When it comes to comfy, cozy comforters, Buffy and its Cloud Comforter seem to get all the buzz lately. But Buffy recently launched a new down alternative comforter called the Buffy Breeze, leaving many fans wondering how it compares to the popular Cloud Comforter.
Should you make the switch? Or stick with the tried and true cloud?
I took a deep dive into both comforters to find out. Below is a detailed comparison of the key features, pros and cons, and real user experiences with both the Buffy Breeze and Cloud comforters.
My goal is to arm you with the info you need to decide which of these two fan favorite comforters is better for your unique sleeping needs and preferences.
Key Feature Comparison
Before we dig into the pros, cons and real user reviews, let’s look at how the two comforters stack up on specs:
| Feature | Buffy Breeze | Buffy Cloud |
| Fill Material | Proprietary Breeze fiber blend | Proprietary cloud fiber blend |
| Weight | Lightweight | Heavyweight |
| Warmth Rating | 3 seasons | 4 seasons |
| Shell Fabric | Eucalyptus Tencel lyocell | Eucalyptus Tencel lyocell |
| Fill Power | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
| Thread Count | Not disclosed | Not disclosed |
| Sizes Available | Full/Queen, King/CA King | Full/Queen, King/CA King |
| Price | $169-$219 | $159-$209 |
| Warranty | 1 year | 1 year |
| Certifications | STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX, MADE SAFE | STANDARD 100 by OEKO-TEX, MADE SAFE |
As you can see from the table, the two comforters have a lot of similarities. They both use proprietary down alternative fibers, eucalyptus Tencel lyocell shells, and are OEKO-TEX and MADE SAFE certified.
The main differences come down to warmth rating and weight. The Cloud is rated for 4 seasons, while the Breeze is a 3 season comforter. And the Cloud is noticeably heavier and thicker than the new lightweight Breeze.
Beyond the specs, there are some key pros, cons and differences between the two comforters that real user reviews consistently point out. Let’s explore those next.
Key Differences Between The Breeze And Cloud
While the Breeze and Cloud share similarities like their shell fabric and certifications, they have some notable differences when it comes to performance, feel and intended use cases:
- Weight and Warmth
The Cloud is noticeably heavier and warmer than the Breeze. The Cloud weighs around 7-10 lbs compared to the Breeze’s 5-7 lbs depending on size. And it’s rated for 4 season use, while the Breeze is better for 3 seasons. The Cloud’s extra weight comes from its thicker, more insulating fill. This makes it excel at trapping heat. But also means it can overheat.
- Fill Material
Both use proprietary down alternative fibers, but the Breeze fill is engineered more for breathability. It’s designed to allow more airflow and regulate temperature better. Meanwhile the Cloud fill prioritizes trapping heat. The materials are different densities tuned for their specific purposes.
- Feel and Sound
The Breeze has a more silky, smooth feel while the Cloud feels more substantial and densely cushy. The Breeze also makes less crinkly sounds than the Cloud thanks to its more lightweight fill. Its construction cuts down on the fill shifting and clumping that can cause that crinkly down-like noise.
- Fluffiness
The Cloud has more loft and feels ultra fluffy, akin to a down comforter. Its fill stays evenly distributed for consistent marshmallowy softness. The Breeze has less loft and is comparatively thinner and flatter. It lacks that super plush hotel bed feel.
- Durability
The Cloud is longer-lasting, maintaining its loft and feel over years of use. The fill doesn’t shift or clump as quickly as cheaper down alternatives. The Breeze may compress and flatten more rapidly over time according to user reviews. Its thinner construction seems less hardy for the long haul.
- Price
The Cloud is $10-20 more expensive depending on size. The construction and materials that provide its unmatched longevity come at a small premium. Value-focused shoppers may prefer the Breeze for slightly less.
So in summary – the Cloud excels on insulation, plushiness and durability, while the Breeze is lighter, more breathable and better for warmer weather. Decide based on the attributes most important to your needs.
Buffy Breeze Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Lightweight and breathable for hot sleepers
- Cooling breeze fiber fill regulates temperature
- Silky soft Tencel shell feels luxurious
- Ideal for multi-season use
- Makes less crinkly sounds than original Cloud
- Less fill shifting and clumping than Cloud
- Good for people with allergies
- Affordable compared to down comforters
- OEKO-TEX and MADE SAFE certified
Cons:
- Thinner and less fluffy than the Cloud
- Not as warm for winter & cold sleepers
- Tencel shell prone to wrinkles
- Only available direct from Buffy (no Amazon)
- Not as long lasting as the Cloud
- Lacks the cloud-like hotel bed feel
The biggest upside of the Breeze is the lightweight, breathable feel that makes it perfect for hot sleepers or multi-season use. It sleeps cooler than the cloud and has less fill shifting. The breezy fill is also great for allergy sufferers.
Downsides are that it lacks the marshmallow-y thickness of the Cloud, isn’t as warm, and may not hold up as well long term. Some miss that luxurious hotel bed feel of the Cloud.
Buffy Cloud Pros and Cons
Pros:
- Plush, fluffy and cloud-like
- Warm and insulating – great for cold weather
- Makes you feel like you’re sleeping in a luxe hotel bed
- Stays evenly distributed and puffy over time
- Barely makes any crinkly sounds
- Available on Amazon for fast, free shipping
- Long lasting over many years
Cons:
- Too hot for warm and hot sleepers
- Heavyweight and overly warm in summer
- Fill clumps and shifts more over time
- Shell prone to wrinkling
- Not as breathable as the Breeze
- Allergens can get trapped in thicker fill
- More expensive than the Breeze
The Cloud’s biggest benefits are its cloud-like fluffiness, warmth, and longevity. It excels at making you feel like you’re floating in a puffy hotel bed. The fill stays evenly distributed for that pillowy feel.
Drawbacks are it sleeps hot, can be too heavy for warmer weather, and the fill is prone to shifting. It also may trap allergens more than the Breeze. And it comes with a higher price tag.
Buffy Breeze Versus Cloud: Real User Reviews
Beyond the specs and main pros and cons, it’s helpful to look at real user reviews of the Breeze and Cloud. Here’s what buyers love and don’t love about each after sleeping on these comforters:
Buffy Breeze User Reviews
- “This is so much more breathable than the original Cloud! I’m a hot sleeper and finally found a comforter I don’t overheat in.”
- “I got the Breeze since I wanted something lighter for summer but still cozy for year-round use. It’s perfect for me!”
- “This feels nicer and less crinkly than the Cloud. Great lightweight comforter for allergies.”
- “Not as puffy and luxurious feeling as the Cloud but much better for warm weather.”
Buffy Cloud User Reviews
- “I love sinking into the thick, fluffy comfort of this comforter! Feels like I’m at a 5-star hotel.”
- “This comforter is sooo warm and cozy – perfect for winter and cold nights.”
- “I’ve washed it multiple times over 3 years now and it’s held up great. Worth the price!”
- “Much warmer than I expected! Great for winter but too hot in the summer.”
As you can see, the Breeze appeals most to hot sleepers wanting breathability, while the Cloud wins on luxury, warmth and durability.
Which Is Better: Buffy Breeze Or Cloud?
So when all is said and done, which comforter is best – the Buffy Breeze or the OG Cloud Comforter?
In terms of quality and performance, both are excellent mid-range down alternative comforters that use high quality materials to mimic the feel of a premium down comforter at an affordable direct-to-consumer price point.
For hot sleepers or those wanting a lightweight, breathable comforter for multi-season use, the new Buffy Breeze is the better choice. Its breeze fill and lightweight feel prevent overheating at night.
If you want that ultra-plush, fluffy hotel bed feel, the Cloud is better suited to delivering that marshmallowy softness and cloud-like sleeping experience. It’s also the warmer, more insulating choice for winter and cold weather.
Both comforters are great options in the budget-friendly down alternative space. Choose based on your unique sleeping needs and preferences. And rest assured with Buffy’s 1 year warranty and customer-friendly return policy, you can try out either comforter risk-free.
Hopefully this detailed comparison of the Buffy Breeze and Cloud comforter helps you decide which of these popular down alternative comforters is the right fit for your perfect night’s sleep!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
The Buffy Cloud comforter does tend to sleep hot, especially in warm weather or for people who run naturally warm. Its thick, heavyweight fill traps heat and can cause overheating. Many hot sleepers find it too warm for summer or year-round use. The new Buffy Breeze is a lighter, more breathable option.
Buffy is considered one of the leading direct-to-consumer bedding brands, known for quality down alternative comforters at affordable prices. Their signature Cloud comforter is loved by many for its hotel-like feel. And their eucalyptus Tencel shell fabric and proprietary fills aim to mimic premium down. With over 17,000 5-star reviews, Buffy has earned a reputation for quality comforters.
Yes, the Buffy Breeze comforter is fully machine washable. Buffy recommends washing it a maximum of once every 3 months, on a gentle cycle with cold water. Air dry or tumble dry low. Be sure to use a duvet cover to protect the shell fabric.
Some of the top brands for quality down comforters are Brooklinen, Parachute, Riley Home, Snowe Home, and Boll & Branch. They use premium down with high fill power and thread counts at mid-high price points. More affordable options are Buffy’s Cloud comforter or Amazon’s RDS down comforters.
Wrapping Up
In summary, for a lightweight and breathable 3-season comforter, go with Buffy’s new Breeze. But if you want unmatched fluffiness, warmth and durability, stick with the tried and true Buffy Cloud.
Either way, you can’t go wrong giving one of these popular down alternative comforters a try. Sweet dreams!