installation | Lightweight, expandable | Geo-Loc sizes for easy replacement |
| Warranty | Lifetime Limited | Lifetime Limited |
| Cost | Budget-friendly | Premium price, better long-term savings |
Overview of Simonton Windows
First, let’s start with some background on Simonton Windows.
The company has over 70 years of industry experience, making them a trusted brand for replacement windows.
They offer a full range of products from single-hung windows to sliding doors.
Simonton windows are available through professional building supply retailers across the United States and Canada.
Their products are designed to suit various home styles and budgets. They also have robust quality testing procedures to ensure durable and reliable windows.
Key Differences Between Simonton Madeira And DaylightMax Windows
Now let’s look specifically at how the Madeira and DaylightMax series compare.
- Frame Materials
One of the biggest differences between Madeira and DaylightMax is the frame material.
Madeira windows have frames made from vinyl. This is a lightweight yet rigid material resistant to warping. Vinyl frames have excellent insulating properties and don’t require painting. Madeira vinyl is available in white or beige.
DaylightMax windows feature Ultrex fiberglass frames. Ultrex is Simonton’s patented material made to mimic wood in appearance while being highly durable. These fiberglass frames won’t warp, dent, or swell and also resist fading. They have a wood-like grain texture and are available in three colors: white, beige, and tan.
So in summary:
- Madeira: Vinyl frames that don’t require painting and have good insulation. Available in white or beige.
- DaylightMax: Durable, low-maintenance Ultrex fiberglass with wood-like aesthetics in white, beige or tan.
Fiberglass is considered more premium than vinyl, but both materials offer durability and low maintenance. Vinyl provides better insulation while fiberglass has more realistic wood aesthetics.
- Glazing
In addition to different frame materials, Madeira and DaylightMax windows also have different glazing configurations.
Madeira windows use ThermaPlus SP glazing.
This is Simonton’s standard double pane glass with an energy-efficient Low-E coating and argon gas fill.
It helps lower energy costs while reducing condensation.
DaylightMax offers triple pane Triple IG glazing.
With three panes instead of two, it enhances insulation, soundproofing, and protection from UV rays versus standard double glazing.
The inner and outer glass panes also have Low-E coatings for optimal efficiency.
To summarize the glazing:
- Madeira: ThermaPlus SP double glazing with Low-E and argon gas.
- DaylightMax: Triple glazing with Low-E on inner and outer panes for optimal efficiency.
The triple glazing gives DaylightMax better insulation and soundproofing. But double glazing is still energy efficient, especially with Low-E and argon.
- Energy Efficiency
Speaking of efficiency, just how do Madeira and DaylightMax compare in overall energy performance?
Madeira windows meet ENERGY STAR requirements in all 50 states. ENERGY STAR is a program by the EPA that sets strict efficiency guidelines. Madeira windows achieve this certification with ThermaPlus SP glazing, effective weatherstripping, and multi-chamber frame design.
But DaylightMax windows go beyond ENERGY STAR with better U-factors and Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC). Here are some comparisons:
- For a double-hung window, Madeira has a U-factor of 0.30 while DaylightMax has a U-factor of 0.27. The lower the U-factor, the better the insulation.
- For SHGC, Madeira has a 0.30 rating and DaylightMax has 0.28 in warmer climates. Lower SHGC reduces summer heat gain.
So while both series offer energy efficiency, DaylightMax excels in thermal performance. Its triple glazing and Ultrex frames boost insulation for potentially even greater long-term energy savings.
- Appearance and Design
Madeira and DaylightMax windows also differ in their appearance, color options, and overall design:
- Madeira has smooth, sleek vinyl frames in white or beige with flat casing and clean corners. The double-hung and sliding windows have an elegant slimline look.
- DaylightMax windows mimic wood with the fiberglass’ realistic grain texture. The Ultrex material is highly colorfast, so the white, beige, or tan coloring will stay true. The frames also have sculpted edges and robust details for a distinctive appearance.
For window styles, both Madeira and DaylightMax offer popular choices like single-hung, double-hung, sliders, casements, awnings, and more. Madeira windows come in many standard and custom sizes.
DaylightMax windows use a system called Geo-Loc sizing to suit regional standard opening sizes. So these windows are tailored to replace existing ones in your geographic area.
Overall, Madeira offers versatile and slimline vinyl windows. DaylightMax provides attractive, wood-look windows molded to common openings.
- Glass Options
Homeowners can further customize their Madeira or DaylightMax windows with different types of glass:
Madeira offers these added glass features:
- Low-E366 – Extra solar control Low-E coating to reduce heat gain
- Obscure – Frosted or pebbled glass for privacy
- Tempered – Added safety glass for impact resistance
DaylightMax glass options include:
- Triple-pane – Already standard, but a good upgrade over double-pane
- Low-E272 – Excellent insulation and solar control
- Tempered – For enhanced durability and safety
So both lines provide versatility with add-on glass types to suit your climate, privacy, and security needs. Madeira offers a bit more variety overall when it comes to specialty glazing.
- Installation and Replacement
Simonton Madeira and DaylightMax windows are installed by trained professionals, not DIY. This ensures proper integration with your home’s waterproofing and exterior.
The Madeira vinyl windows are lightweight, making them easy for installers to handle. The expandable frame design uses fins to simplify retrofitting into existing openings.
DaylightMax windows are a bit heavier due to the fiberglass material. But Simonton’s Geo-Loc sizes are molded to replicate common existing sizes. This makes swapping out old windows for new DaylightMax ones an easier direct replacement.
Overall, Madeira’s vinyl and DaylightMax’s molded Geo-Loc sizing both make installation straightforward. Professional window contractors will handle this process seamlessly.
- Warranties
The warranties on Madeira and DaylightMax windows give added peace of mind:
- Madeira windows have a Lifetime Limited Warranty covering the vinyl frames and component parts. The glass has a 20-year warranty.
- DaylightMax windows also come with a Lifetime Limited Warranty on the Ultrex frames and parts. The Triple IG glass carries a 20-year warranty.
These comprehensive warranties show the durability expected with both Simonton product lines. Madeira and DaylightMax windows are built to last for years if properly maintained.
- Cost Comparison
In terms of upfront investment, Madeira vinyl windows are more budget-friendly than DaylightMax.
Vinyl is less expensive than premium Ultrex fiberglass. And the standard double glazing also helps lower costs versus the triple glazing on DaylightMax.
But DaylightMax windows come with a higher purchase price since they are built with top-tier materials and glazing.
Their energy efficiency leads to better long-term cost savings on utilities over time. And fiberglass is highly durable, so DaylightMax windows can boost resale value.
Here is a general price overview:
- Madeira: More affordable initial cost, good for a tighter budget
- DaylightMax: Higher upfront investment, but greater energy savings long-term
Exact window pricing depends on your specific size, configuration, and location. Get quotes from retailers to compare exact costs for your project.
Madeira And DaylightMax: Which Is Best For You?
Now that we’ve compared these two lines in depth, how do you decide whether Madeira or DaylightMax is the right choice?
Here are a few quick recommendations based on key factors:
- Budget-friendly vinyl windows – Madeira
- Premium aesthetics and authentic wood look – DaylightMax
- Maximum energy efficiency – DaylightMax
- Soundproofing – DaylightMax for its triple glazing
- Easier retrofitting into existing spaces – Madeira or DaylightMax
But carefully weigh your priorities in terms of budget, features, efficiency, appearance, and more. If energy savings are most important, investing in DaylightMax triple glazing may pay off long-term. If you want great performance at a lower cost, Madeira windows are an excellent vinyl option.
Be sure to get professional quotes rather than relying on rough estimates. And work with qualified installers to ensure your new Simonton windows are properly sized, fitted, sealed, and integrated into your home’s structure.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Simonton Windows is one of the largest manufacturers of replacement windows in the U.S. They are consistently top-rated and ranked as one of the best window brands by both industry experts and customers.
Yes, Simonton makes high-quality windows known for durability, energy efficiency, and reliable performance. They offer affordable vinyl models along with premium fiberglass windows. Both their Madeira and DaylightMax product lines receive positive homeowner reviews.
Most Simonton windows meet or exceed ENERGY STAR requirements. Their Madeira series qualifies for ENERGY STAR in all 50 states. DaylightMax goes beyond ENERGY STAR standards with triple glazing for even better efficiency.
The DaylightMax window frame width is 3 1/4 inches. This allows for a good balance of an authentic wood look while maximizing the visible glass area. The fiberglass frame material is narrower than typical vinyl but has a realistic wood grain texture.
Final Thoughts
Simonton’s Madeira and DaylightMax lines are both quality options made by a trusted manufacturer. Now that you know the detailed pros and cons of each, you can make an informed decision based on your budget, efficiency needs, aesthetics, and other factors unique to your home.
Be sure to get professional quotes for installation rather than rough estimates. This will give you a more accurate cost comparison. An experienced window contractor can also advise you on selecting the proper sizes and configurations.
Investing in new Simonton windows is a major home upgrade. But with the right choice like durable, energy efficient Madeira or DaylightMax, you’ll benefit from greater comfort and savings for years to come.
