I’ve spent years in my kitchen, grinding away food scraps and wrestling with the occasional clogged sink, so I know a thing or two about garbage disposals.
When it came time to replace my old unit, I found myself torn between two heavyweights: Moen and InSinkErator. This article is my journey to compare these brands, weighing their pros and cons, features, and performance from a real user’s perspective.
I’ll break down what makes each brand tick, helping you decide which fits your kitchen best.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Moen | InSinkErator |
| Motor Type | Permanent Magnet (up to 2700 RPM) | DuraDrive Induction (1725 RPM) |
| Horsepower Options | 1/3 HP to 1 HP | 1/3 HP to 1.25 HP |
| Noise Reduction | SoundSHIELD insulation | SoundSeal technology |
| Grinding Stages | Single-stage | MultiGrind (2-4 stages) |
| Warranty | 5-10 years | 1-12 years |
| Mounting System | Universal Xpress Mount | QuickLock Mount |
| Power Cord | Pre-installed | Optional (sold separately) |
| Price Range | $100-$300 | $100-$800 |
| Model Variety | ~13 models | ~20+ models |
| Best For | Easy installation, style | Heavy-duty grinding, quietness |
Why I’m Comparing Moen And InSinkErator?
As a home cook who churns out meals daily, my garbage disposal is a kitchen MVP. It handles everything from veggie peels to chicken bones, keeping my sink clear and my trash can less smelly.
But when my old disposal started groaning like a tired old dog, I knew it was time for an upgrade. Moen and InSinkErator kept popping up as top contenders, and for good reason—they dominate the market.
I wanted to understand what sets them apart, so I rolled up my sleeves, tested models, and spoke with other homeowners to get the full picture.
Both brands have their fans. InSinkErator is the veteran, with decades of trust and a wide range of models. Moen, newer to the disposal game, brings its reputation for sleek faucets and innovative design.
I’m not here to crown a winner outright but to give you a clear, no-nonsense comparison based on my experience and research. Let’s get into it.
My Experience With Moen Garbage Disposals
I started with a Moen GXS75C Host Series 3/4 HP unit, drawn by its sleek black casing and promise of easy installation.
Right out of the box, I noticed the pre-installed power cord—a small but appreciated touch.
Swapping out my old disposal took about 20 minutes, thanks to the Universal Xpress Mount, which clicked into place with minimal fuss.
If you’re a DIYer like me, this is a big win.
Pros of Moen
- Easy Installation: The pre-installed power cord and Universal Xpress Mount make setup a breeze. I didn’t need to call a plumber or buy extra parts.
- Sleek Design: Moen’s disposals look modern and compact, fitting neatly under my sink without hogging cabinet space.
- Removable Splash Guard: Cleaning is simple. The splash guard pops off, letting me scrub away food bits that cause odors.
- Powerful Permanent Magnet Motor: The 2700 RPM motor in the GXS75C chewed through chicken bones and potato peels like a champ. It’s fast and less prone to jams.
- Solid Warranty: My model came with a 10-year warranty, giving me peace of mind for long-term use.
- Affordable for Features: At around $150-$200, Moen offers strong value for mid-range models.
Cons of Moen
- Single-Stage Grinding: Moen’s single-stage grinding isn’t as thorough as multi-stage systems. I noticed larger food particles in the drain, which could be an issue for older plumbing.
- Noise Level: The SoundSHIELD insulation helps, but it’s not whisper-quiet. Grinding bones sounded like a low growl, which might bother light sleepers nearby.
- Fewer Models: With only about 13 models, Moen’s lineup feels limited compared to InSinkErator’s variety.
- Width Issues: The GXS75C is wider than some competitors, which made fitting it under my narrow cabinet a bit tricky.
The Moen impressed me with its speed and style. I tossed in celery stalks, carrot tops, and even a stray chicken bone, and it handled them with ease.
But when I tried grinding fibrous veggies like celery, I noticed some stringy bits lingering, which meant running the water longer to flush everything down. It’s not a dealbreaker, but it’s something to consider if your plumbing is finicky.
My Experience With InSinkErator Garbage Disposals
Next, I tested the InSinkErator Evolution Compact 3/4 HP model. InSinkErator’s reputation as the gold standard had me curious, and I wasn’t disappointed.
Installation was straightforward, though I had to buy a power cord separately, which added a small cost and hassle. The QuickLock Mount was compatible with my existing setup, so swapping it in took about 25 minutes.
Pros of InSinkErator
- MultiGrind Technology: The Evolution’s two-stage grinding system pulverized food into tiny particles. Even tough scraps like corn cobs and melon rinds were no match.
- Quiet Operation: SoundSeal technology made this unit noticeably quieter than my Moen. I could run it during a phone call without raising my voice.
- Wide Model Range: With over 20 models, InSinkErator has options for every budget and need, from the budget-friendly Badger 5 to the premium Evolution Excel.
- Durability: The stainless steel grinding components felt sturdy, and user reviews suggest these units last 10-15 years with proper care.
- Septic-Safe Options: Models like the Evolution Septic Assist include bio-cartridges to break down waste, a bonus for homes with septic systems.
- Trusted Brand: Plumbers and homeowners alike praise InSinkErator for reliability, which gave me confidence in its performance.
Cons of InSinkErator
- Installation Complexity: The lack of a pre-installed power cord meant extra steps for DIYers like me. Hardwiring is an option, but it’s not as user-friendly.
- Fixed Splash Guard: Cleaning the splash guard was a pain. I had to disconnect the unit to scrub it, which took more time than I’d like.
- Pricey High-End Models: Top-tier models like the Evolution Excel can cost over $800, which feels steep for a garbage disposal.
- Slower Motor: The 1725 RPM DuraDrive induction motor is powerful but slower than Moen’s, taking a bit longer to grind tough scraps.
The InSinkErator shone when I threw in a mix of raw fish scraps and vegetable peels. The multi-stage grinding left almost nothing behind, and the quiet hum was a pleasant surprise.
However, I did notice some rust on an older Badger model I inspected at a friend’s house, suggesting that lower-end models might not hold up as well over time.
Key Features of Moen And InSinkErator Breakdown
Let’s talk about what makes these disposals tick. Both brands offer unique features, but they cater to slightly different needs.
- Motor Type and Power
Moen uses permanent magnet motors, which spin faster (up to 2700 RPM) and start instantly, reducing the chance of jams.
I found this especially helpful when grinding tough scraps like bones, as the motor didn’t bog down.
InSinkErator’s DuraDrive induction motors, running at 1725 RPM, are slower but deliver consistent torque.
They’re better for sustained grinding of large volumes, like when I cleaned up after a big family dinner.
Horsepower options range from 1/3 HP to 1 HP for Moen and up to 1.25 HP for InSinkErator, so both cover small to large households.
- Grinding Technology
InSinkErator’s MultiGrind system (2-4 stages) is a standout. It breaks food down into finer particles, which is great for preventing clogs. My Evolution Compact left my drain nearly spotless after grinding chicken bones.
Moen’s single-stage grinding is simpler and faster but less thorough. If you have older pipes, InSinkErator’s finer grind might save you from plumbing headaches.
- Noise Reduction
Noise matters when you’re running a disposal during dinner prep. InSinkErator’s SoundSeal technology edged out Moen’s SoundSHIELD in my tests.
The Evolution Compact was quiet enough that I barely noticed it running, while the Moen GXS75C had a noticeable hum. If you value a peaceful kitchen, InSinkErator has the upper hand.
- Installation and Compatibility
Moen wins for DIYers. The pre-installed power cord and Universal Xpress Mount made my installation a snap. InSinkErator’s QuickLock Mount is just as compatible, but the optional power cord added a step.
Both brands use three-bolt mounting systems, so you can swap one for the other without replacing your sink flange.
- Warranty and Durability
Moen offers 5-10 year warranties, with higher-end models like the EXL100C boasting 10 years. InSinkErator’s warranties range from 1-12 years, but entry-level models like the Badger 5 often come with just 1-3 years.
I’d lean toward Moen for longer coverage on mid-range units, but InSinkErator’s premium models match or exceed that with proven longevity.
- Maintenance and Cleaning
Moen’s removable splash guard is a game-changer for cleaning. I could pop it off, rinse it, and have it back in seconds. InSinkErator’s fixed splash guard required disconnecting the unit, which was a hassle.
Both brands recommend regular cleaning with baking soda and vinegar to keep odors at bay.
Real-World Performance: My Kitchen Tests
To get a true sense of these disposals, I put them through real-world scenarios.
I cooked a big meal—think chicken wings, corn on the cob, and a pile of veggie scraps—and ran each unit through its paces.
The Moen GXS75C powered through the pile in under a minute, but I noticed some larger particles in the drain, requiring extra water to flush.
It handled bones well, though the noise was noticeable.
The InSinkErator Evolution Compact took about 10 seconds longer but left the drain cleaner, and the quiet operation let me chat with my spouse without shouting. For fibrous foods like corn husks, InSinkErator’s multi-stage grinding was noticeably better, reducing stringy bits that Moen left behind.
I also tested lighter loads, like coffee grounds and citrus peels, to mimic daily use. Both units performed well, but Moen’s faster motor cleared the chamber quicker. For heavy-duty tasks, InSinkErator’s torque and grinding stages gave it an edge.
If you cook a lot or host big gatherings, InSinkErator might be your go-to. For lighter use or quick cleanups, Moen’s speed is hard to beat.
Cost and Value
Price is a big factor. Moen’s disposals range from $100 to $300, making them accessible for most budgets. The GXS75C, at around $150, felt like a steal for its features.
InSinkErator’s range is broader, from $100 for the Badger 5 to over $800 for the Evolution Excel. The Evolution Compact, at $175-$200, offers premium features at a reasonable price.
For value, Moen delivers strong performance for the price, especially for DIYers who save on installation. InSinkErator’s higher-end models justify their cost with advanced grinding and quietness, but budget models like the Badger 5 can feel underpowered and prone to rust.
Which Brand Fits Your Kitchen?
Choosing between Moen and InSinkErator depends on your priorities. If you want a stylish, easy-to-install unit that handles everyday scraps with speed, Moen is a great pick. Its permanent magnet motor and long warranties make it a reliable choice for small to medium households.
If you need a heavy-duty disposal for tough scraps or a quiet kitchen, InSinkErator’s MultiGrind and SoundSeal technology are tough to beat. Its wider model range also means more options for specific needs, like septic systems.
In my kitchen, I leaned toward InSinkErator for its grinding prowess and quietness, but I appreciated Moen’s simplicity and sleek look. Your choice will hinge on how you use your disposal, your budget, and whether you prioritize ease of installation or top-tier performance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
It depends on your needs. InSinkErator is often praised for durability and quietness, while Moen offers great value and easy installation. I’d pick InSinkErator for heavy use, Moen for lighter tasks.
Yes, both use three-bolt mounting systems (Moen’s Universal Xpress and InSinkErator’s QuickLock), so you can swap them without changing your sink flange.
Plumbers often recommend InSinkErator for its reliability and multi-stage grinding but warn against putting non-food items or grease down any disposal to avoid clogs.
Recent reports highlight InSinkErator’s Evolution Compact for quietness and grinding power and Moen’s GXS75C for value and speed. Both score high for performance.
A 3/4 HP disposal is stronger and better for frequent use or tough scraps. A 1/2 HP unit works for light tasks but may struggle with bones or fibrous foods.
A garbage disposal is any device that grinds food waste under your sink. InSinkErator is a leading brand, known for its MultiGrind technology and quiet operation.
Conclusion: Making Your Choice
You’re standing at the crossroads of Moen and InSinkErator, and I’ve been there. Both brands offer solid options, but it comes down to what you value most. If you’re like me and want a disposal that’s easy to install and looks sharp, Moen’s got your back with its fast motor and user-friendly design.
If you need a workhorse that grinds everything to dust and keeps the noise down, InSinkErator’s your pick. Weigh your kitchen’s needs, budget, and DIY skills, and you’ll find the perfect fit.
Happy grinding!