Regarding choosing the proper underlayment for your flooring, two popular options are Floor Muffler and QuietWalk. However, Floor Muffler has a better sound reduction feature than Quiet Walk.
If you are planning to give your floor a new look, then Floor Muffler and Quiet Walk will definitely entice you. Both brands offer some exceptional products that will enhance the strength of your floors.
Here is a quick comparison chart highlighting the key specifications of Floor Muffler and Quiet Walk.
Quick Comparison Table
| Specifications | Floor Muffler | Quiet Walk |
| Sound Reduction | Best Sound Reduction | Average |
| Airflow | Goof Airflow Features | Poor Airflow Features |
| Durability | High Durability | Low Durability |
| Price | Expensive | Affordable |
Key Differences Between Floor Muffler And Quiet Walk
The above comparison table gave you a brief idea about the specifications of Floor Muffler and Quiet Walk. It’s time to identify the key features of the two products.
- Sound Reduction
Both Floor Muffler and QuietWalk are designed to reduce sound transmission between floors.
Floor Muffler is made from high-density foam with an acoustic barrier layer to help absorb impact noise.
It is advertised to have an excellent sound rating of IIC 74 and STC 73.
QuietWalk is made from a blend of recycled fibers and has a built-in moisture barrier.
It is also advertised to have a sound rating of IIC 71 and STC 66, slightly lower than Floor Muffler.
- Composition
Floor Muffler is made from high-density foam specifically designed for noise reduction. It has an acoustic barrier layer that helps absorb sound and reduce impact noise.
In contrast, QuietWalk is made from recycled fibers that are less dense than foam. These fibers provide some noise reduction but less foam.
- Airflow
Another critical factor to consider when choosing an underlayment is airflow. If an underlayment restricts airflow, it can trap moisture and lead to problems like mold and mildew.
Floor Muffler has a unique design allowing airflow between the underlayment and the subfloor. This airflow helps prevent moisture buildup and keeps the underlayment dry.
QuietWalk also has a breathable design, but it may allow less airflow than Floor Muffler.
- Thickness
The thickness of underlayment can play a significant role in the comfort level and noise reduction it provides.
Floor Muffler is available in thicknesses of 2mm, 2.5mm, and 3mm, while QuietWalk is only available in a 3mm thickness.
- Density
The underlayment’s density can significantly impact its ability to reduce noise and provide a comfortable walking surface.
Floor Muffler is a high-density foam with 10 pounds per cubic foot density. This density helps it absorb impact noise and provide a more stable surface for flooring.
QuietWalk, on the other hand, has a lower density of 5.6 pounds per cubic foot. This lower density can make it less effective at reducing noise and providing a stable surface.
- Durability
Floor Muffler is made from high-density foam, which makes it more durable than many other types of underlayment. It can withstand heavy foot traffic and resist compression over time.
QuietWalk is made from recycled fibers, which can be less durable than foam. It may be more prone to compression and wear over time.
- Installation
Both Floor Muffler and QuietWalk are easy to install. They can be laid down directly on the subfloor, and most types of flooring can be installed on top of them.
However, Floor Muffler has a self-sealing lip and tape system that makes it easy to install and helps prevent moisture from seeping through the seams.
QuietWalk also has a built-in moisture barrier, but it may not seal as tightly as Floor Muffler.
- Suitability for Different Types of Flooring
Floor Muffler and QuietWalk are suitable for various flooring types, including laminate, hardwood, and engineered wood.
However, Floor Muffler is also recommended for tile and stone flooring, which can be more challenging to install.
This is because tile and stone require a more stable and level surface, and Floor Muffler’s high density can provide this stability.
- Moisture Protection
Moisture protection is an important consideration when choosing an underlayment.
Both Floor Muffler and QuietWalk have moisture barriers built-in. Floor Muffler has a 100% waterproof layer, while QuietWalk has a moisture barrier that protects against minor spills and infiltration.
- Certifications
Floor Muffler and QuietWalk have received various certifications for their performance and safety.
Floor Muffler has been certified by the Carpet and Rug Institute for its ability to reduce VOC emissions.
It has also been certified by the International Code Council for its sound reduction and fire safety.
QuietWalk has also been certified by the Carpet and Rug Institute for low VOC emissions and by the Underwriters Laboratories for its fire safety.
- Price
The price of underlayment can vary widely depending on the thickness, brand, and quality. In general, Floor Muffler is more expensive than QuietWalk.
Floor Muffler’s higher price point is due to its superior sound reduction and durability.
Which One Is Better?
Floor Muffler dominates the maximum segments of this discussion and proves to be the best option against Quiet Walk.
The combination of premium materials, exceptional sound reduction features, and long-lasting service make Floor Muffler unique.
Moreover, Floor Muffler has special moisture protection and airflow process that maintains the stability of your floors.
Price is the only drawback of Floor Muffler underlayment. However, the top-notch materials and construction justify the high price range of Floor Muffler.
Overall, Floor Muffler ticks all the boxes of being the best underlayment for your flooring.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Floor Muffler combines quality products and highly durable service to give you the best flooring underlayment experience.
At an affordable price range, Quiet Walk provides good underlayment for your flooring that is highly durable.
Floor Muffler has proved to be the best underlayment for hardwood flooring.
Yes, Floor Muffler has renowned for its long-lasting service and robust underlayment features.
Conclusion
Clearly, Floor Muffler is the winner in this comparison.
Floor Muffler combines quality products and highly durable service to give you the best flooring underlayment experience.