When it comes to down comforters, Cuddledown and The Company Store are two of the most well-known and popular brands. But which one offers the better quality and value for your money?
This in-depth guide compares the pros, cons, features, and key differences between Cuddledown and The Company Store down comforters to help you decide which is best for your needs and budget.
A Brief Comparison Table
| Aspects | Cuddledown | The Company Store |
| Fill Power | 600-800 | 550-600 |
| Shell Fabric | 400-600 thread count cotton sateen or percale | 300 thread count cotton sateen |
| Construction | Baffle box, double needle stitching | Baffle box |
| Warranty | Lifetime guarantee | 5 years |
| Warmth Ratings | Rated 1-5 based on temperature | General warmth only |
| Size Range | Twin to California King, plus specialty sizes | Twin to California King |
| Price Range | $200 – $600+ | $160 – $500 |
| Ethical Sourcing | Uses RDS-certified down | No ethical sourcing details |
| Returns | 60-night trial, free shipping | 60-night trial, return shipping fee |
Overview of Cuddledown and The Company Store
Cuddledown and The Company Store both offer high-end down comforters known for their outstanding warmth, fluffiness, and durability.
- Cuddledown
Cuddledown is a family-owned business founded in 1973 that specializes in down bedding, including comforters, pillows, mattress pads, and more.
Their down comforters feature baffle box construction to prevent the down from shifting and are filled with premium ethically-sourced goose down.
Cuddledown has a reputation for excellent quality and service.
Their comforters come with a lifetime guarantee against defects in materials and workmanship.
- The Company Store
The Company Store was established in 1910 and offers a wide range of home goods. Their down comforters contain high-quality down sourced from Europe and Canada.
They use a baffle box design and preshrunk cotton shell. The Company Store comforters come with a 5-year warranty.
Key Differences Between Cuddledown And Company Store Down Comforters
Both brands sell directly to consumers online and have excellent customer service and satisfaction guarantees. Now let’s compare them in more detail across several factors:
Down Fill Power
The fill power of down refers to its loft and insulation quality. Higher fill powers like 600-900+ provide more warmth without extra weight. Here is how Cuddledown and The Company Store compare:
- Cuddledown: Offers comforters with 600, 700, and 800 fill power options. This gives you choices for year-round warmth levels.
- The Company Store: Most comforters are 550 or 600 fill power. Warmer 700-800 options are less common.
Winner: Cuddledown offers more choices for high fill power down comforters.
Shell Fabric
The outer fabric shell of the comforter impacts the durability, texture, and ease of maintenance.
- Cuddledown: Uses 400-thread-count sateen cotton shell or lightweight percale. Durable, breathable, and smooth.
- The Company Store: 300-thread-count sateen cotton shell. Less soft than Cuddledown but still good quality.
Winner: Cuddledown due to the higher thread count shell options.
Construction and Durability
Sturdy construction ensures the down stays evenly distributed inside the comforter.
- Cuddledown: Box baffle construction with double-needle stitching minimizes shifting. Very durable with a lifetime guarantee.
- The Company Store: Also box baffle construction. 5-year warranty indicates less durable than Cuddledown.
Winner: Cuddledown offers better construction and an unmatched lifetime guarantee.
Warmth Ratings
The warmth level you need depends on your climate and sleep preferences.
- Cuddledown: Rates comforters on a 1-5 warmth scale. Lets you customize warmth.
- The Company Store: Most are general warmth without temperature ratings. Less choice.
Winner: Cuddledown for providing a temperature-based rating system.
Sizes Available
Getting the right size comforter ensures it fits your bed properly.
- Cuddledown: Offers all standard sizes from twin to California king plus some specialty sizes.
- The Company Store: Also has standard size range but fewer extra-large options.
Winner: Cuddledown for slightly more size availability.
Price and Value
Comforters are a long-term investment. Quality vs. cost is important.
- Cuddledown: $200 to $600+ based on size, warmth, and fill power. Excellent quality relative to price.
- The Company Store: $160 to $500 range. Very good for the price but Cuddledown has premium options.
Winner: Cuddledown if you want top-tier quality. Company Store better value on a budget.
Ethical Sourcing Practices
Responsible down sourcing helps ducks and geese. Check company policies.
- Cuddledown: Uses RDS-certified down and traceability program. Ensures humane practices.
- The Company Store: No details available on ethical sourcing standards for down.
Winner: Cuddledown for their transparency and commitment to responsible down certification.
Returns and Warranty
Good coverage provides peace of mind in case of defects.
- Cuddledown: Lifetime guarantee against manufacturing defects. 60-night trial with free returns.
- The Company Store: 5-year warranty. Also has 60-night trial but charges return shipping.
Winner: Cuddledown offers a true lifetime guarantee and totally free returns.
Key Differences and Which Is Best
To recap, here are the main differences between the two brands:
- Cuddledown has higher fill power options, softer shell fabrics, better construction and durability, more sizing, premium quality, and ethical sourcing.
- The Company Store has very good but slightly lower performance, fewer luxury comforter choices, and more affordable pricing.
So which is better?
Cuddledown is the winner if you want the absolute best quality and don’t mind paying more for it.
Their comforters are exceptionally warm, soft, durable, and ethically-sourced.
The Company Store offers impressive value and quality at lower prices.
If you want great performance for the budget, they are an excellent option.
You can’t go wrong with either brand, but your priorities for fill power, materials, and price will determine whether Cuddledown or Company Store is better for your needs.
Cuddledown Down Comforter Pros and Cons
Let’s now take an in-depth look at the key benefits and drawbacks of Cuddledown down comforters:
Pros
- Ultra-plush feel from premium down and shell
- Very breathable and moisture-wicking
- Maintains loft and insulation over time
- Distributes down evenly without shifting
- Highly durable construction and materials
- Wide range of sizes for any bed
- Temperature-based warmth rating system
- ethically sourced down
- Lifetime guarantee
Cons
- More expensive than many other brands
- Must be professionally cleaned occasionally
- Need to fluff regularly to maintain maximum loft
The Company Store Down Comforter Pros and Cons
Here are the main advantages and disadvantages of The Company Store’s down comforters:
Pros
- Quality materials at an affordable price point
- Warm and lightweight yet cozy
- Durable baffle box construction
- Wide range of attractive styles
- Machine washable for easy care
- Good comforter for year-round use
Cons
- Lower fill power than premium brands
- Lacks super-soft shell options
- Limited high-end choices for super warmth
- Shorter 5-year warranty period
- Must pay return shipping for trial
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Yes, Cuddledown is a very legitimate company. They have been family-owned and operated in the USA since 1973 and are considered an industry leader in high-end down bedding. Cuddledown has outstanding reviews and an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau.
The Company Store is a good and reputable brand known for decent quality at moderate price points. They have been around for over 100 years. While not quite as luxurious as top-tier brands like Cuddledown, The Company Store makes excellent down comforters that offer very good performance and comfort for the price.
Yes, Cuddledown remains in business today and is still family-run. They continue to sell their popular American-made down comforters direct to consumers online and run their own manufacturing facility.
Cuddledown is 100% American owned and operated. Their down comforters are designed and manufactured at their factory in Eden Prairie, Minnesota. Cuddledown takes pride in being an American-made company.
Conclusion
In summary, Cuddledown and The Company Store both make wonderful down comforters. Cuddledown stands out for unparalleled quality, maximum warmth, and ethical practices. But The Company Store offers impressive performance at lower price points.
Consider your budget, needs for fill power and durability, and care requirements to decide which brand suits your lifestyle. With proper care, either brand will provide many years of blissfully warm and comfortable sleep.