CordaRoy’s Vs. Lovesac: Here’s The One I Kept (And Why It Saved Me Thousands)

I’ve spent years chasing the perfect mix of comfort, versatility, and value in furniture. As someone who’s moved apartments more times than I care to count, hosted countless game nights, and dealt with surprise overnight guests, I’ve tried everything from cheap futons to high-end sectionals.

That’s how I ended up with both a CordaRoy’s convertible bean bag bed and a Lovesac Sac in my living room at one point. My goal here is to help you decide between these two popular foam-filled giants by sharing what I’ve learned from real-life use—no sales pitch, just straight talk from someone who’s flopped onto both more times than I can count.

Right off the bat, here’s a quick side-by-side that cuts through the noise. I made this table based on my own pieces (a Queen CordaRoy’s and a SuperSac-equivalent from Lovesac) plus current pricing and specs as of late 2025.

Head-to-Head Comparison of CordaRoy’s And Lovesac

After living with both side-by-side for almost two years (yes, my living room looked ridiculous), here’s the no-BS comparison across the scenarios that actually matter to me.

• Comfort Showdown (Sitting and Lounging): Lovesac destroys CordaRoy’s for pure relaxation. That softer DuraFoam blend lets you melt into it—no effort required to get comfortable. I could (and did) spend entire Sundays disappearing into the Sac. CordaRoy’s feels more like a supportive chair—great for upright reading, working on my laptop, or gaming because I don’t sink so deep I lose circulation in my legs. If your idea of comfort includes staying productive, CordaRoy’s wins. If it’s total zoning out, Lovesac every time.
• Versatility and Guest-Ready Reality: CordaRoy’s laps the field here. Unexpected overnight guests? Ten minutes later everyone has a real bed with actual mattress support. I’ve hosted Thanksgiving crashes, sick friends, and breakup sleepovers—no air mattress drama. Lovesac is strictly a lounger. You can nap on it, maybe squeeze two people for a drunk sleep, but nobody wants to wake up achy after a full night.
• Durability and Long-Term Wear: Both are tanks, honestly. My CordaRoy’s foam still rebounds perfectly after countless conversions. Lovesac’s reputation for never sagging held true too. Edge goes slightly to CordaRoy’s because the lifetime warranty covers everything, including covers.
• Maintenance and Cleaning: Tie, but different strengths. Both covers wash beautifully. CordaRoy’s is easier day-to-day because chenille/microfiber hides fur and stains better between washes. Lovesac’s luxury fabrics (phur especially) show everything but clean up dramatically when you do wash them.
• Value for Money in 2025 Dollars: CordaRoy’s wins by a mile for 90% of people. You’re getting comparable daily comfort plus a legitimate guest bed for literally half (or less) the price. Lovesac only makes financial sense if you genuinely don’t need the bed function and have the budget for luxury lounging.
• Style and Room Aesthetics: Lovesac takes this easily. The premium covers look expensive and elevate the whole room. CordaRoy’s looks cozy and intentional but never “designer.” If your space is Instagram-worthy, Lovesac fits better.
• Space Efficiency and Moving: CordaRoy’s again. In chair mode it’s compact and purposeful. When you need floor space for yoga or kids playing, the bed folds away completely. Lovesac is a permanent fixture—beautiful, but always there.
• Heat and Temperature Regulation: CordaRoy’s edges it out. The denser foam and better airflow mean I never overheat, even in summer. Lovesac’s plusher foam can trap heat during long sessions—fine in winter, sweaty otherwise.
• Kid and Pet Friendliness: CordaRoy’s for the win with active households. The firmer structure holds up better to jumping and wrestling, and the bed feature means sleepovers are effortless. Lovesac is comfier for cuddling but shows wear faster from claws and rough play.
• Who Ends Up Using It Most in My House: The dogs picked Lovesac (softer = better nap spot). The humans picked CordaRoy’s for everything else—reading, working, actual sleeping. That’s probably the clearest real-world verdict.

What I Love About CordaRoy’s (The Pros That Keep Me Coming Back)

I’ve owned my queen-size CordaRoy’s for over five years now, and it’s still the piece I reach for when I need reliable comfort without fuss. Here’s what makes it stand out in my everyday life.

• The bed conversion changes everything for real sleep When friends or family stay over, I unzip it in under two minutes and have a full queen mattress that’s thick, supportive, and honestly better than most pull-out couches I’ve tried. Guests routinely tell me they slept like babies—no back pain, no sagging in the middle. The foam is dense enough to feel like a legitimate bed, not just a padded floor.
• Insane value that makes the price laughable I paid around $420 for mine on sale. For that, I got a daily chair plus a guest bed that would cost $800+ anywhere else. Even at full price today (closer to $550–$650 depending on fabric), it’s half or less what a comparable Lovesac setup runs after you add a decent cover.
• Machine-washable and pet/kid-proof in practice My dogs treat it like their personal throne. Spills, fur, muddy paws—the cover zips off, survives my washer and dryer on gentle, and comes out perfect. I’ve done this dozens of times with zero shrinking or fading on the chenille.
• Lifetime warranty that actually means something The foam and workmanship are covered forever. I’ve seen people online replace torn covers or sagging foam years later at no cost. That kind of backing lets me relax instead of babying the furniture.
• Easier to live with in smaller spaces It doesn’t dominate the room like some massive Sacs do. When it’s in chair mode, it looks intentional and cozy, not like a giant blob taking over my living room.
• No off-gassing and safer materials Straight out of the box, zero chemical smell. The foam is CertiPUR-US certified, which gave me peace of mind when my niece started using it as her reading nook.

Where CordaRoy’s Falls Short for Me (The Cons I Can’t Ignore)

It’s not flawless, and these are the things that occasionally make me eye my old Lovesac photos with nostalgia.

• Converting it back into the chair is a workout Folding and stuffing a queen-size foam mattress back into the cover takes real effort—think 5–10 minutes of wrestling if you’re alone. My partner and I tag-team it now, but the first few times left me sweaty and annoyed.
• Sitting comfort is supportive but not “cloud-like” Because the foam is designed to function as a real bed first, it’s firmer and more structured. Great for posture and long gaming sessions, but you don’t get that total enveloping sink that makes you forget you’re sitting.
• Fewer luxury fabric choices You get solid options—chenille, microfiber, faux fur, corduroy—but nothing like the 250+ premium covers Lovesac offers. If you want something wild like escapist phur or patterned velvet, you’re out of luck.
• Needs occasional fluffing after heavy bed use After a weekend of guests, the foam can clump a bit when you stuff it back in. A quick shake and punch usually fixes it, but it’s one extra step Lovesac rarely requires.
• Heavier than you’d expect for “just a bean bag” My queen weighs about 75 lbs. Fine once it’s placed, but rearranging the living room for cleaning day means recruiting help.

Why Lovesac Sac Feels Like Pure Luxury (The Pros That Justify the Splurge)

I splurged on a SuperSac with a phur cover during a 30% off sale, and for pure lounging, nothing in my house has ever come close.

• That sink-in comfort is legitimately addictive The DuraFoam blend is softer and more responsive—it’s like the foam hugs every curve. Reading, napping, or binge-watching feels decadent. My friends literally fight over who gets the Sac on movie nights.
• Endless cover options let you redesign on a whim I started with standard corduroy, then switched to a plush faux fur for winter and a sleek velvet for summer. Changing covers takes minutes and completely transforms the vibe of the room.
• Holds its shape like nothing else Five years of daily use (including dog zoomies and kid pile-ons), and it still looks and feels brand new. No flat spots, no permanent indentations.
• Perfect for sprawling with multiple people The bigger sizes (SuperSac and up) easily swallow two adults plus kids or pets. It’s social furniture—everyone ends up migrating to it.
• Premium build quality you can feel The stitching, zippers, and overall construction scream high-end. It just feels expensive in the best way.

The Downsides of Lovesac That Made Me Keep My CordaRoy’s Too

The price tag isn’t the only reason I eventually sold mine.

• Eye-watering cost, especially with covers separate Even on sale, insert + good cover easily hits $1,200–$2,000+. That’s real money for something that doesn’t double as a bed.
• Not a viable overnight sleeping solution Naps? Heavenly. Full night? You wake up hot in the dips and sore where support is lacking. I’ve tried with toppers—still no match for CordaRoy’s flat mattress.
• Takes up permanent real estate It’s massive and doesn’t tuck away. In smaller apartments, it can make the room feel cluttered no matter how you arrange it.
• Heavier and harder to move solo My SuperSac was over 100 lbs. Vacuuming underneath or rearranging meant waiting for help.
• Shorter warranty on the parts that wear out Lifetime on foam is great, but covers only get three years. Replacing a $400+ cover because of pet damage hurts.

My Personal Experiences: Stories From The Trenches

I’ll never forget the first time my in-laws visited unexpectedly.

With Lovesac, we’d have been scrambling for air mattresses.

With CordaRoy’s, I just pulled out the queen bed and everyone slept great.

On the flip side, during a week-long staycation, the Lovesac was where we all gravitated for movies—nobody wanted to leave that cloud-like embrace.

One summer, both dogs decided the Lovesac was their throne. Cleaning the phur cover was easy, but the CordaRoy’s chenille hid fur better day-to-day.

When I moved last year, the CordaRoy’s was infinitely easier to transport and set up in the new place.

• Who Should Buy CordaRoy’s?

You have frequent overnight guests, limited space, kids or pets that destroy furniture, or simply want maximum bang for your buck. If you’re furnishing a first apartment, game room, or dorm—start here.

• Who Should Buy Lovesac Sac?

You prioritize pure lounging luxury above all else, have the budget, want endless style options, and don’t need a real guest bed. It’s the ultimate “treat yourself” piece.

Also Read: Comparison of LoveSac And Comfy Sacks.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Final Verdict

After living with both, I kept the CordaRoy’s as my main piece and sold the Lovesac. The bed conversion and value won me over completely. That said, if money weren’t a factor and I had a dedicated theater room, I’d buy the Lovesac again in a heartbeat for that unmatched sink-in feel.

You really can’t go wrong—both are miles ahead of traditional bean bags. Think about your actual lifestyle: Do you need a guest bed more than ultimate plushness? Go CordaRoy’s. Do you just want the comfiest seat on earth? Lovesac.

Whichever you choose, you’re getting American-made quality that lasts. And if you’re still torn, many showrooms let you try both—sit, flop, and decide for yourself.