Atrium Vs. Pella Windows For Your Home

If you’re in the market for new windows, two big names you’re likely to encounter are Atrium and Pella. Both companies have been around for decades and offer a wide selection of vinyl, wood, fiberglass, and composite windows.

When it comes to choosing between Atrium and Pella, there are several factors to weigh. Price, warranties, styles, energy-efficiency, and overall quality should all play a role in your decision.

Understanding the pros and cons of each brand will help you make the right investment for your home.

Key Differences At A Glance

Aspects	Atrium	Pella
Price range	$200 – $700	$400 – $2000+
Window types	Double hung, sliders, casements, awnings, and picture models. Basic operating styles.	Wide selection including bay, bow, and specialty windows with built-in shades and blinds.
Materials	Primarily vinyl. Some fiberglass options.	Vinyl, fiberglass, pine, oak, maple, cherry, mahogany, and more.
Energy efficiency	Good. Meets requirements in warmer climates.	Great. Exceeds standards across all regions.
Warranties	Limited lifetime on vinyl and hardware. 10 years on hardware.	Limited lifetime. 20 years on glass. Fully transferable.
Appearance	Attractive but basic styling.	Gorgeous. Upscale styles and visual appeal.
Lead times	Quick shipping, usually in stock.	Longer for custom orders, especially wood windows.
Maintenance	Low maintenance vinyl.	Wood models require restaining and recoating.

As you can see, Atrium and Pella both make quality windows but excel in different areas. Think about your budget, design priorities, and local building requirements as you weigh these two leading brands.

Overview of Atrium and Pella

Founded in 1977, Atrium Windows and Doors is based out of Dallas, Texas.

They manufacture a variety of different window types including double hung, sliders, casements, awnings, and picture models.

The majority of their windows feature vinyl construction for durability and low maintenance.

However, Atrium also offers fiberglass and composite windows.

Atrium touts their high-quality vinyl formula that resists fading, chalking, pitting, and warping even after years of exposure to the elements. Their proprietary vinyl also helps block ultraviolet rays. Most Atrium vinyl windows come with a limited lifetime warranty.

Pella was established in 1925 and is headquartered in Pella, Iowa. They have a broader selection of upscale window options that include vinyl, fiberglass, and wood models. Their wood choices include pine, oak, maple, cherry, and mahogany.

Pella is known for its innovative window designs that include things like between-the-glass blinds and built-in shades. Most Pella windows have a limited lifetime warranty that’s transferable to future homeowners.

Major Differences

There are a few major differences to note between Atrium and Pella:

Pricing – Pella windows come with higher price tags than Atrium. Their wood windows in particular can cost significantly more than vinyl or fiberglass. Atrium is better suited for homeowners on tighter budgets.
Window Types – Pella offers more window operating styles than Atrium. Casement, double hung, and sliding windows are available from both brands. However, Pella also manufactures specialty windows like bay and bow windows.
Materials – As mentioned, Pella provides more material options with various wood species. Atrium’s selection is primarily vinyl but also includes some fiberglass.
Energy Efficiency – Both brands offer windows that meet ENERGY STAR® requirements. However, Pella tends to edge out Atrium slightly when it comes to overall energy efficiency ratings.
Visual Appeal – Pella’s wood window styles take the cake when it comes to aesthetic appeal. Atrium windows are more modest in their designs.

Atrium Windows Pros and Cons

Atrium’s affordability and low maintenance requirements make it appealing to homeowners. But there are some downsides to weigh as well.

Atrium Pros

Budget-Friendly Pricing – Atrium consistently offers some of the lowest prices in the industry. Their basic vinyl models start under $200. Fiberglass options are still very reasonable.
Quality Vinyl Construction – Atrium’s durable vinyl formula resists weathering and requires little upkeep. No paint or stain needed. Their proprietary vinyl also blocks UV rays.
Variety of Styles – From single-hung and double-hung to sliding and casement windows, Atrium offers all of the most popular operating styles. Picture models are also available.
Limited Lifetime Warranty – A strong warranty provides peace of mind. Atrium covers the vinyl and hardware components with their limited lifetime warranty.
Energy Efficient Options – While not the most efficient, Atrium does offer windows that will meet ENERGY STAR requirements for most climates.

Atrium Cons

Lower Efficiency Ratings – Atrium’s standard vinyl models tend to rate lower in overall energy efficiency compared to leading brands. Upgrades are needed to meet requirements in colder regions.
More Prone to Drafts – Some homeowners note that Atrium’s vinyl windows allow more air leakage resulting in drafts. Proper installation is key.
Less Aesthetic Appeal – Atrium’s vinyl windows are attractive but have a more basic, undistinguished look. Those wanting elegance may be disappointed.
Shorter Hardware Warranty – Only a 10-year warranty on hardware is provided. Other brands often offer 20 years or more of coverage on moving parts.
Hit and Miss Customer Service – While some customers report prompt issue resolution, others have experienced long delays and unhelpful service. Inconsistency is an issue.

Also Read: Is Atrium 450 Series Windows Worth It?

Pella Windows Pros and Cons

Pella windows deliver beautiful aesthetics, innovation, and quality craftsmanship. But you’ll pay more for these benefits.

Pella Pros

Premium Styles and Materials – From pine to mahogany, Pella offers unparalleled visual appeal. Many designs feature between-the-glass shades or blinds.
Exceptional Energy Efficiency – Multiple panes of low-emissivity glass and insulating gases give Pella windows excellent efficiency. They exceed requirements.
Superior Weatherproofing – Pella’s advanced sealants, strong framing, and tight construction result in exceptional resistance to air and water infiltration.
Leading Warranties – All Pella windows have a limited lifetime warranty that’s transferable. And you get 20 years of coverage on the glass.
Great Customer Service – Pella earns high marks from nearly all customers when it comes to service and support. Their representatives are responsive and helpful.
Added Home Value – High-end Pella windows can help boost your home’s resale value. Their craftsmanship is recognized in the real estate market.

Pella Cons

Higher Price Points – There’s no getting around the fact that Pella windows come with premium price tags. Their wood models in particular can cost anywhere from 2 to 4 times as much as basic vinyl.
Some Condensation Issues – The exceptional seal of Pella windows occasionally results in temporary condensation between the panes as humidity escapes a home. Usually resolves itself.
Heavy Window Weight – Wood models, triple pane glass, and integrated blinds and shades add significant weight. Proper installation and structural reinforcement are a must.
Long Lead Times – The custom craftsmanship results in a several week or longer wait for some Pella windows after order placement. Basic vinyl lines tend to ship faster.
Ongoing Maintenance – Pella’s wood windows will require periodic recoating and restaining to maintain their elegant appearance over decades of use.

Atrium And Pella Windows: Which Is Better For You?

So when it comes time to decide between Atrium or Pella for your next window project, which brand should you select?

Here are a few key factors to help determine the right choice:

If budget is your top concern, Atrium is the clear value winner. Their low prices make window upgrades attainable for any homeowner. Just be prepared for basic styling.
If energy efficiency is most important because of cold winters or hot summers, Pella is the way to go. Their innovative designs result in exceptional energy savings.
If you want elegant windows that enhance your home’s beauty, Pella is definitely worth the investment. Atrium can’t match their upscale looks.
For low maintenance and durability, Atrium’s quality vinyl is hard to beat. Just opt for fiberglass if you live in an extreme climate.
For a smooth purchasing and installation process, Pella earns higher marks for customer service. Atrium can be hit or miss.

Also Read: Is Pella Windows Better Than Window Mart?

FAQ – Atrium and Pella Window Comparisons

Still trying to choose between Atrium or Pella? Here are answers to some of the most frequently asked questions about these two popular brands.

Does Atrium make good windows?

Yes, Atrium makes good quality vinyl windows that offer an affordable option for most homeowners. Their proprietary vinyl resists weathering, provides insulation, and requires minimal maintenance. Atrium windows meet energy standards in warmer climates. Just don’t expect top of the line efficiency or luxury features. Stick with Atrium if you prioritize price over all else.

What windows are comparable to Pella?

Some brands that offer similar quality and features as Pella include: Marvin Windows, Andersen Windows, Jeld-Wen Windows, Milgard Windows, Simonton Windows.
These companies provide elite design options, energy efficiency, strength, and durability that compare to Pella. They also occupy the high-end segment of the market regarding pricing. Budget-friendly brands can’t truly match what Pella offers overall.

Are Pella windows overpriced?

Pella windows come with premium price tags, especially their wood models. While expensive, most customers don’t feel they are overpriced when factoring in the exceptional craftsmanship, materials, WARRANTIES, efficiency ratings, and visual appeal. If your goal is to add beauty and value to your home for decades to come, Pella windows are worth the investment for many homeowners. However, those with tight budgets will likely find the prices too high for their needs.

Who is the best window company?

There is no definitive consensus on the very best window company overall. Several big brands dominate the high-end window market including: Pella, Marvin, Andersen, Milgard, Jeld-Wen, Simonton.
While Pella ranks consistently among the top window providers across various criteria, it’s wise to consider which traits — like cost, materials, or warranties — matter most to you. Comparing the strengths of brands like Pella and Atrium can help guide you to the ideal window for your particular home and budget. Consulting reviews and determining what past customers have valued is helpful during this major purchasing decision as well. There is no truly one size fits all window.

The Bottom Line

Replacing your home’s windows with quality new models from trusted brands like Atrium and Pella is a worthwhile investment that can enhance comfort, efficiency, beauty, and resale value. Carefully weigh the pros and cons of each company.

If first costs drive your decision making, Atrium provides quality vinyl windows at affordable prices. Their basic styling still offers curb appeal.

For premium performance and design with exceptional warranties, Pella is the leader in the high-end window market. Their versatility across materials and operating styles results in endless custom options.

Whichever you choose, be sure to get multiple quotes and speak to local window experts. An energy audit can also help determine the best replacement models to meet your home’s needs while maximizing energy savings over the long haul.

Investing in the right windows eventually pays for itself.