I’ve spent years wielding a paintbrush, transforming homes and offices with fresh coats of color. Choosing the right paint is a make-or-break decision for any project, and Sherwin-Williams offers a dizzying array of options.
Two of their most popular lines, ProMar 200 and Emerald, often spark debates among contractors and DIYers alike. In this article, I’ll share my hands-on experience with both, breaking down their pros, cons, and key features to help you decide which paint suits your needs.
From coverage to durability, I’ve got you covered with insights to make your next painting project a success.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | ProMar 200 | Emerald |
| Price per Gallon | ~$30–$40 (contractor), ~$72 (retail) | ~$80–$110 (retail) |
| VOC Content | Zero VOC | Zero VOC |
| Coverage | 250–400 sq. ft./gallon | 350–400 sq. ft./gallon |
| Durability | Moderate, good for low-traffic areas | Excellent, ideal for high-traffic areas |
| Washability | Moderate, shows marks with heavy scrubbing | Superior, withstands frequent cleaning |
| Finishes Available | Flat, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss, Gloss | Flat, Matte, Satin, Semi-Gloss |
| Application | Easy, good for contractors | Smooth, slightly thicker, professional-grade |
| Best For | Budget-friendly commercial/residential jobs | Premium residential, high-end projects |
| Mold/Mildew Resistance | Good, with anti-microbial agents | Excellent, advanced mold/mildew protection |
| Touch-Up Ability | Excellent, seamless touch-ups even years later | Good, but may show slight sheen differences |
My Journey With ProMar 200 And Emerald
As a painter, I’ve rolled gallons of both ProMar 200 and Emerald across walls, ceilings, and trim. Each has its own personality, and picking the right one depends on the job at hand. ProMar 200 is like the reliable workhorse of paints—affordable, versatile, and a go-to for contractors.
Emerald, on the other hand, feels like the luxury sedan of the paint world—premium, durable, and built for lasting beauty. Let me walk you through my experiences, breaking down what makes each paint tick and where they shine or stumble.
ProMar 200: The Contractor’s Choice
When I first started painting professionally, ProMar 200 was my introduction to Sherwin-Williams’ contractor-grade line.
It’s designed for folks like me who need a paint that gets the job done without breaking the bank.
I’ve used it in everything from new construction homes to apartment complexes, and it’s earned its reputation as a solid, no-fuss option.
Key Features of ProMar 200
ProMar 200 is a zero-VOC interior latex paint, meaning it’s low-odor and environmentally friendly. This is a big deal when you’re painting indoors, especially in spaces where people live or work.
I’ve painted entire homes with ProMar 200 and barely noticed a smell, which is a relief compared to the headache-inducing fumes of older oil-based paints. It comes in six sheens—Flat, Low Sheen, Eggshell, Satin, Semi-Gloss, and Gloss—giving me flexibility for different surfaces and aesthetics.
Coverage is decent, typically 250–400 square feet per gallon, depending on the surface. I’ve found it spreads smoothly with a brush or roller, rarely splattering, which makes for a clean workday.
It dries quickly, often within 30 minutes to an hour, so I can apply a second coat without waiting all day. The paint also boasts anti-microbial agents that help prevent mold and mildew, which is great for humid climates or bathrooms.
One standout feature is its touch-up ability. I’ve gone back to jobs years later, touched up a scuff or two, and the results blended seamlessly. This is a lifesaver for rental properties or homes where touch-ups are frequent.
ProMar 200 also holds color well indoors, though it can fade in sun-exposed areas over time.
Pros of ProMar 200
- Affordable Price Point: At around $30–$40 per gallon with a contractor discount, it’s a budget-friendly choice for large projects. Even at retail (~$72), it’s cheaper than premium paints.
- Zero VOC: No harsh odors, making it ideal for indoor use, especially in occupied spaces.
- Excellent Touch-Up: Touch-ups blend effortlessly, even after years, saving time and money.
- Easy Application: Smooth and cooperative whether brushed, rolled, or sprayed.
- Versatile Finishes: From flat to gloss, it suits walls, ceilings, and trim.
- Good for Commercial Use: Perfect for apartments, offices, or new builds where cost matters.
Cons of ProMar 200
- Moderate Durability: It holds up in low-traffic areas but scuffs or marks in busy spaces like hallways.
- Limited Washability: Scrubbing too hard can leave marks or dull the finish, especially in glossy sheens.
- Not Self-Priming: Often requires a separate primer for bare surfaces or drastic color changes.
- Fades in Sunlight: Not the best for sun-drenched rooms or exteriors.
- Not Premium Quality: It’s reliable but lacks the richness and longevity of higher-end paints.
I remember painting a rental unit with ProMar 200 Flat. The walls looked crisp, and the client loved the low cost. But when tenants moved in, the walls showed scuffs after a few months of wear.
It’s great for quick jobs or spaces that get repainted often, but for a family home with kids and pets, it’s not my first choice.
Emerald: The Premium Performer
When I want a paint that screams quality, I reach for Sherwin-Williams Emerald. This is the brand’s top-tier interior acrylic latex paint, designed for homeowners and high-end projects where durability and finish matter.
I’ve used Emerald in upscale homes, and it never fails to impress with its rich, professional look.
Key Features of Emerald
Like ProMar 200, Emerald is zero-VOC, so it’s low-odor and eco-friendly.
It covers 350–400 square feet per gallon, often with fewer coats than ProMar 200, thanks to its superior hide.
Available in Flat, Matte, Satin, and Semi-Gloss finishes, it’s versatile enough for most interior surfaces.
What sets it apart is its advanced stain-blocking technology and exceptional washability.
I’ve scrubbed walls painted with Emerald, and they look as good as new, even after years of wear.
Emerald’s formula is thicker, giving it a luxurious feel when applied. It’s self-priming on most surfaces, which saves time and money on prep.
The paint also resists mold and mildew better than ProMar 200, making it a top pick for bathrooms or kitchens. Its color retention is stellar, even in rooms with big windows where UV rays are a concern. However, touch-ups can be trickier, especially with glossier finishes, as sheen differences may show.
Pros of Emerald
- Superior Durability: Built for high-traffic areas, it resists scuffs, stains, and wear.
- Excellent Washability: Scrub away dirt without damaging the finish.
- Great Coverage: Often achieves full coverage in one coat, saving time and paint.
- Self-Priming: No need for a separate primer on most surfaces.
- UV Resistance: Retains color and sheen in sun-exposed areas.
- Premium Finish: Offers a rich, smooth look that elevates any space.
Cons of Emerald
- High Cost: At $80–$110 per gallon, it’s a significant investment.
- Thicker Formula: Can feel heavy for beginners, requiring a steady hand.
- Touch-Up Challenges: Sheen differences may show, especially in glossier finishes.
- Overkill for Some Projects: Its premium features may be unnecessary for low-traffic spaces.
- Limited Sheen Options: Fewer finishes compared to ProMar 200.
I once painted a client’s living room with Emerald Satin. The walls had a silky, flawless finish that made the room feel high-end. Years later, the client called to say the walls still looked pristine despite kids and pets.
But when I touched up a small ding, I had to be meticulous to avoid sheen mismatches. Emerald’s quality is undeniable, but it demands precision.
Head-to-Head Comparison of Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 And Emerald
Let’s break down how ProMar 200 and Emerald stack up in key areas. I’ve painted with both in various settings, so I’ll share what I’ve learned from real-world use.
- Cost and Value
ProMar 200 is the clear winner for budget-conscious projects.
With contractor pricing, I’ve snagged it for as low as $30 per gallon, though retail can hit $72.
It’s a go-to for commercial jobs or rentals where cost trumps longevity.
Emerald, at $80–$110 per gallon, is a splurge.
But its durability and one-coat coverage often mean fewer gallons and less labor, which can offset the price for high-end homes.
- Coverage and Application
ProMar 200 covers 250–400 square feet per gallon, but I often need two coats for a uniform finish, especially over darker colors. It’s forgiving for beginners, spreading easily without splatter.
Emerald’s coverage is slightly better, often hitting 350–400 square feet with one coat on primed surfaces. Its thicker formula feels luxurious but can be tricky for novices. I’ve found Emerald flows better on smooth walls, while ProMar 200 handles textured surfaces like a champ.
- Durability and Washability
This is where Emerald shines. I’ve seen ProMar 200 hold up in low-traffic bedrooms, but in kitchens or hallways, it scuffs under heavy use. Scrubbing can dull its finish, especially in glossy sheens. Emerald, on the other hand, laughs off dirt and grime.
I’ve cleaned walls painted with Emerald Matte with no trace of damage, making it ideal for homes with kids or pets.
- Mold and Mildew Resistance
Both paints have anti-microbial agents, but Emerald’s advanced formula offers better protection. In a humid bathroom I painted with ProMar 200, I noticed slight mildew after a year.
The same space painted with Emerald stayed spotless. If moisture is a concern, Emerald is worth the extra cost.
- Touch-Up and Color Retention
ProMar 200 is a touch-up dream. I’ve touched up walls years later with no lap marks or color mismatches. Emerald’s touch-ups are trickier, especially in Satin or Semi-Gloss, where sheen differences can show.
However, Emerald’s color retention is unmatched, holding vibrant hues even in sunny rooms, while ProMar 200 may fade in direct sunlight.
- Best Use Cases
ProMar 200 is my pick for budget-driven projects like rentals, new construction, or spaces that get repainted often. It’s reliable, affordable, and gets the job done.
Emerald is for homeowners who want a premium, long-lasting finish, especially in high-traffic areas or rooms with moisture. If you’re painting a forever home, Emerald’s durability and washability make it a smart investment.
My Experiences With Sherwin-Williams ProMar 200 And Emerald
I’ve had my fair share of painting adventures with both paints.
One summer, I tackled a new condo complex with ProMar 200.
The budget was tight, and the developer wanted a clean, professional look.
The paint went on smoothly, and the touch-up ability saved us when movers nicked the walls.
But when I painted a family’s dining room with Emerald, the difference was night and day.
The rich finish and durability wowed the homeowners, and they didn’t mind the higher cost for a space they’d use daily.
Another time, I used ProMar 200 Eggshell in an apartment. It looked great initially, but after a year of tenants, the walls showed wear. In contrast, a kitchen I painted with Emerald Matte held up through spills and splashes, looking as good as the day I finished.
These experiences taught me that ProMar 200 is a solid choice for quick, cost-effective jobs, while Emerald is the star for lasting quality.
Choosing The Right Paint For You
So, how do you decide?
It comes down to your project, budget, and priorities.
If you’re a contractor or DIYer working on a rental or flip, ProMar 200’s affordability and touch-up ease make it a no-brainer.
It’s reliable and gets the job done without draining your wallet.
But if you’re painting your home and want a finish that lasts, resists stains, and looks luxurious, Emerald is worth every penny.
Its durability and washability mean fewer repaints, saving you money in the long run.
Consider the space you’re painting. For low-traffic areas like guest rooms, ProMar 200 is plenty. For kitchens, bathrooms, or hallways, Emerald’s toughness is unmatched. Think about sunlight exposure too—Emerald’s UV resistance makes it ideal for sunny rooms.
And if you’re eco-conscious, both are zero-VOC, so you can’t go wrong there.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Sherwin-Williams SuperPaint, Duration, and Emerald are all superior in durability and washability. SuperPaint offers a great balance of quality and cost, while Duration and Emerald excel in high-traffic or high-moisture areas.
Emerald is Sherwin-Williams’ top-tier interior paint, offering unmatched durability, washability, and coverage. However, “best” depends on your needs—SuperPaint or Duration may suffice for less demanding projects at a lower cost.
Emerald’s thicker formula can feel heavy for beginners but provides excellent coverage and a premium finish. With proper technique, it’s manageable and not overly thick.
Emerald is Sherwin-Williams’ premium interior and exterior acrylic latex paint line, known for superior durability, washability, stain-blocking, and zero-VOC formulas. It’s ideal for high-end residential and commercial projects.
Wrapping Up
You’re standing at the paint counter, torn between ProMar 200 and Emerald, and I get it—it’s a big decision. My years of painting have shown me that ProMar 200 is your trusty, budget-friendly ally for quick jobs or spaces that don’t need to withstand daily wear.
Emerald, though, is the premium choice, delivering a durable, stunning finish that’ll make your home shine for years. Weigh your budget, the room’s purpose, and how long you want the paint to last.
Whatever you choose, you’re on your way to transforming your space with confidence.