If you’re in the market for new windows, two big names you’ll likely encounter are Heartland and Pella. Both companies make high-quality windows with excellent energy efficiency, durability and aesthetics. But which brand is better for your home and budget?
In this comprehensive guide, we’ll compare Heartland and Pella windows to help you decide which is the right choice for your replacement or new construction project.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Feature | Heartland Windows | Pella Windows |
| Cost | $300 – $550 per window (lower cost) | $700 – $1,200 per window (premium cost) |
| Efficiency | Very good, especially with triple pane glass | Slightly higher, fiberglass can be more efficient |
| Styles | Limited to casement and single-hung | Many operating styles like double-hung and sliders |
| Soundproofing | Moderate noise reduction | Superior sound dampening technology |
| Exterior Color Options | Wide variety with SuperCapSR | Mostly white or brown |
| Durability | Lifetime warranty, durable glass and vinyl | Equally durable with multi-decade warranties |
| Availability | Primarily Midwest | Nationwide |
| Best For | Budget-friendly efficiency | Max soundproofing and features |
Heartland Windows Overview
Founded in 1946, Heartland Windows and Doors manufactures vinyl windows and patio doors. The company is based in Iowa and its products are made in the USA.
Heartland Pros
- Value priced – Heartland windows are very competitively priced, making them budget-friendly.
- High energy efficiency – Heartland’s EdgeForce nailing fin frame and premium vinyl deliver excellent insulation. Their triple pane glass options are some of the most energy efficient on the market.
- Customization – Heartland uses SuperCapSR exterior cladding to offer a wide range of colors and finishes. They also have unlimited custom grid patterns.
- Good warranties – Heartland windows have a limited lifetime warranty and 20 year glass breakage warranty.
Heartland Cons
- Limited operating styles – Casement and single-hung are the only operable window types Heartland offers. No double hungs or sliders.
- Minimal soundproofing – These vinyl windows are average at reducing outside noise. Some competing brands rate significantly better.
- Limited presence – With factories only in the Midwest, Heartland doesn’t have nationwide availability. Lead times may be longer.
Pella Windows Overview
Founded in 1925, Pella is one of the most recognized and preferred window brands on a national scale. They offer a wide range of high-end wood, vinyl and fiberglass windows and doors.
Pella Pros
- Exceptional quality – Pella products are very well-built and go through rigorous testing. They meet the highest industry grades for air and water infiltration.
- Leading designs – Pella makes almost every window operating style imaginable, along with innovative options like between-the-glass blinds.
- Superior soundproofing – Pella Acoustic windows have some of the best sound dampening technology available. Great for noisy areas.
- Brand prestige – Homeowners often see big added value in the Pella name. Their windows can directly impact resale.
Pella Cons
- Very expensive – Pella windows come at a premium cost, sometimes 2-3x cheaper vinyl alternatives. They are an investment.
- Heavy panes – Large Pella panes, especially wood models, can make windows more difficult to operate and maintain.
- Limited exterior color options – Most Pella windows come in white or brown only. You’ll pay extra for custom colors.
Key Differences Between Heartland And Pella Windows
Now that we’ve reviewed both brands separately, let’s directly compare them on a few key factors:
- Cost
This is where you’ll find the starkest contrast. Pella windows are priced at the highest end of the market, regularly running $700 – $1,200 per window. Heartland offers one of the most affordable quality windows, often in the $300 – $550 per window range.
- Efficiency
Both Heartland and Pella make very efficient windows. Pella fiberglass models rate slightly better for overall insulation, but Heartland vinyl widows with triple pane glass are not far behind. Any modern window from either brand will improve energy conservation over old windows.
- Aesthetics
With unlimited grid patterns and rich exterior colors via SuperCapSR, Heartland allows for much more customization of your window’s looks. Pella offers classic good looks but less variety.
- Sound Reduction
Pella Acoustic windows are engineered to dampen sound better than most vinyl competitors. This makes them ideal for noisy urban areas. Heartland vinyl windows offer moderate noise blocking that trails leading brands.
- Durability
You can expect equal longevity out of Heartland and Pella windows. Both are constructed of quality materials that stand up to weathering and wear-and-tear over decades. Their warranties back up decades of reliable performance.
- Availability
Pella has a nationwide presence with multiple factories and distribution centers across the country. This gives them an advantage in product availability and lead times. Heartland mainly services the Midwest region with its Iowa headquarters.
Best Windows For Minnesota Homes
When it comes to choosing the best new windows for Minnesota homes, both Heartland and Pella products are great options that can handle the state’s cold winters and swing seasons.
Here are a few tips for picking the ideal windows for Minnesota’s climate:
- Look for whole window U-Factors around 0.27 or lower to limit heat conduction. The glass is most important.
- Consider triple pane glass for optimal insulation against temperature extremes.
- Ensure the frame has at least double weatherstripping to reduce air leaks.
- Pick windows with durable exteriors that can withstand hail, heavy winds and snow loads.
- Choose high visible light transmittance for maximum solar heat gain during frigid months.
- Opt for low-maintenance vinyl or fiberglass frames instead of wood that can rot over time.
Both Pella and Heartland check these boxes for Minnesota-approved windows. Just decide whether Pella’s premium features are worth the added costs over Heartland’s affordability and customization.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Pella windows are widely regarded as some of the highest quality residential windows available. They meet the highest ratings for air and water infiltration, and are put through rigorous testing. The materials and construction are first-rate.
Pella windows carry premium price tags due to their top-tier materials, high-end brands and industry-leading innovations. For example, their patented between-the-glass Cordless Blind option adds cost. But you get what you pay for – Pella windows can enhance home value.
Beyond the quality craftsmanship, Pella windows feature leading designs like their disappearing screens and soundproofing technology. Homeowners also appreciate the aesthetic appeal and durability over many decades. And their high-end reputation matches the prestige of luxury homes.
The ideal windows for Minnesota’s cold winters feature triple pane glass, U-Factors under 0.27, durable exteriors that can handle snow loads, and ample weatherstripping. Both Pella and Heartland make windows that meet these requirements for energy efficiency and durability.
The Verdict
For most homeowners, the budget-friendly yet highly customizable Heartland will make the most sense for seamless Minnesota window replacements or new builds. Their vinyl windows provide an ideal balance of value, insulation, quality and appearance options.
However, if you want the absolute best soundproofing, innovative features and prestige, then Pella’s luxury cache may justify the upcharge. You can’t go wrong with either brand, but for a sound investment, Heartland is our top recommendation.