Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal Reviews: Think TWICE!

If you’re like me, you’ve probably scoured the cereal aisle looking for the perfect combination of taste, nutrition, and that elusive guilt-free indulgence. When I stumbled upon Eat Your Mouth Off Chocolate Cereal, I thought I had found a hidden gem.

A high-protein, zero-added-sugar, vegan-friendly cereal with a chocolatey twist? Sounds like breakfast dreams come true, right? Well, let me save you some trouble—you might want to set your expectations differently before you pick up that box.

First Impressions of Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal

Eat Your Mouth Off certainly knows how to grab your attention.

From the bold, playful name to its flashy promise of 100% plant-based ingredients and 22 grams of protein per serving, the marketing paints a picture of a revolutionary product.

It’s like the brand is daring you to try something new while whispering, “You’ll love this.”

But as much as I wanted to be blown away, my actual experience didn’t quite live up to the hype.

The Taste Test: Sweet Cocoa or Artificial Overload?

I’ll be honest—I had high hopes. I poured myself a bowl, added my favorite oat milk, and went in for that first bite.

Initially, there was a faint hit of cocoa sweetness, but it quickly dissolved into something… off.

It’s hard to describe, but the artificial sweetener aftertaste was overwhelming.

Think of biting into something that tricks you with a promising aroma but leaves a chalky, chemical-like flavor in your mouth.

Eating it dry wasn’t much better. While it starts with a faint resemblance to chocolate cereal classics like Cocoa Puffs, the aftertaste is just as overpowering. And if you leave it sitting in milk? It turns into a gritty, mushy mess that’s less about indulgence and more about endurance.

Texture Troubles: Styrofoam, Anyone?

One of the biggest letdowns for me was the texture. The cereal pieces are thick and dense—far from the light and crispy bite I was expecting. The moment they hit the milk, they don’t soften in a pleasant way; instead, they take on a texture that’s strangely reminiscent of soggy cardboard.

Honestly, it’s not the kind of mouthfeel that leaves you reaching for a second bowl.

The Pros of Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal

Even though my experience was far from perfect, I’ll give credit where it’s due. Here’s what Eat Your Mouth Off does well:

High Protein Content: At 22 grams per serving, this cereal packs a punch when it comes to protein. If you’re on a plant-based diet and looking to up your protein intake, this is a potential option.
Low in Sugar: With zero added sugar, it appeals to those trying to cut down on overly sweetened cereals.
Vegan-Friendly: It’s 100% vegan, making it a guilt-free choice for anyone committed to plant-based living.
Portable Snack: Dry, it could work as a quick snack on the go—if you can get past the taste.

Why Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal Falls Short?

Unfortunately, the cons outweigh the pros for this cereal. Here’s what you should consider:

Artificial Taste: The overpowering artificial sweetener aftertaste makes it difficult to enjoy.
Unpleasant Texture: Thick and gritty, especially after a few seconds in milk, the texture leaves much to be desired.
Lack of Versatility: Unlike other cereals that can double as tasty toppings or snacks, this one struggles to perform even in its intended role.
Disappointing Presentation: Let’s not ignore the visual aspect—many reviewers have compared its appearance to rat droppings. Not exactly appetizing.

Comparing Eat Your Mouth Off With Other Brands

Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal Vs. Orgain Fruity Cereal

Flavor: Orgain Fruity Cereal is known for its bright, nostalgic flavor profile reminiscent of childhood classics like Froot Loops. The fruity notes feel natural and balanced, without overwhelming sweetness or artificial aftertaste. In contrast, Eat Your Mouth Off starts with a faint chocolate flavor that’s quickly overshadowed by a harsh, artificial aftertaste that lingers unpleasantly. If taste matters most to you, Orgain wins this round hands down.
Texture: Orgain Fruity Cereal delivers a satisfying crunch that holds up well in milk, making each bite enjoyable from start to finish. On the other hand, Eat Your Mouth Off cereal suffers from a dense, gritty texture that turns to mush within seconds of hitting milk. While Orgain offers a classic cereal experience, Eat Your Mouth Off feels more like a chore to chew.
Nutritional Profile: Both cereals cater to health-conscious consumers, but their focus differs. Orgain is more about clean, organic ingredients and provides moderate protein levels, while Eat Your Mouth Off is all about high protein (22g per serving). However, the unpleasant taste and texture of Eat Your Mouth Off make its nutritional benefits less appealing. If you prioritize a balance of health and enjoyment, Orgain strikes a better middle ground.

Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal Vs. Seven Sundays Cereal

Flavor: Seven Sundays Cereal emphasizes natural flavors, using real fruit and whole ingredients to create a mildly sweet, wholesome taste. It doesn’t try to mimic sugary cereals, instead offering a sophisticated alternative. Eat Your Mouth Off attempts to deliver indulgent chocolate flavors but ends up with an overpowering artificial sweetness that detracts from the experience. Seven Sundays’ subtlety makes it far more enjoyable for adults seeking a healthier option.
Texture: Seven Sundays uses a blend of whole grains that provide a hearty, satisfying crunch. Whether dry or soaked in milk, it maintains a great bite throughout. Meanwhile, Eat Your Mouth Off’s thick, styrofoam-like texture and its tendency to dissolve into a soggy, gritty mess in milk leave much to be desired. Seven Sundays takes the win for texture, especially for cereal lovers who value a pleasant mouthfeel.
Nutritional Profile: Eat Your Mouth Off focuses on protein, boasting 22g per serving, while Seven Sundays prioritizes natural ingredients and fiber content. Both are vegan and plant-based, but Seven Sundays’ clean ingredient list gives it a nutritional edge for those who avoid processed or artificial components. Eat Your Mouth Off may pack more protein, but Seven Sundays provides a more wholesome and balanced nutritional experience.

Eat Your Mouth Off Cereal Vs. Premier Protein Cereal

Flavor: Premier Protein Cereal delivers on its promise of indulgent flavors with a focus on simplicity. It offers a satisfying chocolate taste without veering into overly artificial territory. Compared to the chemical aftertaste of Eat Your Mouth Off, Premier Protein provides a far superior chocolate experience.
Texture: Premier Protein Cereal manages to replicate the light, crispy texture you’d expect from traditional cereals. It remains crunchy in milk without becoming overly soft. Eat Your Mouth Off, on the other hand, suffers from an unappealing texture that’s both dense and gritty. If texture is a deciding factor, Premier Protein easily outperforms.
Nutritional Profile: Both cereals prioritize high protein content, with Premier Protein offering 20g per serving compared to Eat Your Mouth Off’s 22g. However, Premier Protein achieves this without sacrificing taste or texture, making it the more well-rounded choice. Eat Your Mouth Off may edge out slightly in protein, but Premier Protein’s overall balance makes it a better option for most people.

Making the Most of What You’ve Got

If you’ve already bought a box and don’t want it to go to waste, here are some tips to salvage it:

Use It as a Mix-In: Combine it with a sweeter cereal to balance out the flavor.
Blend It Into Smoothies: Pulverize the cereal and use it as a protein-packed ingredient in chocolate or peanut butter smoothies.
Bake With It: Crush it up and use it as a crunchy topping for yogurt parfaits or baked goods.
Portion Carefully: Stick to smaller servings to minimize the overpowering aftertaste.

Is Eat Your Mouth Off Worth It?

If you’re looking for a truly indulgent breakfast cereal or snack, this isn’t it. While the high protein and vegan credentials are impressive, the overwhelming artificial aftertaste, unpleasant texture, and lackluster versatility make it a tough recommendation.

If you’re seeking a healthier cereal alternative, I’d suggest looking elsewhere—brands like Magic Spoon or Catalina Crunch deliver far better experiences without sacrificing nutrition.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is Mouth Off cereal good for you?

Nutritionally, Eat Your Mouth Off has its merits, like high protein and no added sugar. However, the overpowering artificial taste and texture issues may outweigh the health benefits for many.

Who owns Mouth Off cereal?

Eat Your Mouth Off cereal is a product of Kellogg’s, a well-known name in the cereal world. Unfortunately, it doesn’t live up to the reputation of their other offerings.

Is healthy cereal actually healthy?

Not all healthy cereals are created equal. While low sugar and high protein are great, taste, texture, and ingredient quality also matter. It’s essential to find a balance between health benefits and enjoyment.

Is Eat Your Mouth Off cereal vegan?

Yes, it’s 100% vegan and plant-based, making it a suitable option for those following a vegan diet.

Wrapping It Up

So, should you buy Eat Your Mouth Off Chocolate Cereal? If you’re chasing nutritional goals at any cost and don’t mind sacrificing flavor and texture, it might be worth a try.

But for the rest of us who want a satisfying breakfast or snack, there are much better options out there. Save your taste buds—and your wallet—for something you’ll actually enjoy.