If you’re in the market for new windows, two big names you’ll likely encounter are JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific. Both companies make a wide range of high-quality windows for residential and commercial use.
But which is the better choice for your home?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific windows side-by-side, looking at key factors like materials, designs, energy efficiency, warranties, and cost. Read on for an in-depth analysis of the pros and cons of each brand.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | JELD-WEN | Sierra Pacific |
| Materials | Vinyl, wood, aluminum-clad, fiberglass | Vinyl, aluminum, wood, aluminum-clad |
| Styles | Double hung, sliding, casement, custom | Double hung, casement, custom |
| Energy Efficiency | Many ENERGY STAR options | Leading efficiency innovations |
| Warranties | Lifetime limited | Lifetime limited |
| Noise Reduction | Laminated, acoustical glass | Advanced noise dampening tech |
| Security | Impact resistant, laminated glass | Commercial grade hardware |
| Screens | Fiberglass, retractable | Aluminum, hidden pocket |
Overview of JELD-WEN
Founded in 1960, JELD-WEN is one of the world’s largest manufacturers of windows and doors.
The company offers a full line of vinyl, wood, aluminum-clad wood, and fiberglass windows under various brand names including JELD-WEN, AuraLast, and Weather Shield.
Some key things to know about JELD-WEN windows:
- Headquartered in Oregon and operates over 120 manufacturing facilities globally
- Offers a wide array of window types including casement, double-hung, sliding, awning, bay/bow, garden, etc.
- vinyl and fiberglass lines feature proprietary composite materials for strength and energy efficiency
- Majority of products qualify for ENERGY STAR certification
- Provide limited lifetime warranties on most vinyl and wood window models
Overview of Sierra Pacific Windows
Sierra Pacific got its start in a small California lumber mill in 1949. Now based in Red Bluff, CA, the company has grown into one of the largest U.S. manufacturers of custom and stock windows and doors.
Here are some core facts about Sierra Pacific:
- Produces vinyl, aluminum, wood, and aluminum-clad wood windows and patio doors
- Custom capabilities include unique shapes, sizes, materials, finishes, hardware, and energy packages
- Offers triple glazing and other high performance glass options
- Specializes in architectural and heavy commercial projects
- Known for exceptional quality, durability, and energy efficiency
- Backed by a limited lifetime warranty on vinyl products
Key Differences Between JELD-WEN And Sierra Pacific Windows
Now that we’ve introduced the two brands, let’s delve into a detailed comparison of how their window products stack up.
Window Materials
One of the biggest differences between JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific is the range of materials they offer.
JELD-WEN windows come in:
- Vinyl – Composite vinyl/polyvinyl chloride (PVC) with fiberglass reinforcement. Durable, energy efficient, low maintenance.
- Wood – Primarily pine, available in natural or factory painted finishes. Warm aesthetic.
- Aluminum-clad wood – Exterior aluminum protects wood interior. Combines benefits of both materials.
- Fiberglass – JELD-WEN’s proprietary fiberglass blended with polymer resins. Increased strength and thermal performance.
Sierra Pacific offers:
- Vinyl – Heavy-duty, multi-chambered vinyl frames promote thermal efficiency.
- Aluminum – Lightweight yet very durable, ideal for coastal climates. Minimal maintenance.
- Wood – Custom crafted from pine, alder or other quality woods. Stain or paint to match decor.
- Aluminum-clad wood – Exterior aluminum paired with pine, alder or mahogany interior.
Both brands offer excellent choices. Vinyl and fiberglass are generally the most energy efficient and low maintenance options, while real wood brings unique visual appeal. Aluminum-clad wood provides the benefits of both materials in one.
Window Designs and Styles
JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific both manufacture windows in a wide array of standard and custom designs.
Some of the most popular JELD-WEN styles include:
- Double hung
- Sliding
- Casement
- Awning
- Glider
- Bay and bow
- Garden windows
- Glass block windows
- Round top windows
- Custom shapes
Sierra Pacific is especially known for its custom capabilities, but also offers these common designs:
- Double and single hung
- Sliding
- Swinging and hinged casement
- Fixed picture windows
- Radius/arched windows
- Bays and bows
- Glass block windows
- Specialty shapes like triangles, trapezoids, parallelograms, etc.
Both brands can accommodate architectural styles like Craftsman, cottage, Tudor, colonial, and more. Unique grid patterns, hardware finishes, glass types and window shapes further allow you to match your home’s aesthetic.
Overall, Sierra Pacific takes the lead when it comes to truly one-of-a-kind custom shapes and sizes. But JELD-WEN also provides style flexibility through its collection of window series within each material line.
Energy Efficiency
Energy efficiency is a major factor for today’s homeowners and a key area where newer window technology shines.
JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific both offer high performance windows with upgraded glazing, gas fills, weatherstripping, and other energy saving features.
Many JELD-WEN windows meet ENERGY STAR requirements. Specific technologies include:
- High performance Low-E glass coatings to reduce heat loss/gain
- Argon or krypton gas filled gap between panes for improved insulation
- Warm Edge SpacerTM technology for less glass edge heat transfer
- Vinyl and fiberglass frames enhance thermal performance
- Weather stripping for air tight seal
Sierra Pacific energy efficiency options include:
- Multi-layered Low-E glass with optimum solar control
- Krypton or argon gas filled double and triple glazing
- Thermal breaks in aluminum frames
- High-density foam filled frames
- Triple-fin weather stripping
- Structural enhancements like composite reinforcement
Both brands clearly offer excellent energy savings compared to old single pane windows.
Depending on the specific products compared, Sierra Pacific edges ahead slightly with its triple glazing capabilities.
Installation and Maintenance
Low maintenance windows are important for keeping your home looking its best over time.
JELD-WEN’s most low-maintenance options include:
- Vinyl – Won’t rot, warp, or require painting. Easy to clean.
- Fiberglass – Superior strength resists warping. Paint not needed.
- Wood – Requires refinishing every 2-3 years to protect the surface.
- Aluminum-clad wood – Exterior aluminum eliminates the need to paint or stain the exposed portions.
Sierra Pacific windows offer these conveniences:
- Vinyl – Durability and color retention minimizes maintenance needs.
- Aluminum – Extremely resistant to weather and corrosion. Simple cleaning.
- Wood – Interior wood requires regular staining, sealing, and painting. Exteriors protected.
- Aluminum-clad wood – Low maintenance aluminum exteriors. Uncovered wood portions require normal upkeep.
As for installation, both JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific windows can be installed as replacement units or into new construction. Sierra Pacific offers factory trained installers, while JELD-WEN partners with local contractors.
Follow all manufacturer instructions for proper installation in your climate and home type. Ongoing maintenance like lubricating moving parts will extend window performance.
Weatherproofing and Durability
To shield your home from the elements, windows have to stand up to Mother Nature’s worst. Quality and durability differ between budget models and premium brands.
Here’s how JELD-WEN ensures weatherproofing and longevity:
- Multi-point locking hardware creates tight seal
- Weatherstripping prevents air and water infiltration
- Composite materials prevent rotting, swelling, warping
- Stainless steel hardware withstands corrosion
- Meets or exceeds industry standards for water testing
- Vinyl and wood products back by limited lifetime warranties
Sierra Pacific weatherproofs and toughens windows through:
- Multi-layer weatherstripping and compression bulb seals
- Stainless steel hardware rated for coastal use
- Rigorously tested to pass water infiltration requirements
- Structural enhancements like composite reinforcement
- Interior wood protected by exterior cladding
- Lifetime limited warranties on vinyl and alu minum-clad wood
Both brands follow meticulous manufacturing processes with quality control testing. Overall construction quality, materials used, and design innovations allow JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific windows to achieve excellent durability and weather resistance. Backed by reassuring warranties, either is a smart long-term investment.
Noise Reduction
If you live on a noisy street or under an airport flight path, noise pollution can be aggravating. Upgraded windows can significantly dampen outside noise.
JELD-WEN offers these noise reducing upgrades:
- Laminated or acoustical glass panes
- Panes staggered for improved soundproofing
- Tight weatherstripping seals out sound infiltration
- Solid wood, vinyl, and fiberglass naturally dampen noise
For even quieter interiors, Sierra Pacific windows include:
- Extra thick glazing muted outside noise
- Laminated glass construction with sound dampening interlayers
- Elastomeric vinyl compression seals stop air leaks
- Bulb seal weatherstripping rated for high noise reduction
- Improved structure through composite reinforcement
If soundproofing is a concern, consult the STC (Sound Transmission Class) ratings for each brand’s window styles. The higher the STC class, the more noise reduction you’ll experience. Both companies make windows specifically designed to minimize urban noise disruptions.
Security Features
Along with weatherproofing, break-in resistance gives homeowners important peace of mind.
To keep your home and family secure, JELD-WEN offers:
- Impact resistant window options
- Laminated glass for strength against blunt force
- Security sensors compatible with many home systems
- Locking hardware secures windows tight
- Systems to guard against forced entry
Sierra Pacific security features include:
- Extra strong laminated, tempered safety glass
- Commercial grade security hardware
- Advanced locking mechanisms
- Roll down security shades
- Integration with home security systems
- Visible deterrents like warning labels
Premium window styles from both brands can meet strict forced entry codes for protection. There are lots of ways to enhance security through innovative window features.
Glass Options
The type of glass used impacts everything from durability and energy savings to clarity and UV protection.
JELD-WEN glass choices include:
- Low-E coated glass – Improved insulation and solar control
- Laminated glass – Shatter and sound resistant
- Obscured glass – For light while preserving privacy
- Tinted glass – Reduce glare and heat gain
- Tempered glass – Increased strength for safety
Sierra Pacific takes glazing up a notch with:
- Standard double glazing – Two panes enhance insulation
- Optional triple glazing – Ultimate energy efficiency
- Unlimited custom glass capabilities – Built to your specs
- Specialty glass like fritted, spandrel, wired, etc.
- Blast resistance, security, soundproofing glass
- High visibility Low-E and other coatings
Both offer extensive options, but Sierra Pacific pulls ahead with triple glazing and completely custom glass construction. Though this does come at an added cost over standard double pane glass.
Screen Options
Movable screens allow natural airflow while keeping pests outside.
JELD-WEN offers fiberglass mesh screens optional on most windows. Features include:
- Better visibility over aluminum mesh
- Available in multiple colors
- ScreenAwayTM retractable screens disappear when not needed
Sierra Pacific screen options include:
- Heavy duty aluminum mesh screens
- Easy to remove without tools
- Available in charcoal, black, grey, or bronze
- Hidden pocket screens for a clear view
For high visibility screening and an unobstructed outdoor view when desired, JELD-WEN’s ScreenAway retractable screens are a unique advantage. Both brands offer secure screens that integrate seamlessly into window frames.
Warranties and Certifications
When investing in new windows, you want reassurance that they’ll perform as promised. Both JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific back their windows with industry-leading warranties.
Here’s the warranty coverage offered by JELD-WEN:
- Lifetime limited – On vinyl, wood, and clad wood windows and patio doors
- 20 year – Insulated glass units
- 10 year – Blinds/shades
- Most components covered against manufacturing defects
Sierra Pacific warranties include:
- Lifetime limited – On vinyl and clad wood windows and doors
- 10 year – Insulated glass units
- 10 year – Aluminum frame finish
- Transferable warranties for second homeowners
- Optional extended service plans available
Many JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific products also meet ENERGY STAR requirements for proven energy efficiency.
Both brands comply with important certifications and codes for water infiltration, air leakage, and durability.
For crafted windows you can count on for the long run, the warranties from either manufacturer give peace of mind. Compare policies before purchasing to fully understand coverage.
Costs and Budget
Let’s talk numbers. JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific windows range from affordable to premium:
JELD-WEN MSRP pricing:
- Vinyl windows – $200 – $700
- Wood windows – $400 – $1,200
- Clad wood windows – $600 – $1,400
- Fiberglass windows – $550 – $900
Sierra Pacific typical costs:
- Vinyl windows – $250 – $850
- Aluminum windows- $475 – $1,100
- Wood windows- $650 – $2,500
- Clad wood windows – $850 – $1,800
As you’d expect, vinyl and fiberglass are the most budget friendly options from JELD-WEN. Wood windows carry the highest price tag.
Sierra Pacific vinyl windows are cost competitive, but their specialty wood and commercial-grade aluminum products hit premium price points.
Both brands offer sales, seasonal discounts, and contractor pricing which can reduce costs. Exact window prices depend on sizes, customization, special features, and geographic region.
JELD-WEN Or Sierra Pacific: Which Is Better For You?
Now that we’ve examined the ins and outs of each brand, let’s summarize how they compare:
JELD-WEN Pros:
- Broader style and material selection including proprietary fiberglass
- Industry leading innovations like ScreenAway retractable screens
- Competitive pricing across most product lines
- Meets ENERGY STAR specs for proven efficiency
- Wide range of specialty shapes and custom designs
Sierra Pacific Pros:
- Heavy duty construction quality and durability
- Advanced glazing like triple pane glass
- Unmatched custom capabilities for sizes and shapes
- Exceptional noise reduction and weatherproofing
- Lifetime warranties with transferable coverage
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Sierra Pacific windows range from about $250 – $2,500 depending on the material and style. Vinyl models cost $250-$850. Aluminum windows run $475-$1,100. Wood windows are $650-$2,500. Aluminum-clad wood combinations fall between $850-$1,800. Unique custom designs can reach even higher price points.
Sierra Pacific Windows is part of the Sierra Pacific Industries company, one of the largest millwork operations in the U.S. They manufacture all their own windows and doors at facilities in California, Washington, Wisconsin and Pennsylvania.
For custom Sierra Pacific windows, lead times range from 3-10 weeks depending on the specifications. Stock size vinyl windows ship within 1-2 weeks. Reach out to a Sierra Pacific representative for accurate lead times on your order.
The JELD-WEN V2500 and V4500 refer to two models within their vinyl window product line:
V2500 – JELD-WEN’s mid-range vinyl window offering basic features at an affordable price point.
V4500 – JELD-WEN’s premium vinyl window with upgraded glass packages, hardware, screens, and other high-end features. Triple-pane glass and other energy efficiency upgrades available.
The V4500 costs more upfront but delivers better performance and lower heating/cooling bills over the long run. Compare the two models side-by-side to decide which best fits your home and budget.
Closing Remarks
For most homeowners, JELD-WEN is an excellent choice that combines quality, energy savings, and durability at very reasonable prices. Their huge selection of window styles, materials, and custom options give you ample choices.
Sierra Pacific wins on ultra-premium designs, commercial-grade construction, and completely custom capabilities. They are leaders in soundproofing and weatherproofing. Sierra Pacific is ideal for high end architectural projects, historic reproductions, and replacing old drafty windows with maximum energy efficiency.
Whichever brand you select, inspect windows carefully before installation and perform regular maintenance. With proper installation and care, JELD-WEN and Sierra Pacific windows will enhance your home for decades to come.