Aarke Vs. SodaStream: Which Sparkling Water Maker Wins My Kitchen Counter?

I’m a sparkling water fanatic, and I’ve spent countless hours fizzing up my own drinks at home. If you’re like me, you’ve probably eyed both Aarke and SodaStream machines, wondering which one deserves a spot in your kitchen.

In this article, I’ll walk you through my experience with both brands, comparing their features, performance, and quirks to help you decide which carbonator suits your lifestyle.

From design to functionality, I’ll break down the pros and cons, share a comparison table, and answer common questions to guide your choice.

A Brief Comparison Table

My Journey With Sparkling Water Makers

I’ve always loved the crisp bite of sparkling water. There’s something about those bubbles that makes hydration feel like a treat. Over the years, I’ve tried buying bottled seltzer, but the plastic waste and cost added up fast.

That’s when I turned to home carbonation. Aarke and SodaStream quickly became my top contenders, each promising to transform tap water into fizzy perfection.

I’ve used both extensively, and I’m here to share what I’ve learned about their design, performance, and value to help you pick the right one.

Design and Aesthetics: A Visual Showdown

• Aarke’s Scandinavian Elegance

When I first unboxed my Aarke Carbonator 3, I was struck by its sleek, stainless steel body.

It’s like a piece of modern art for your countertop. The minimalist design, with clean lines and a polished finish, screams sophistication.

Available in colors like Matte Black, Copper, and Gold, it’s a machine that doesn’t just make sparkling water—it elevates your kitchen’s vibe.

At 6.6 pounds, it feels sturdy, not flimsy, and its compact size (16.3 x 6 x 10.4 inches) fits neatly on my counter without hogging space.

The lever mechanism adds a tactile charm. It’s satisfying to pull, almost like operating a vintage soda fountain. But there’s a catch: the screw-in bottle connection can be a bit fiddly, especially if you’re in a rush.

Still, the premium materials and thoughtful design make it a standout for anyone who values aesthetics as much as function.

• SodaStream’s Practical Variety

SodaStream, on the other hand, takes a more utilitarian approach. I’ve tested models like the Terra, One Touch, and Duo, and each has its own personality.

The Terra, with its plastic and stainless steel mix, is lightweight (4.5 pounds) and comes in fun colors like Red and Blue. It’s not as chic as Aarke, but it’s approachable and blends into most kitchens without drawing too much attention.

The One Touch, which requires electricity, has a more modern look with its button-driven interface, but its plastic construction feels less luxurious. The Duo, with its glass and plastic bottle options, strikes a balance between style and practicality.

SodaStream’s snap-lock bottle system is a game-changer for ease of use—no twisting required, just click and go. If you’re after function over form, SodaStream’s designs are hard to beat.

Functionality: Fizzing Up the Details

• Aarke’s Manual Precision

The Aarke Carbonator 3 is all about control. Its manual lever lets me decide exactly how fizzy I want my water. A gentle pull gives a light sparkle, while a few firm pumps deliver a bold, Topo Chico-level fizz.

I love this flexibility, especially when I’m experimenting with different carbonation levels for cocktails or mocktails. The process is simple: fill the bottle with cold water, screw it into the machine, and pull the lever a few times. Done.

However, Aarke doesn’t include a CO2 cylinder, which was a surprise when I first bought it. In the U.S., finding compatible 60L cylinders can be a hassle, and I had to order one separately, adding to the initial cost.

The screw-in bottle system, while secure, takes a bit more effort than I’d like, especially compared to SodaStream’s snap-lock.

• SodaStream’s User-Friendly Approach

SodaStream machines are designed for simplicity.

The Terra’s push-button carbonation is straightforward—press a button, and you’re sparkling in seconds.

The snap-lock bottle system is a dream; it clicks into place without any twisting, making it ideal for quick use.

The One Touch takes it a step further with electric carbonation and preset fizz levels, which is great if you want consistency without thinking too much.

The Duo, with its glass bottle option, feels a bit more upscale and is perfect for serving at dinner parties.

All SodaStream models come with a CO2 cylinder, which is a huge plus for getting started right away.

However, the push-button systems on the Terra and Duo don’t offer the same granular control as Aarke’s lever, and the One Touch’s reliance on electricity means you’re tethered to an outlet.

Versatility: Bottles and Beyond

• Aarke’s Limited but Premium Options

Aarke’s Carbonator 3 primarily uses BPA-free PET bottles, but they’ve recently introduced a glass bottle option for their Pro model.

I appreciate the eco-friendly aspect of reusable bottles, and the PET bottle is durable and easy to clean.

However, Aarke’s compatibility is narrower—it only works with 60L CO2 cylinders, and you’re limited to Aarke-branded or select SodaStream bottles.

This can feel restrictive if you’re used to SodaStream’s broader ecosystem.

I also found that Aarke’s focus is squarely on water carbonation. If you’re hoping to carbonate juice or wine (like some other machines allow), you’ll be out of luck. It’s a purist’s machine, which suits me fine since I’m mostly after plain seltzer, but it might not satisfy everyone.

• SodaStream’s Flexible Ecosystem

SodaStream shines in versatility. Their machines work with a wide range of bottles, from 0.5-liter to 1-liter BPA-free plastic to glass carafes (on models like the Duo and Aqua Fizz).

The snap-lock system makes swapping bottles a breeze, and I love that I can keep multiple bottles chilled in the fridge for back-to-back carbonation sessions.

SodaStream also offers compatibility with both 60L and 130L CO2 cylinders, giving you more flexibility for heavy use. Plus, their machines are designed to handle flavored syrups, making it easy to whip up sodas or flavored seltzers.

While I’m a sparkling water purist, I’ve dabbled with their fruit drops, and they’re a fun way to mix things up.

Durability and Build Quality

• Aarke’s Premium Craftsmanship

The Aarke Carbonator 3 feels like it’s built to last. Its all-metal construction gives it a reassuring heft, and the stainless steel components resist wear and tear. I’ve dropped the drip tray once or twice (clumsy moments, we all have them), and it’s held up without a scratch.

Aarke’s focus on repairability is another plus—they encourage fixing rather than replacing, which aligns with my goal of reducing waste.

The downside? That premium build comes with a premium price tag, and the lack of an included CO2 cylinder feels like a nickel-and-dime move for such a high-end product. Still, if you’re willing to invest, the Carbonator 3 feels like a long-term companion.

• SodaStream’s Practical Durability

SodaStream’s machines, particularly the Terra and Duo, are durable but less luxurious.

The plastic-heavy construction on models like the Terra and Jet keeps costs down but doesn’t inspire the same confidence as Aarke’s metal body.

That said, I’ve used my Terra for over a year without issues, and the snap-lock mechanism shows no signs of wear.

The Duo’s metal accents and glass bottle option add a touch of durability, but it still doesn’t match Aarke’s premium feel.

SodaStream’s widespread availability of replacement parts and CO2 refills makes maintenance a breeze, which is a big win for practicality.

Price and Value: What’s Worth Your Money?

• Aarke’s Premium Price Point

The Aarke Carbonator 3 is undeniably expensive, often retailing around $250 or more. Add in the cost of a separate CO2 cylinder, and you’re looking at a significant upfront investment.

For me, the stunning design and precise carbonation control justify the cost, especially since I use it daily. But if you’re on a budget or don’t care about aesthetics, the price might feel steep.

• SodaStream’s Budget-Friendly Range

SodaStream offers options for every wallet. The Terra is a steal at around $100, and even the more advanced Duo and One Touch stay under $200. The included CO2 cylinder sweetens the deal, making SodaStream a better value for casual users or those new to home carbonation. If you’re looking to save money and still get reliable fizz, SodaStream’s got you covered.

Pros and Cons of Aarke And SodaStream

Aarke Carbonator 3

Pros

• Gorgeous stainless steel design elevates any kitchen.
• Manual lever offers precise control over carbonation levels.
• Compact and sturdy, built to last with repairable components.
• Compatible with select SodaStream bottles for some flexibility.

Cons

• High price tag, especially without an included CO2 cylinder.
• Screw-in bottle system is less convenient than snap-lock.
• Limited to 60L CO2 cylinders and water-only carbonation.
• Finding CO2 refills in the U.S. can be tricky.

SodaStream (Terra, One Touch, Duo)

Pros

• Budget-friendly options, with models starting at $100.
• Snap-lock bottle system is quick and user-friendly.
• Wide range of models, colors, and bottle types (plastic and glass).
• Included CO2 cylinder and broad refill availability.

Cons

• Plastic-heavy construction feels less premium.
• One Touch requires electricity, limiting portability.
• Push-button carbonation offers less control than Aarke’s lever.
• Some models lack the aesthetic appeal of Aarke.

My Experience With Aarke And SodaStream

I’ve been using both Aarke and SodaStream for over a year, and each has its moments.

With Aarke, I feel like a barista crafting the perfect fizz.

The lever is fun to use, and the machine’s sleek look makes me smile every time I see it.

But I’ll admit, screwing in the bottle gets old, and I’ve cursed a few times when I couldn’t find a CO2 refill locally.

SodaStream’s Terra is my go-to when I’m in a hurry.

The snap-lock bottle is a lifesaver, and I love that I can grab a CO2 cylinder at most big-box stores.

The One Touch is great for consistent fizz, but I don’t love being tied to a power outlet.

The Duo’s glass bottles are a nice touch for dinner parties, but the plastic components feel a bit cheap compared to Aarke.

Which One Should You Choose?

If you’re a design enthusiast who loves precise control and doesn’t mind spending more, Aarke’s Carbonator 3 is your match. It’s a statement piece that delivers excellent fizz, perfect for those who see their kitchen as an extension of their style.

But if you want affordability, versatility, and ease of use, SodaStream’s range—especially the Terra or Duo—is hard to beat. They’re practical, reliable, and backed by a robust ecosystem of bottles and refills.

For me, it’s a tie. I keep my Aarke on the counter for its looks and precision, but I reach for the SodaStream Terra when I need quick, no-fuss seltzer. Your choice depends on what matters most: style and control or convenience and value.

Also Read: Comparison of SodaStream ArtAnd Terra Sparkling Water Makers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Conclusion: Your Fizz, Your Way

Choosing between Aarke and SodaStream comes down to what you value in your sparkling water experience. I’ve shared my journey with both, from Aarke’s elegant lever to SodaStream’s practical snap-lock bottles.

Whether you’re drawn to Aarke’s premium craftsmanship or SodaStream’s budget-friendly versatility, both brands make it easy to enjoy fizzy drinks at home. You can’t go wrong, but think about your priorities—style or simplicity—and pick the one that fits your vibe.

So, grab a glass, carbonate some water, and let the bubbles brighten your day!