Farrell-Calhoun Paint Vs. Sherwin-Williams: A Painter’s Perspective

I’ve painted my fair share of walls, from cozy living rooms to sprawling exteriors, and choosing the right paint brand always feels like a big decision. After years of experimenting, I’ve narrowed my focus to two heavyweights: Farrell-Calhoun and Sherwin-Williams.

Both have their fans, but which one truly delivers for your project?

In this article, I’ll share my hands-on experience with both brands, breaking down their strengths, weaknesses, and key features in a conversational yet analytical way. My goal is to help you pick the perfect paint for your next project, whether you’re a DIYer or a pro.

A Brief Comparison Table

My Journey With Paint Brands

Painting is personal. It’s not just about slapping color on a wall; it’s about transforming a space to reflect who you are. Over the years, I’ve learned that the paint you choose can make or break the experience.

I first stumbled across Farrell-Calhoun when I moved to the Southeast, where it’s a regional favorite. Sherwin-Williams, on the other hand, has been a constant in my painting adventures, from small apartments to large commercial jobs.

Both brands have earned their stripes, but they cater to different needs, budgets, and vibes. Let’s break it down.

Farrell-Calhoun: The Underdog with Heart

Farrell-Calhoun isn’t a household name like Sherwin-Williams, but it’s got a loyal following, especially in the Southeast and Midwest.

Founded in 1905 in Memphis, Tennessee, this family-owned company has been churning out paint for over a century.

I first tried their Ultra Supreme Interior Paint when I was redoing my living room, and I was blown away by how well it covered my old, dark navy walls in just one coat.

Key Features of Farrell-Calhoun

• Zero VOC Formulas: Their paints, like the Ultra Supreme line, are environmentally friendly, with no harsh odors. I painted my daughter’s nursery with their Pro PVA Drywall Primer and didn’t worry about fumes.
• Superior Coverage: The high solid content means fewer coats. I’ve saved hours on projects because of this.
• Durable Finishes: Their Enamalex Acrylic/Polyurethane Bonding Enamel is a beast for high-traffic areas. I used it on my kitchen cabinets, and they still look pristine after two years of spills and splashes.
• Affordable Pricing: At $30–$45 per gallon, it’s a steal compared to premium brands. I saved nearly $200 on a recent exterior project by choosing their Decra-Tec Acrylic Exterior Paint.
• Custom Color Matching: They can match almost any color. I brought in a fabric swatch from my couch, and they nailed the shade for my dining room.

Pros of Farrell-Calhoun

• Cost-Effective: You get high-quality paint without draining your wallet. For budget-conscious DIYers like me, this is a game-changer.
• Excellent Coverage: One coat often does the trick, even on tricky surfaces. I painted over a bold red accent wall with their Ultra Supreme, and no primer was needed.
• Personalized Service: Their stores feel like stepping into a family business. The staff at my local Farrell-Calhoun in Memphis spent 20 minutes helping me pick the perfect sheen.
• Regional Expertise: Formulated for Southern climates, their paints resist mildew and humidity better than some national brands I’ve tried.
• Versatile Product Line: From industrial coatings to interior eggshells, they’ve got something for every project. Their Enamalex is a go-to for metal surfaces.

Cons of Farrell-Calhoun

• Limited Availability: If you’re not in the Southeast or Midwest, good luck finding a store. I had to order online for a project when I moved to the Northeast, and shipping added up.
• Thicker Consistency: Some of their exterior paints, like Decra-Tec, need thorough stirring and can feel heavy on the brush. I struggled with streaks until I got the hang of it.
• Less Brand Recognition: It’s not as flashy as Sherwin-Williams, so some clients question its quality. I’ve had to convince a few that it’s not a “cheap” brand.
• Fewer Specialty Options: They don’t offer the high-tech hybrids or pre-cat epoxies that Sherwin-Williams does. For niche projects, I’ve had to look elsewhere.

Sherwin-Williams: The Industry Titan

Sherwin-Williams is the rock star of the paint world.

With stores across the country and a reputation for premium quality, it’s the go-to for many contractors and homeowners.

I’ve used their Emerald Designer Edition for countless projects, and the results are always stunning.

Their paints feel like they’re made for pros, but even as a DIYer, I’ve found them approachable.

Key Features of Sherwin-Williams

• Extensive Color Palette: Their Sher-Color system is a game-changer. I once matched a sunset-inspired hue for a client’s bedroom in minutes.
• Premium Durability: Their Emerald line is tough as nails. I painted my home’s exterior with it, and it’s held up through three brutal winters without fading.
• Low-VOC Options: Like Farrell-Calhoun, they prioritize eco-friendliness. Their Harmony line is perfect for sensitive spaces like my home office.
• Advanced Technology: From self-priming paints to stain-blocking formulas, Sherwin-Williams invests heavily in innovation. Their Premium Ceiling Paint made my popcorn ceiling look flawless.
• Nationwide Availability: No matter where you are, there’s a Sherwin-Williams store nearby. I’ve never had to worry about sourcing their products.

Pros of Sherwin-Williams

• Unmatched Durability: Their exterior paints, like SuperPaint, outlast most competitors. My fence still looks vibrant after five years.
• Consistent Quality: Every can feels reliable. I’ve never had a bad batch, which can’t be said for some budget brands I’ve tried.
• Professional Support: Their staff are paint nerds in the best way. They’ve walked me through complex projects, like refinishing a metal railing, with expert advice.
• Wide Range of Finishes: From matte to high-gloss, they’ve got it all. I used their Cashmere line for a silky-smooth bedroom finish that still gets compliments.
• Frequent Sales: Their 30–40% off sales bring prices down significantly. I snagged Emerald paint for $50 a gallon during a promotion.

Cons of Sherwin-Williams

• Higher Cost: At $50–$80 per gallon, it’s a splurge. I’ve winced at the price tag for larger projects, even with discounts.
• Inconsistent Store Experiences: While most stores are great, I’ve hit a few where the service felt rushed or impersonal.
• Two Coats Often Needed: For bold colors, I’ve had to double up on coats, which eats into time and budget.
• Overwhelming Options: With so many lines—Emerald, Duration, SuperPaint—it’s easy to get decision fatigue. I spent an hour debating shades once.

Head-to-Head Comparison of Farrell-Calhoun Paint And Sherwin-Williams

Let’s get into the meat of it: how do these brands compare when you’re standing in the store, paint roller in hand? I’ve broken it down by key factors that matter to me as a painter.

• Price and Value

Farrell-Calhoun is the clear winner for budget-conscious folks.

Their paints cost $30–$45 per gallon, and the quality rivals brands twice the price.

I painted my entire 1,500-square-foot home with their Ultra Supreme for under $200.

Sherwin-Williams, on the other hand, can hit $80 for premium lines like Emerald. Even with sales, it’s pricier.

But here’s the kicker: Sherwin-Williams’ durability often means fewer touch-ups, so the long-term value can justify the cost.

For a small project, I’d go Farrell-Calhoun. For a high-stakes exterior job, Sherwin-Williams might be worth the investment.

• Coverage and Application

Farrell-Calhoun’s high solid content makes it a coverage champ. I painted over a dark green wall with their eggshell latex, and one coat was enough.

Sherwin-Williams paints, like Emerald, flow beautifully off the brush but sometimes need two coats for full opacity, especially with vibrant hues.

Both brands are spatter-resistant, but I’ve found Sherwin-Williams’ self-priming options, like their ceiling paint, save prep time. Farrell-Calhoun’s thicker formulas can be tricky on exterior surfaces, requiring more elbow grease to avoid streaks.

• Durability

Both brands are durable, but Sherwin-Williams edges out slightly for exteriors. Their SuperPaint has kept my deck looking fresh through rain, sun, and snow. Farrell-Calhoun’s Decra-Tec is no slouch, though—it’s UV- and mildew-resistant, perfect for humid Southern climates.

For interiors, I’d call it a tie. My Farrell-Calhoun-painted kitchen cabinets and Sherwin-Williams-painted bedroom walls both handle wear and tear like champs.

• Color Selection and Matching

Sherwin-Williams’ Sher-Color system is a dream for color enthusiasts. I once brought in a seashell from a beach trip, and they matched it perfectly. Farrell-Calhoun’s color range is impressive for a regional brand, and their custom matching is spot-on.

However, Sherwin-Williams’ nationwide presence means you’re more likely to find exotic shades or trendy palettes. If you’re after a unique color, Sherwin-Williams has the edge; for straightforward projects, Farrell-Calhoun delivers.

• Eco-Friendliness

Both brands prioritize low- or zero-VOC formulas, which I appreciate as someone with kids and pets.

Farrell-Calhoun’s Ultra Supreme and Sherwin-Williams’ Harmony lines are virtually odorless, making them ideal for indoor projects.

I painted my home office with Harmony and worked in there the same day without a headache.

Farrell-Calhoun’s focus on eco-friendly paints feels more boutique, but Sherwin-Williams’ scale means they’ve got more low-VOC options across their lines.

• Availability and Customer Service

Farrell-Calhoun’s regional footprint is a double-edged sword. Their stores offer warm, personalized service—I’ve had staff mix samples on the spot and even visit my project site to troubleshoot.

But if you’re outside their region, you’re stuck ordering online. Sherwin-Williams’ nationwide network is a lifesaver for accessibility, and their staff are usually knowledgeable, though I’ve had hit-or-miss experiences at busier locations.

For small-town charm, Farrell-Calhoun wins; for convenience, Sherwin-Williams takes it.

Real-World Scenarios: Which Paint For Your Project?

Let’s talk practical. Here’s how I’d choose based on common painting scenarios.

• Interior Walls: For living rooms or bedrooms, Farrell-Calhoun’s Ultra Supreme is my pick for its one-coat coverage and zero-VOC formula. If you’re going for a bold color, Sherwin-Williams’ Emerald Designer Edition ensures a flawless finish, though you might need two coats.
• Ceilings: Sherwin-Williams’ Premium Ceiling Paint is spatter-resistant and brightens rooms beautifully. Farrell-Calhoun’s Pro PVA Drywall Primer is great for new drywall but has a stronger odor during application.
• Exterior Surfaces: Sherwin-Williams’ SuperPaint is my go-to for durability in harsh weather. Farrell-Calhoun’s Decra-Tec is a solid, budget-friendly alternative for fences or siding in humid climates.
• High-Traffic Areas: Farrell-Calhoun’s Enamalex is perfect for cabinets or trim that take a beating. Sherwin-Williams’ ProClassic line is equally tough but pricier.
• Budget Projects: Farrell-Calhoun’s everyday low prices make it ideal for large jobs. Sherwin-Williams’ sales can close the gap, but you’ll need to time your purchase.

My Personal Take: A Tale of Two Projects

To give you a real-world perspective, let me share two projects that highlight these brands’ strengths.

Last year, I repainted my home’s exterior with Farrell-Calhoun’s Decra-Tec.

The price was unbeatable, and the mildew resistance was perfect for my humid Tennessee summers.

The paint went on thick, which took some getting used to, but the finish has held up beautifully.

On another project, I used Sherwin-Williams’ Emerald for a client’s dining room.

The color depth was unreal, and the client raved about the luxurious feel.

But the cost? Ouch. I had to budget carefully to stay in the black.

Tips For Choosing Between Farrell-Calhoun and Sherwin-Williams

• Test Samples: Both brands offer samples. I always paint a small patch first to see how the color looks in my lighting.
• Consider Your Climate: If you’re in a humid area, Farrell-Calhoun’s regional formulas are tailored for you. In extreme weather, Sherwin-Williams’ durability shines.
• Factor in Labor: Farrell-Calhoun’s one-coat coverage saves time, which is huge for DIYers. Sherwin-Williams’ self-priming options can also cut prep time.
• Ask for Advice: Farrell-Calhoun’s staff are hands-on, while Sherwin-Williams’ pros can guide you through complex projects. Don’t be shy—ask questions!
• Check for Sales: Sherwin-Williams’ discounts can make their paints more affordable. Farrell-Calhoun’s steady pricing is predictable but less flexible.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: Your Paint, Your Choice

Choosing between Farrell-Calhoun and Sherwin-Williams comes down to your priorities. If you’re after affordability, excellent coverage, and a family-owned vibe, Farrell-Calhoun is your best bet. It’s served me well on budget-conscious projects without sacrificing quality.

If you want unmatched durability, a massive color selection, and nationwide convenience, Sherwin-Williams is worth the splurge. Both brands have earned my trust, and I hope my experience helps you find the perfect paint for your next project.

Grab a brush, pick your shade, and transform your space—you’ve got this!