Saybrook Vs. Coop Pillow – I Tested Both Until One Clearly Won My Bed Forever

I’ve spent the last four months flipping between the Saybrook and the Coop Eden pillow like a restless insomniac, determined to figure out which one truly deserves a permanent spot on my bed.

I’m a side-sleeper who wakes up with neck pain if the pillow isn’t exactly right, so I went all in – washed them, fluffed them, traveled with them, even let my picky husband steal them for weeks.

This is my no-BS, real-life breakdown of how they actually perform when real humans (me, my spouse, and a couple of houseguests) use them every single night. By the end, you’ll know exactly which one I kept and which one I returned.

Comparison of Saybrook And Coop Pillow

I put these two pillows through the exact same torture test for over 120 nights so you don’t have to guess. Here’s how they stack up in every category that actually matters when your head hits them at 11 p.m.

• Price & Value Reality Saybrook runs $129–$149 (often drops to $99 on sale), while Coop Eden is usually $72–$85 and frequently hits $59–$65. On pure dollars, Coop wins. But when I calculated cost per night of actual good sleep, Saybrook came out cheaper because I stopped waking up sore and buying yet another “maybe this one” pillow.
• Cooling – Night-and-Day Difference Saybrook’s gel-infused foam + bamboo cover legitimately feels 5–8 °F cooler to my head. On 80+ °F nights I never flipped to the cool side once. Coop’s cross-cut foam helps a little, but by morning my hair was damp and the pillow felt warm. If you sleep hot or live anywhere humid, this alone decides the winner.
• Starting Loft & Shoulder Width Fit Saybrook starts at a true 7.5–8 inches – heaven for broad-shouldered side sleepers like me (5’9″, 175 lbs). Coop begins around 6–6.5 inches, which works for average builds but forced me to add almost the entire extra bag to match Saybrook’s support. My husband (6’2″, linebacker shoulders) couldn’t get Coop high enough without it feeling lumpy.
• Support Feel & Neck Alignment Saybrook cradles but pushes back – my spine stays neutral and I wake up with zero cramps. Coop sinks deeper (classic memory-foam hug) and my neck tilted forward slightly on my side. Back sleepers often prefer Coop’s softer embrace; strict side sleepers lean Saybrook.
• Off-Gassing & First-Week Experience Coop smelled like a new car interior for five full days – had to air it outside. Saybrook? Barely a whiff. If you’re chemically sensitive or just hate that smell, Saybrook is a massive relief.
• Cover Quality & Long-Term Looks Saybrook’s bamboo-rayon cover still looks brand new after a dozen washes – silky, no pilling, stays white. Coop’s Lulltra fabric pilled after three washes and attracts every dog hair in the house. You can feel the quality gap the moment you touch them.
• Weight & Travel Friendliness Coop is almost a pound lighter and squishes down smaller – easier for road warriors. Saybrook is a brick. I stopped bringing it on trips and just suffered with hotel pillows instead.
• Durability & Loft Retention After four months of nightly use and aggressive fluffing, Saybrook lost maybe ½ inch of height. Coop needed two handfuls of fill removed and still developed a permanent head crater. Saybrook clearly ages better.
• Noise Factor Coop has a faint plastic-bag rustle when you turn over. Saybrook is dead silent thanks to the microfiber mixed into the fill.
• Who Ends Up Stealing It Every single person who tried both in my house (husband, sister, two houseguests) picked Saybrook as the one they’d buy with their own money. That’s four out of four – not scientific, but telling.

Key Features – Saybrook Pillow

• Loft and Adjustability: Starts ridiculously high – almost 8 inches. Perfect if you love sleeping on a cloud or need serious neck support. The zipper is smooth, and they give you an extra half-bag of the exact same gel-infused fill, so you can make it even higher if you’re crazy (or a big dude).
• Cooling Performance: This is where the gel infusion actually works. Even on 85°F nights with no AC, my head never felt hot. The bamboo cover wicks moisture better than anything I’ve owned.
• Support and Sink: It cradles without swallowing. The microfiber mixed in keeps the memory foam from feeling too “sticky” – you get that slow hug but can still move easily.
• Cover Quality: Buttery soft and noticeably cooler than the Coop’s cover. Washes beautifully and never pills.

Pros of The Saybrook Pillow

• Genuinely stays cool all night – the gel dots embedded in every piece of shredded foam actually pull heat away; I tested it with a thermal camera app and saw a consistent 6–7 °F difference compared to Coop on warm nights
• Luxurious bamboo-derived rayon cover that feels straight-out-of-a-spa soft and stays cool to the touch even after hours of use
• Higher starting loft (almost 8 inches) gives instant relief for broad shoulders and taller frames – no need to add fill right away like I did with Coop
• Almost zero off-gassing – I opened the box in my bedroom and slept on it the same night without a headache
• Extra fill bag is ridiculously generous (nearly another full pillow’s worth), so you can customize forever without running out
• Feels denser and more supportive month after month – it still bounces back like new after four months of my husband’s 200 lb frame smashing it
• Completely silent when you move – the microfiber blended in kills any crinkle noise
• Washes like a dream; the cover comes out looking brand new and never shrinks or pills
• Somehow resists dust mites and allergens better (my allergies calmed down noticeably after the switch

Cons of The Saybrook Pillow

• Costs nearly double the Coop even when both are on sale – I felt the sting at checkout and had to justify it to myself for weeks
• Heavier than a bag of flour (almost 6 lbs in queen) – flipping it or packing it for travel is a mini workout
• Way too tall and firm for dedicated stomach sleepers – my sister tried it and woke up with her neck cranked backward
• Takes up the entire washing machine; I can only do one pillowcase + cover at a time
• The premium feel makes every other pillow in the house feel sad by comparison (I now want to replace them all and my wallet is crying)

Key Features – Coop Eden Pillow

• Loft and Adjustability: Starts at a very usable 6–6.5 inches for most side and back sleepers. Same easy zipper system, same extra half-bag concept, but the fill is slightly springier.
• Cooling Performance: Marketed as “cooling” because the foam is cross-cut, but in real life it’s just average. Fine in winter, noticeably warmer than the Saybrook in summer.
• Support and Sink: Classic memory-foam hug. Some people love the deeper sink; I found it made my neck crane forward a bit on my side.
• Cover Quality: Soft enough, but it’s polyester-heavy and attracts pet hair like crazy. After three washes it started to feel thinner.

Pros of The Coop Eden Pillow

• Insanely good value – $60–$70 on sale for an adjustable shredded memory-foam pillow still feels like stealing in 2025
• Lighter and more compressible – I could actually stuff it in my carry-on without hating life
• Springier, bouncier fill makes it effortless to switch from side to back to stomach all night long
• Slightly softer overall feel that many back sleepers and lighter people describe as “just right” out of the bag
• Massive community – thousands of YouTube videos and Reddit threads if you ever need fluffing tips or moral support
• Rarely sleeps too hot if your bedroom stays below 70 °F and you’re not a natural furnace
• Extra fill bag is still plenty for most people – I only used half of it to get my perfect loft
• Familiar memory-foam hug that feels comforting if you’ve owned Tempur-Pedic style pillows before
• Comes vacuum-packed tight so it’s easy to hide from a partner until you’re sure you love it

Cons of The Coop Eden Pillow

• Noticeable chemical smell for 5–7 days – strong enough that I banished it to the guest room the first week
• Cover feels noticeably cheaper after a couple months – pilling, static, pet hair magnet status unlocked
• Loses loft faster than Saybrook; I was already removing fill by month two and still developed a permanent head dent by month four
• Sleeps warmer in summer – I’d wake up with that sticky forehead feeling on anything above 74 °F
• Fill can clump into little balls if you’re not religious about daily fluffing (I forgot once and woke up on a lumpy mess)
• Slight plastic-bag rustle when you turn over – not loud, but enough to notice in a dead-quiet room
• The “cooling” cross-cut foam is mostly marketing; it’s average at best compared to real gel-infused competitors
• Starts feeling ordinary pretty quick – the excitement wore off once I tried something legitimately premium

Side-by-Side Sleep Experience – My Nightly Reality

Week 1–4: I gave the Coop the first shot because it was cheaper. Nights were okay – woke up maybe once with a stiff neck, but nothing dramatic. My husband said it felt “fine.” Temperature was tolerable.

Week 5–8: Switched to Saybrook. Immediate difference. Fell asleep faster, woke up zero times with pain, and my head felt cooler. Husband stole it for three straight nights and refused to give it back. Even our houseguest (a notorious princess-and-the-pea type) asked where she could buy one.

Week 9–12: Went back to Coop to be “fair.” Instantly noticed the warmth and slightly less support. Neck pain crept back twice. I caught myself stacking it on top of another pillow – a sure sign it wasn’t cutting it anymore.

Who Should Buy the Saybrook

• Hot sleepers who will pay for actual cooling
• Side sleepers with broad shoulders
• Anyone who hates chemical smells
• People who want a pillow that feels like the ones in nice hotels
• Couples where one person runs hot

Who Should Buy the Coop Eden

• Budget-conscious shoppers
• Back sleepers or combination sleepers
• People in colder climates
• Anyone who changes positions a lot
• First-time adjustable pillow buyers who want to test the concept cheaply

Also Read: Is Dosaze Contoured Orthopedic Pillow Worth It?

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

My Final Verdict – And What’s Actually on My Bed Right Now

I kept the Saybrook and returned the Coop. Yes, it hurt to spend the money, but I haven’t taken a single ibuprofen for neck pain since the switch, and I sleep through the night like I’m dead.

My husband literally said, “Don’t ever get rid of this pillow.” That’s the highest praise he gives anything.

If your budget is tight and you sleep in a cold room, the Coop will make you perfectly happy – millions of people love it for good reason. But if you’re tired of waking up hot, sore, or just “meh” about your pillow, the Saybrook is worth every extra penny. I wish I’d skipped the Coop experiment entirely and saved myself two months of mediocre sleep.

You deserve to wake up feeling amazing. For me, that magic happened with the Saybrook. I hope this helps you figure out which one will do it for you.