Beyond Brew Vs. Everyday Dose: I Tried Both for 30 Days. Here’s the Brutal Truth.

I was a mess. Every morning, I’d wake up and slam a 12-ounce cup of dark roast coffee just to feel human. By 11 AM, I was jittery, anxious, and couldn’t focus. By 3 PM, I was a zombie, hunting for sugar or another cup, which I knew would ruin my sleep.

I was stuck in a caffeine trap and needed a way out. My quest led me to the world of mushroom-based coffee alternatives, and two names kept appearing: Everyday Dose and Beyond Brew. I bought both. This is the complete story of my experience and how these two “better energy” drinks stack up.

The main intent of this article is to give you a real-user, first-person breakdown of every single component, from taste and texture to the actual feeling you get, so you can decide which one is truly worth your money.

A Brief Comparison Table

The Coffee Problem: Why I Was Desperate For A Change

Let’s be real: I love coffee. I love the smell, I love the ritual, I love that first-sip feeling.

What I don’t love is what it had started doing to me. My relationship with caffeine had turned toxic.

It wasn’t just the jitters, that vibrating-in-my-own-skin feeling.

It was the anxiety. I’d find my heart racing during a simple work email.

My focus was a joke; I’d sit down to work, and my brain would have 1,000 tabs open, just like my browser.

Then came the crash. The dreaded 3 PM wall. It was less a “wall” and more of a total system failure. I’d feel sluggish, irritable, and completely drained. This cycle of a 9 AM high followed by a 3 PM low was unsustainable.

I tried switching to green tea, but it just didn’t have the “oomph” I needed to get my day started. I needed something that could provide clean energy, genuine focus, and not make me feel like I was having a low-grade panic attack all day.

That’s when I fell down the mushroom rabbit hole. These “functional mushrooms” aren’t the magic kind, but they might as well be. They promise all the things I was missing: focus, energy, immune support, and stress reduction, all without the negative side effects of high-dose caffeine.

The two biggest players in the game seemed to be Everyday Dose and Beyond Brew. They looked similar, but as I discovered, they are built for two very different people.

First Up: My Experience with Everyday Dose

Everyday Dose markets itself hard as “the coffee replacement.” The branding is slick, minimalist, and very much aimed at the modern, wellness-conscious consumer. My starter kit arrived with a cool, matte black container, a rechargeable frother, and a slick little measuring spoon. They are all-in on “the ritual.”

• The Vibe and The Promise

The promise is simple: the taste of coffee, the calm focus of L-Theanine, and the beauty benefits of collagen, all with 80% less caffeine than a normal cup.² At only 45mg of caffeine, it’s just enough to “wake you up,” but not enough to “wire you.”

I was skeptical. How could this possibly replace my dark roast?

What’s Inside? The Ingredient Deep Look

This is where things get interesting. Everyday Dose has a very lean, targeted formula.

• Lion’s Mane Mushroom: This is the “focus” mushroom.³ It’s a powerful nootropic (a brain-booster) that studies suggest can help with cognitive function and nerve growth factor (NGF). This is the ingredient you want for clearing brain fog.
• Chaga Mushroom: This is the “immunity” mushroom.⁴ It’s an antioxidant powerhouse, traditionally used to support the immune system and reduce inflammation.⁵
• L-Theanine: This is their secret weapon. L-Theanine is an amino acid found in green tea that promotes a sense of “calm alertness.”⁶ When you combine it with caffeine, you get a beautiful synergy. The L-Theanine smooths out the rough edges of the caffeine, eliminating the jitters and anxiety while sharpening the focus.⁷ It’s a “smart drug” stack, and it works.
• Grass-Fed Collagen (Types I & III): This is the “beauty” and “joint” bonus.⁸ Collagen is the most abundant protein in our bodies, and supplementing with it is all the rage for improving skin elasticity, hair strength, and joint health.⁹ This is a huge value-add if those are your goals.
• Low-Acidity Coffee Extract: This is how they get the coffee taste and the 45mg of caffeine. By using a low-acid extract, it’s also much gentler on your stomach, which any coffee drinker with acid reflux will appreciate.¹⁰

My Personal Test: Taste, Mixability, and The “Dose”

I boiled the water, added a scoop to my mug, and hit it with the included frother. It instantly whipped up into a creamy, frothy, latte-like drink. It looked and smelled like a decent cup of coffee.

The Taste: I was shocked. It actually tastes like coffee. Not a bold, dark roast, but a very smooth, creamy, light-roast coffee. It’s not bitter at all. It has a slightly earthy, nutty undertone from the mushrooms, but the coffee flavor is absolutely the star. I added a splash of oat milk, and it was, by all accounts, a delicious morning beverage.

The Feel: This is what mattered. About 20 minutes after my first cup, I didn’t feel “jacked.” I just felt… awake. Clear. The brain fog was gone, but so was the anxiety. I sat down to work, and for the first time in a long time, I just worked.

My focus was sharp, my mind was quiet, and I wasn’t bouncing my leg under the desk. There were no jitters. And most importantly? There was no crash. The energy was smooth, and it just gently tapered off in the afternoon. It was exactly what they promised.

Pros of Everyday Dose

• The L-Theanine + Caffeine Stack: This is a game-changer. The “calm focus” is real and incredibly effective for productivity.
• The Collagen Bonus: Getting a solid dose of collagen in my morning drink is a massive win. It’s great for my skin and my creaky knees. It’s a two-for-one.
• The Taste: If you are a coffee lover who just can’t quit the taste of coffee, this is your product. It’s the closest-tasting alternative I’ve found.
• The “Ritual”: The starter kit, with the frother and spoon, makes you feel like you’re having a premium experience. It successfully replaces the coffee-making ritual.
• Gentle on the Stomach: The low-acid coffee extract is fantastic. No stomach burn or acidity.

Cons of Everyday Dose

• Limited Mushroom Spectrum: It only has two mushrooms.¹¹ While they are great, I couldn’t help but wonder if I was missing out on the benefits of others, like Reishi or Cordyceps.
• The Collagen Source: It uses bovine (cow) collagen, so this is not a vegan-friendly product.¹² This is a deal-breaker for many.
• The Price: It’s a premium product with a premium price tag. You are paying for the collagen and the slick marketing.

Next Up: My Experience with Beyond Brew

After a few weeks on Everyday Dose, I switched to Beyond Brew. This one felt different from the start. Made by Live Conscious, the branding is less “minimalist tech bro” and more “earthy, holistic health.” It doesn’t promise to be “coffee.” It promises to be “Beyond” coffee.

Its main sales pitch isn’t just focus; it’s gut health. This perked me up, as I know the gut-brain connection is incredibly powerful.

• The Vibe and The Promise

Beyond Brew promises a 6-in-1 “superfood” blend.¹³ The goal is not just clean energy and focus, but also digestive support and broad-spectrum immunity. It contains a tiny bit of caffeine (~40mg) not from coffee, but from fermented Pu-erh tea.

• What’s Inside? The Ingredient Deep Look

This formula is stacked. It’s a completely different philosophy than Everyday Dose.

• The 6-Mushroom Blend: This is a powerhouse.
  • Lion’s Mane: The same focus mushroom as in Everyday Dose.
  • Reishi: The “chill” mushroom. It’s a powerful adaptogen known for helping the body manage stress and improving sleep.
  • Chaga: The same antioxidant, immune-supporting mushroom.¹⁴
  • Cordyceps: The “energy” mushroom.¹⁵ This one is famous for supporting energy production on a cellular level (ATP) and increasing oxygen uptake. Athletes love it.
  • Turkey Tail: One of the most-studied mushrooms for immune support, particularly for its gut-health properties.¹⁶
  • Maitake: Another immune-supporter that works synergistically with the others.
• The Gut-Health Core: This is its unique selling point.
  • Organic Tahl Gum (Acacia Fiber): A potent prebiotic. This is food for your good gut bacteria, helping them thrive.
  • DE111 (a spore-based Probiotic): This is a specific, shelf-stable probiotic strain that supports digestive health and promotes a healthy gut microbiome.
• Organic Pu-erh Tea: This is the caffeine source. Pu-erh is a fermented tea that is known for being very gentle on the stomach and providing a clean energy lift. It also has its own digestive benefits.
• Organic Cacao and Cinnamon: These are in there for flavor, and they also provide their own antioxidant benefits.

My Personal Test: Taste, Mixability, and The “Brew”

I prepared this one the same way: a scoop in a mug with hot water and my trusty frother (which I now used for everything).

It frothed up, but a little less creamy than Everyday Dose. The color was a deep, dark brown, almost like a hot chocolate.

The Taste: This does not taste like coffee.

And it doesn’t try to. The primary flavor is rich, dark cacao, with a lovely warmth from the cinnamon.

It’s earthy, but not “muddy.” It’s more like a very sophisticated, not-too-sweet hot chocolate.

It’s delicious in its own right, but if you’re expecting coffee, you will be disappointed. I loved it as a “morning cocoa” ritual.

The Feel: This was a totally different kind of energy. The Everyday Dose “feel” was a mental “on” switch. The Beyond Brew “feel” was a physical “on” switch. The Cordyceps and Pu-erh tea provided a clean, sustaining energy that felt like it was coming from my core, not my head. It was less “sharp focus” and more “deep stamina.”

But the real effect took a few days to notice. My digestion felt amazing. I was less bloated, and things just felt… smoother. Calmer. That gut-brain connection is no joke. When my gut felt good, my mood was better, and my overall sense of well-being was higher. The Reishi also seemed to be working, as I just felt a general sense of calm throughout the day.

Pros of Beyond Brew

• The Gut Health Focus: The prebiotic/probiotic combination is a massive differentiator. For anyone with digestive issues, this is the clear winner.
• Broad Mushroom Spectrum: You get six powerful mushrooms, covering energy (Cordyceps), stress (Reishi), focus (Lion’s Mane), and immunity (Chaga, Turkey Tail, Maitake).¹⁹ It feels like a truly holistic blend.
• Completely Vegan: No animal products in sight.
• The Taste: While not “coffee,” the rich cacao-cinnamon flavor is a delicious and comforting ritual in its own right.
• The “Stamina” Energy: The energy from Cordyceps feels more like physical stamina than a mental buzz, which I really enjoyed.

Cons of Beyond Brew

• Not a Coffee Replacement: If you are addicted to the taste of coffee, this will not scratch that itch.
• Lacks the “Laser Focus” Stack: It doesn’t have L-Theanine. While the Lion’s Mane is great for focus, it doesn’t have that immediate, sharp, “calm-alert” kick that the Everyday Dose L-Theanine/caffeine combo provides.
• No Beauty Bonus: You’re not getting any collagen here. The focus is purely on internal health (gut, immunity).

Head-to-Head Comparison of Beyond Brew And Everyday Dose

So, after weeks of testing both, here’s my direct comparison.

• Winner for Focus: Everyday Dose

This one is easy. The combination of 45mg of coffee extract plus L-Theanine is a proven, potent nootropic stack. It delivers a “tunnel vision” focus that is perfect for plowing through a workday, writing, or coding. Beyond Brew’s Lion’s Mane is great for long-term brain health, but it can’t beat the immediate sensation of focus from Everyday Dose.

• Winner for Energy: Beyond Brew

This was a surprise.

Everyday Dose gives you a great mental lift, but Beyond Brew gives you physical stamina.

The combination of Cordyceps and fermented Pu-erh tea provides a deep, non-jittery energy that just lasts.

It’s the difference between feeling “alert” and feeling “powered.”

Winner for Wellness “Extras”: It’s a Tie (Depending on Your Goals)

This is the most important part of the review. Your choice depends entirely on what “extra” you want.

• If your goal is skin, hair, and joint health, Everyday Dose is the only choice. The inclusion of a high-quality, grass-fed collagen is an incredible value.
• If your goal is gut health and broad immune support, Beyond Brew wins by a landslide. The probiotic/prebiotic blend combined with six different mushrooms (especially immune-stars like Turkey Tail and Reishi) is something Everyday Dose can’t even touch.

Winner for Taste: It’s a Tie (Depending on Your Preference)

• If you want a coffee replacement, Everyday Dose is your winner. It’s smooth, creamy, and tastes like a light-roast latte.
• If you want a rich, comforting, non-coffee drink, Beyond Brew is your winner. The cacao-cinnamon flavor is a delicious treat.

Winner for Price and Value: Beyond Brew

While both are premium products, Everyday Dose is generally more expensive per serving. When I looked at what I was getting, Beyond Brew felt like a better value for me.

The sheer number of active, high-end ingredients (six mushrooms plus a pre/probiotic blend) felt more substantial than Everyday Dose’s (two mushrooms plus collagen/L-Theanine).

Also Read: Comparison of Joey And MUD\WTR.

Conclusion: My Final Choice and Who You Should Buy

So, after all this, which one is in my mug this morning?

For weeks, I honestly went back and forth. I loved the laser focus of Everyday Dose for heavy workdays. But I loved the gut-healing, stamina-providing-feel of Beyond Brew for my overall well-being.

In the end, I found myself reordering Beyond Brew. The “calm gut” feeling was the benefit I didn’t even know I was missing. It improved my mood, my digestion, and my baseline energy in a way that the “focus” from Everyday Dose just couldn’t. I can get L-Theanine in a capsule if I need it, but I can’t get that 6-mushroom-probiotic blend anywhere else.

Here’s my final recommendation for you.

You should buy Everyday Dose if:

• You are a die-hard coffee lover who must have that coffee taste.
• Your primary goal is “calm, laser-sharp focus” for work or creative projects.
• A major wellness goal for you is improving your skin, hair, nails, or joints.
• You are not vegan.

You should buy Beyond Brew if:

• Your primary goal is improving your digestion and gut health.
• You want the broadest possible spectrum of mushroom benefits (energy, stress, immunity, focus).
• You want a 100% vegan product.
• You’re happy to trade a coffee taste for a rich, hot-cacao-like flavor.

I started this journey looking for a simple coffee replacement, and I ended up with a much deeper understanding of my own health. The choice isn’t about which product is “better,” but which one is “better for you.”

Do you want to supercharge your brain, or do you want to heal your gut? Once you answer that, your choice becomes clear.