Summer is right around the corner, and for many homeowners that means it’s time to service your air conditioner or invest in a new system. Two of the most popular air conditioner brands on the market are Payne and Bryant, but you may be wondering how they compare.
Both Payne and Bryant air conditioners offer high efficiency and reliable cooling, but they have some key differences that may make one a better choice over the other for your home.
In this guide, we’ll take an in-depth look at Payne and Bryant AC units so you can decide which is the right pick for you.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | Payne | Bryant |
|---|---|---|
| Efficiency Ratings | 13-19 SEER | 16-21 SEER |
| Cooling Stages | Single, Two, Variable | Two, Variable |
| Smart Technology | Basic Wi-Fi app control | Advanced controls & connectivity |
| Sound Levels | Average | Very low |
| Air Filtration | Average | Advanced filtration systems |
| Warranty | 10 years parts/compressor | 12 years parts/compressor |
| Price | Affordable, lower cost | Expensive, premium pricing |
| Reputation | Good quality, value brand | Top tier, highest quality brand |
Overview of Payne Air Conditioners
Payne air conditioners are manufactured by Carrier Corporation, a leading name in the HVAC industry. Payne aims to provide feature-rich AC systems that are budget friendly compared to premium brands like Carrier. Payne offers central air conditioners in a range of efficiencies and features:
- Efficiency Ratings: Payne central air units are available in SEER ratings from 13 to 19 SEER for energy efficient cooling. Higher SEER units promote lower energy bills.
- Cooling Stages: Single, two, and variable stage cooling is offered. Higher stage units run more efficiently.
- Smart Technology: Many Payne AC systems are Wi-Fi enabled and work with Carrier’s smart app for monitoring and adjusting temperatures remotely.
- Coils: Payne uses quality copper tubing and aluminum fins in their evaporator and condenser coils for durability. Some models have corrosion-resistant coated coils.
- Warranty: Payne air conditioners have 10-year warranties on parts and compressors, reflecting good predicted lifespan.
Payne tends to be affordably priced, making them a popular choice among homeowners looking for value. While not as feature-packed as premium Carrier units, Payne ACs offer solid cooling technology at more budget friendly price points.
Overview of Bryant Air Conditioners
Bryant is also owned by Carrier Corporation and is positioned as their premium air conditioner brand. Bryant focuses on high end features, advanced technology, and maximum durability. Key traits of Bryant central air conditioners include:
- Efficiency Ratings: With SEER ratings from 16 to 21 SEER, Bryant offers some of the most energy efficient central ACs available. Their Evolution variable speed models are ENERGY STAR Most Efficient certified.
- Smart Technology: Bryant AC units have advanced Wi-Fi capability allowing control through their mobile app and integration with smart home platforms.
- Quiet Operation: Bryant’s variable speed compressors and sound-dampening fan designs make their ACs some of the quietest running.
- Healthy Air: Special air filtration systems remove more allergens, bacteria, and other pollutants from the home.
- Coils: Bryant’s proprietary Spine Fin coil design optimizes airflow and heat transfer for maximum efficiency and longevity.
- Warranty: 12-year parts and compressor warranties reflect Bryant’s reputation for reliability and performance.
While you’ll pay more upfront for a Bryant compared to a Payne, the advanced features, energy savings, and long lasting durability make them worthwhile investments for many homeowners.
Payne And Bryant Air Conditioners: Key Differences
Now that we’ve reviewed the basics on Payne and Bryant air conditioners, let’s compare them across some key factors:
- Efficiency Ratings
When it comes to energy efficiency, Bryant air conditioners are the clear winner. Their Evolution variable speed systems reach SEER ratings as high as 21, significantly beating Payne’s maximum 19 SEER models.
Bryant AC units with two stage and variable speed compressors run much more efficiently than single stage Payne units. Over time, the electrical savings of a top tier Bryant AC can really add up.
Winner: Bryant
- Cooling Performance
Both Payne and Bryant use quality components that provide very reliable cooling. Variable capacity Bryant models may have a slight performance edge thanks to their modulating compressors optimizing runtimes.
But Payne ACs utilize proven cooling technology that competently cools homes in hot climates. For whole home cooling in an average sized house, both brands are good options.
Result: Tie
- Sound Levels
With their variable speed operation and insulated cabinets, Bryant air conditioners are exceptionally quiet. Even at their highest speeds, Bryant Evolution models produce sound levels under 68 dBA.
Payne air conditioners do not have as advanced sound dampening and run louder than Bryant units. If you’re sensitive to noise, Bryant’s quiet operation gives them an advantage.
Winner: Bryant
- Technology Features
Bryant offers far more advanced technology features compared to Payne units.
Their AC models have cutting edge communicative controls, integration with smart home platforms, and advanced air filtration.
Payne air conditioners provide basic Wi-Fi control from a mobile app, but lack the sophisticated electronics of Bryant systems.
For connectivity and smart home perks, Bryant is the leader.
Winner: Bryant
- Warranties
The warranty terms reflect the reputation for reliability between the two brands. Bryant ACs come with 12-year parts and compressor warranties, while Payne offers 10 years of coverage.
The additional 2 years of protection from Bryant demonstrates confidence in their products’ lifespans. But Payne’s 10-year terms are still strong.
Winner: Bryant
- Reputation
As Carrier Corporation’s premium offering, Bryant ACs have an excellent reputation for innovation, efficiency, and reliability. Payne is seen as a more budget friendly brand, though still solid quality.
Between the two brands, Bryant is more recognized and respected by HVAC pros as making some of the best air conditioners.
Winner: Bryant
- Price
The advanced features and robust warranties of Bryant air conditioners come at a cost. Bryant units can run $1000 or more above comparable Payne models. Payne provides great value at lower price points.
If your budget is tight, Payne ACs help you save. For the highest quality though, Bryant is worth the investment.
Winner: Payne
By comparing Payne and Bryant AC units across these factors, you can begin weighing which brand better aligns with your priorities. Keep reading as we compare specific Payne and Bryant models head to head.
Payne And Bryant Air Conditioner Model Comparisons
To further help you decide between Payne and Bryant, let’s pit some best selling models against each other:
Payne PV16 Vs. Bryant 116ANA
The Payne PV16 and Bryant 116ANA are both single stage 16 SEER AC units. The PV16 is Payne’s base model at this efficiency level, while the 116ANA is Bryant’s lowest tier 16 SEER AC.
- Cooling: Both provide reliable cooling for an average home. The base Bryant unit may be slightly better constructed.
- Technology: The 116ANA includes Wi-Fi capability that the PV16 lacks.
- Price: Payne PV16 is the more affordable option by over $200.
Overview: The Payne PV16 gives you an affordable entry to 16 SEER performance. But the 116ANA offers more connectivity and the reputation of Bryant quality for under $1000 more – a justifiable upcharge for many buyers.
Winner: Bryant 116ANA
Payne PA14NC Vs. Bryant 926T
The Payne PA14NC and Bryant 926T both represent a highly efficient variable speed AC option from their respective brand. The Payne PA14NC reaches 19 SEER while the Bryant 926T boasts 20.5 SEER.
- Efficiency: With 5 SEER points higher rating, the Bryant 926T saves more on electrical costs.
- Comfort: The Bryant model offers quieter, more balanced cooling thanks to its variable compressor.
- Controls: The 926T integrates with advanced communicative controls and smart home tech that the PA14NC lacks.
- Price: There is around a $1500 difference in cost with the Bryant unit being more expensive.
Overview: The Bryant 926T justifies its higher price with much smarter, more efficient performance and superior comfort features. It’s a premier AC pick worth the investment.
Winner: Bryant 926T
Payne PA16NC Vs. Bryant Preferred 824ANX
The Payne PA16NC and Bryant Preferred 824ANX both utilize two stage compressors and have Wi-Fi controls. The Payne model is rated at 17 SEER while the Bryant achieves up to 20.5 SEER.
- Efficiency: Once again Bryant wins on energy savings with 4 SEER points higher rating.
- Sound: The Bryant unit runs quieter at its lower stage.
- Filters: The 824ANX uses advanced air filtration to remove airborne particulates.
- Price: About a $500 price premium for the Bryant model.
Overview: With extra efficiency, quieter operation, and better filtration, the Bryant Preferred 824ANX delivers meaningful upgrades over the Payne PA16NC to justify the added cost.
Winner: Bryant Preferred 824ANX
The head to head model comparisons reinforce Bryant’s advantages in efficiency, technology, and premium features. Payne models provide similar cooling at lower price points. Use these matchup comparisons to help narrow your search to the best AC for your specific needs and budget.
Payne Or Bryant Air Conditioners: Which Is Better For You?
After reviewing Payne and Bryant central air conditioners in depth, we can make some summarizing recommendations on which brand may be a better choice for certain homeowners:
Pick Payne If…
- You want reliable cooling at a budget friendly price
- A basic 16-18 SEER unit meets your efficiency needs
- You don’t need fancy tech features or premium add-ons
- Every dollar saved on your AC purchase matters
Pick Bryant If…
- You want best-in-class efficiency to save significantly on energy costs
- Advanced comfort, filtration, and smart controls are important to you
- You have a larger home that needs extra cooling power
- Long-term durability and warranties give you peace of mind
While the final choice depends on your specific needs and preferences, evaluating Payne vs. Bryant across key factors should help guide your AC buying decision. Visiting an HVAC showroom to compare models in person is also recommended.
And be sure to get multiple quotes from qualified local HVAC contractors who can properly size and install your new air conditioner. Finding the right AC unit from Payne, Bryant, or another trusted brand will keep your home comfortable for years to come.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Still trying to choose between Payne and Bryant AC units? Here we answer some common questions homeowners have when comparing these two brands:
Bryant and Payne air conditioners are made by the same parent company, Carrier. However, they are positioned as separate brands. Payne is the more affordable offering while Bryant is the premium line with higher end features and technology. Their model lineups and performance differ despite being sister brands.
As part of the Carrier company, Payne air conditioners utilize proven cooling technology also found in Carrier branded units. However, Carrier ACs are seen as higher tier offerings with increased efficiency, more features, and better warranties. Payne provides a more budget friendly alternative to premium Carrier air conditioners.
Payne is a reputable brand that makes quality air conditioning units. They use sturdy components that provide reliable cooling and efficiency. While not the fanciest AC units, Payne systems are cost effective options that sufficiently cool homes. Their affordable prices and 10-year warranties give them appeal for buyers looking for value.
Yes, Payne is owned by Carrier Corporation. Payne air conditioners are manufactured under the same parent company that produces Carrier, Bryant, and other leading HVAC brands. The technology in Payne units is derived from Carrier’s decades of AC engineering and innovation.
Closing Remarks
Comparing Payne and Bryant allows you to balance factors like price, efficiency, features, and reputation when selecting an AC. Carefully weigh which benefits matter most so you choose the ideal brand and air conditioner for your home.
With proper installation and maintenance, your new Payne or Bryant AC unit should deliver comfortable performance all summer long.